William A. Linn's "Story of the Mormons" Bk. 6b

THE STORY OF THE MORMONS

By William A. Linn

(1902)

Contents (With Links to All Chapters)

Bk. VI chapters on this web-page: 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | Index

Go back to: Page 534

[ 535 ]

BOOK VI
[continued]

CHAPTER XVII

AFTER THE "WAR"
WITH the return of the people to their homes, the peaceful avocations of life in Utah were resumed. The federal judges received assignments to their districts, and the other federal officers took possession of their offices. Chief Justice Eckles selected as his place of residence Camp Floyd, as General Johnston's camp was named; Judge Sinclair's district included Salt Lake City, and Judge Cradlebaugh's the southern part of the state.

Judge Cradlebaugh, who conceived it to be a judge's duty to see that crime was punished, took steps at once to secure indictments in connection with the notorious murders committed during the "Reformation," and we have seen in a former chapter with what poor results. He also personally visited the Mountain Meadows, talked with whites and Indians cognizant with the massacre, and, on affidavits sworn to before him, issued warrants for the arrest of Haight, Higbee, Lee, and thirty-four others as participants therein. In order to hold court with any prospect of a practical result, a posse of soldiers was absolutely necessary, even for the protection of witnesses; but Governor Cumming, true to the reputation he had secured as a Mormon ally, declared that he saw no necessity for such use of federal troops, and requested their removal from Provo, where the court was in session; and when the judge refused to grant his request, he issued a proclamation in which he stated that the presence of the military had a tendency "to disturb the peace and subvert the ends of justice." Before this dispute had proceeded farther, General Johnston received an order from Secretary Floyd, approved by Attorney General Black, directing that in future he should instruct his troops to act as a posse comitatus only on the written application of Governor Cumming. Thus did the church win one of its first victories after the reestablishment of "peace."

--------     536     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

An incident in Salt Lake City at this time might have brought about a renewal of the conflict between federal and Mormon forces. The engraver of a plate with which to print counterfeit government drafts, when arrested, turned state's evidence and pointed out that the printing of the counterfeits had been done over the "Deseret Store" in Salt Lake City, which was on Young's premises. United States Marshal Dotson secured the plate, and with it others, belonging to Young, on which Deseret currency had been printed. This seemed to bring the matter so close to Young that officers from Camp Floyd called on Governor Cumming to secure his cooperation in arresting Young should that step be decided on. The governor refused with indignation to be a party to what he called "creeping through walls," that is, what he considered a roundabout way to secure Young's arrest; and, when it became rumored in the city that General Johnston would use his troops without the governor's cooperation Cumming directed Wells, the commander of the Nauvoo Legion, who had so recently been in rebellion against the government, to hold his militia in readiness for orders. Wells is quoted by Bancroft as saying that he told Cumming, "We would not let them {the soldiers} come; that if they did come, they would never get out alive if we could help it."¹ The decision of the Washington authorities in favor of Governor Cumming as against the federal judges once more restored "peace." The only sufferer from this incident was Marshal Dotson, against whom Young, in his probate court, obtained a judgment of $2600 for injury to the Deseret currency plates, and a house belonging to Dotson, renting for $500 year, was sold to satisfy this judgment, and bought in by an agent of Young.

To complete the story of this forgery, it may be added that Brewer, the engraver who turned state's evidence, was shot down in Main Street, Salt Lake City, one evening, in company with J. Johnson, a gambler who had threatened to shoot a Mormon editor. A man who was a boy at the time gave J. H. Beadle the particulars of this double murder as he received it from the person who lighted a brazier to give the assassin a sure aim.² The coroner's jury the next day found that the men shot one another!

Soon all public attention throughout the country was centered
_________________________
¹ "History of Utah," p. 573, note.
² "Polygamy," p. 192.

--------     537                            AFTER THE "WAR"                                    --------

in the coming conflict in the Southern states. In May, 1860, the troops at Camp Floyd departed for New Mexico and Arizona, only a small guard being left under command of Colonel Cooke. In May, 1861, Governor Cumming left Salt Lake City for the east so quietly that most of the people there did not hear of his departure until they read it in the local newspapers. He soon after appeared in Washington, and after some delay obtained a pass which permitted his passage through the Confederate lines. When the Southern rebellion became a certainty, Colonel Cooke and his force were ordered to march to the East in the autumn, after selling vast quantities of stores in Camp Floyd, and destroying the supplies and ammunition which they could not take away. Such a slaughter of prices as then occurred was, perhaps, without precedent. It was estimated that goods costing $4,000,000 brought only $l00,000. Young had preached non-intercourse with the Gentile merchants who followed the army, but he could not lose so great an opportunity as this, when, for instance, flour costing $28.40 per sack sold for 52 cents, and he invested $4,000. "For years after," says Stenhouse, "the 'regulation blue pants' were more familiar to the eye, in the Mormon settlements, than the Valley Tan Quaker gray."

When Governor Cumming left the territory, the secretary, Francis H. Wooton, became acting governor. He made himself very offensive to the administration at Washington, and President Lincoln appointed Frank Fuller, of New Hampshire, secretary of the territory in his place, and Mr. Fuller proceeded at once to Salt Lake City, where he became acting governor. Later in the year the other federal offices in Utah were filled by the appointment of John W. Dawson, of Indiana, as governor, John F. Kinney as chief justice, and R. P. Flenniken and J. R. Crosby as associate justices.

The selection of Dawson as governor was something more than a political mistake. He was the editor and publisher of a party newspaper at Fort Wayne, Indiana, a man of bad morals, and a meddler in politics, who gave the Republican managers in his state a great deal of trouble. The undoubted fact seems to be that he was sent out to Utah on the recommendation of Indiana politicians of high rank, who wanted to get rid of him, and who gave no attention whatever to the requirements of his office.

--------     538     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

Arriving at his post early in December, 1861, the new governor incurred the ill will of the Mormons almost immediately by vetoing a bill for a state convention passed by the territorial legislature, and a memorial to Congress in favor of the admission of the territory as a state (which Acting Governor Fuller approved). They were very glad, therefore, to take advantage of any mistake he might make; and he almost at once gave them their opportunity, by making improper advances to a woman whom he had employed to do some work. She, as Dawson expressed it to one of his colleagues, "was fool enough to tell of it," and Dawson, learning immediately that the Mormons meditated a severe vengeance, at once made preparations for his departure.

The Deseret News of January 1, 1862, in an editorial on the departure of the governor, said that for eight or ten days he had been confined to his room and reported insane; that, when he left, he took with him his physician and four guards, "to each of whom, as reported last evening, $100 is promised in the event that they guard him faithfully, and prevent his being killed or becoming qualified for the office of chamberlain in the King's palace, till he shall have arrived at and passed the eastern boundary of the territory." After indicating that he had committed an offence against a lady which, under the common law, if enforced, "would have caused him to have bitten the dust," the News added: "Why he selected the individuals named for his bodyguard no one with whom we have conversed has been able to determine. That they will do him justice, and see him safely out of the territory, there can be no doubt."

The hints thus plainly given were carried out. Beadle's account says, "He was waylaid in Weber Canon, and received shocking and almost emasculating injuries from three Mormon lads."¹ Stenhouse says: "He was dreadfully maltreated by some Mormon rowdies who assumed, 'for the fun of the thing,' to be the avengers of an alleged insult. Governor Dawson had been betrayed into an offence, and his punishment was heavy."² Mrs. Waite says that the Mormons laid a trap for the governor, as they had done for Steptoe; but the evidence indicates that, in Dawson's case, the victim was himself to blame for the opportunity he gave.

Stenhouse says that the Mormon authorities were very angry
_________________________
¹ "Polygamy," p. 195.
² "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 592.

--------     539                            AFTER THE "WAR"                                    --------

because of the aggravated character of the punishment dealt out to the governor, as they simply wanted him sent away disgraced, and that they had all his assailants shot. This is practically confirmed by the Mormon historian Whitney, who says that one of the assailants was a relative of the woman insulted, and the others "merely drunken desperadoes and robbers who," he explains, "were soon afterward arrested for their cowardly and brutal assault upon the fleeing official. One of them, Lot Huntington, was shot by Deputy Sheriff O. P. Rockwell {so often Young's instrument in such cases} on January 26, in Rush Valley, while attempting to escape from the officers, and two others, John P. Smith and Moroni Clawson, were killed during a similar attempt next day by the police of Salt Lake City. Their confederates were tried and duly punished." ¹

The departure of Governor Dawson left the executive office again in charge of Secretary Fuller. Early in 1862 the Indians threatened the overland mail route, and Fuller, having received instruction from Montgomery Blair to keep the route open at all hazards, called for thirty men to serve for thirty days. These were supplied by the Mormons. In the following April, the Indian troubles continuing, Governor Fuller, Chief Justice Kinney, and officers of the Overland Mail and Pacific Telegraph Companies united in a letter to Secretary Stanton asking that Superintendent of Indian Affairs Doty be authorized to raise a regiment of mounted rangers in the territory, with officers appointed by him, to keep open communication. These petitioners, observes Tullidge, "had overrated the federal power in Utah, as embodied in themselves, for such a service, when they overlooked ex-Governor Young" and others. ² Young had no intention of permitting any kind of a federal force to supplant his Legion. Heat once telegraphed to the Utah Delegate in Washington that the Utah militia (alias Nauvoo Legion) were competent to furnish the necessary protection. As a result of this presentation of the matter, Adjutant General L. L. Thomas, on April 28, addressed a reply to the petition for protection, not to any of the federal officers in Utah, but to "Mr. Brigham Young," saying, " By express direction of the President of the United States you are hereby authorized to raise,
_________________________
¹ "History of Utah," Vol. II, p. 38.
² Tullidge's "History of Salt Lake City," p. 252.

--------     540     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

arm, and equip one company of cavalry for ninety days' service."¹ The order for carrying out these instructions was placed by the head of the Nauvoo Legion, "General" Wells -- who ordered the burning of the government trains in 1857 -- in the hands of Major Lot Smith, who carried out that order!

Judges Flenniken and Crosby took their departure from the territory a month later than Dawson, and Thomas J. Drake of Michigan and Charles B. Waite of Illinois² were named as their successors, and on March 31 Stephen S. Harding of Milan, Indiana, a lawyer, was appointed governor. The new officers arrived in July.

At this time the Mormons were again seeking admission for the State of Deseret. They had had a constitution prepared for submission to Congress, had nominated Young for governor and Kimball for lieutenant governor, and the legislature, in advance, had chosen W. H. Hooper and George Q. Cannon the United States senators. But Utah was not then admitted, while, on the other hand, an anti-polygamy bill (to be described later) was passed, and signed by President Lincoln on July 2.

During the month preceding the arrival of Governor Harding, another tragedy had been enacted in the territory. Among the church members was a Welshman named Joseph Morris, who became possessed of the belief (which, as we have seen, had afflicted brethren from time to time) that he was the recipient of "revelations." One of these "revelations" having directed him to warn Young that he was wandering from the right course, he did this in person, and received a rebuke so emphatic that it quite overcame him. He betook himself, therefore, to a place called Kington Fort, on the Weber River, thirty-five miles north of Salt Lake City, and there he found believers in his prophetic gifts in the local Bishop, and quite a settlement of men and women, almost all foreigners. Young's refusal to satisfy the demand for published "revelations" gave some standing to a fanatic like Morris, who professed to supply that long-felt want, and he was
_________________________
¹ Vol. II, Series 3, p. 27, War of the Rebellion, official records.
² After leaving Utah Judge Waite was appointed district attorney for Idaho, was elected to Congress, and published "A History of the Christian Religion," and other books. His wife, author of "The Mormon Prophet," was a graduate of Oberlin College and of the Union College of Law in Chicago, a member of the Illinois bar, founder of the Chicago Law Times, and manager of the publishing firm of C. W. Waite & Co.

--------     541                            AFTER THE "WAR"                                    --------

so prolific in his gift that three clerks were required to write down what was revealed to him. Among his announcements were the date of the coming of Christ and the necessity of "consecrating" their property in a common fund. Having made a mistake in the date selected for Christ's appearance, the usual apostates sprang up, and, when they took their departure, they claimed the right to carry with them their share of the common effects. In the dispute that ensued, the apostates seized some Morrisite grain on the way to mill, and the Morrisites captured some apostates, and took them prisoners to Kington Fort.

Out of these troubles came the issue of a writ by Judge Kinney for the release of the prisoners, the defiance of this writ by the Morrisites, and a successful appeal to the governor for the use of the militia to enable the marshal to enforce the writ. On the morning of June 13 the Morrisites discovered an armed force, in command of General R. T. Burton, the marshal's chief deputy, on the mountain that overlooked their settlement, and received from Burton an order to surrender in thirty minutes. Morris announced a "revelation," declaring that the Lord would not allow his people to be destroyed. When the thirty minutes had expired, without further warning the Mormon force fired on the Morrisites with a cannon, killing two women outright, and sending the others to cover. But the devotees were not weak-hearted. For three days they kept up a defence, and it was not until their ammunition was exhausted that they raised a white flag. When Burton rode into their settlement and demanded Morris's surrender, that fanatic replied, "Never." Burton at once shot him dead, and then badly wounded John Banks, an English convert and a preacher of eloquence, who had joined Morris after rebelling against Young's despotism. Banks died "suddenly" that evening. Burton finished his work by shooting two women, one of whom dared to condemn his shooting of Morris and Banks, and the other for coming up to him crying.¹

The bodies of Morris and Banks were carried to Salt Lake City and exhibited there. No one -- President of the church or federal officer -- took any steps at that time to bring their murderers to justice. Sixteen years later District Attorney Van Zile
_________________________
¹ For accounts of this slaughter, see "Rocky Mountain Saints," pp. 593-606, and Beadle's "Life in Utah," pp. 413-420.

--------     542     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

tried Burton for this massacre, but the verdict was acquittal, as it has been in all these famous cases except that of John D. Lee.

Ninety-three Morrisites, few of whom could speak English, were arraigned before Judge Kinney and placed under bonds. In the following March seven of the Morrisites were convicted of killing members of the posse, and sentenced by Judge Kinney to imprisonment for from five to fifteen years each, while sixty-six others were fined $100 each for resisting the posse. Governor Harding immediately pardoned ail the accused, in response to a numerously signed petition. Beadle says that Bishop Wooley advised the governor to be careful about granting these pardons, as "our people feel it would be an outrage, and if it is done, they might proceed to violence;" but that Bill Hickman, the Danite captain, rode thirty miles to sign the petition, saying that he was "one Mormon who was not afraid to sign." The grand jury that had indicted the Morrisites made a presentment to Judge Kinney, in which they said, "We present his Excellency Stephen S. Harding, governor of Utah, as we would an unsafe bridge over a dangerous stream, jeopardizing the lives of all those who pass over it; or as we would a pestiferous cesspool in our district, breathing disease and death." And the chief justice assured this jury that they addressed him "in no spirit of malice," and asked them to accept his thanks "for your cooperation in the support of my efforts to maintain and enforce the law." It is to the credit of the powers at Washington that this judge was soon afterward removed.¹
_________________________
¹ Even the Mormon historian has only this to say on this subject: "Of the relative merit or demerit of the action of the United States and territorial authorities concerned in the Morrisite affair the historian does not presume to touch, further than to present the record itself and its significance." -- Tullidge, "History of Salt Lake City," p. 320.

-------- [ 543 ] --------

CHAPTER XVIII.

ATTITUDE OF THE MORMONS DURING THE SOUTHERN REBELLION
THE attitude of the Mormons toward the government at the outbreak of hostilities with the Southern states was distinctly disloyal. The Deseret News of January 2, 1861, said, "The indications are that the breach which has been effected between the North and South will continue to widen, and that two or more nations will be formed out of the fragmentary portions of the once glorious republic." The Mormons in England had before that been told in the Millennial Star (January 28, 1860) that "the Union is now virtually destroyed." The sermons in Salt Lake City were of the same character. "General" Wells told the people on April 6, 1861, that the general government was responsible for their expulsion from Missouri and Illinois, adding: "So far as we are concerned, we should have been better without a government than such a one. I do not think there is a more corrupt government upon the face of the earth."¹ Brigham Young on the same day said: "Our present President, what is his strength? It is like a rope of sand, or like a rope made of water. He is as weak as water.... I feel disgraced in having been born under a government that has so little power, disposition and influence for truth and right. Shame, shame on the rulers of this nation. I feel myself disgraced to hail such men as my countrymen."²

Elder G. A. Smith, on the same occasion, railing against the non-Mormon clergy, said, "Mr. Lincoln now is put into power by that priestly influence; and the presumption is, should he not find his hands full by the secession of the Southern States, the spirit of priestly craft would force him, in spite of his good wishes and
_________________________
¹ Journal of Discourses, Vol. VIII, pp. 373-374.
² Ibid., Vol. IX, p. 4.

--------     544     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

intentions, to put to death, if it was in his power, every man that believes in the divine mission of Joseph Smith."¹ On August 31, 1862, Young quoted Smith's prediction of a rebellion beginning in South Carolina, and declared that "the nation that has slain the prophet of God will be broken in pieces like a potter's vessel," boasting that the Mormon government in Utah was "the best earthly government that was ever framed by man."

Tullidge, discussing in 1876 the attitude of the Mormon church toward the South, said: --

"With the exception of the slavery question and the policy of secession, the South stood upon the same ground that Utah had stood upon just previously.... And here we reach the heart of the Mormon policy and aims. Secession is not in it. Their issues are all inside the Union. The Mormon prophecy is that that people are destined to save the Union and preserve the constitution.... The North, which had just risen to power through the triumph of the Republican party, occupied the exact position toward the South that Buchanan's administration had held toward Utah. And the salient points of resemblance between the two cases were so striking that Utah and the South became radically associated in the Chicago platform that brought the Republican party into office. Slavery and polygamy -- these 'twin relics of barbarism' -- were made the two chief planks of the party platform. Yet neither of these were the real ground of the contest. It continues still, and some of the soundest men of the times believe that it will be ultimately referred in a revolution so general that nearly every man in America will become involved in the action.... The Mormon view of the great national controversy, then, is that the Southern States should have done precisely what Utah did, and placed themselves on the defensive ground of their rights and institutions as old as the Union. Had they placed themselves under the political leadership of Brigham Young, they would have triumphed, for their cause was fundamentally right; their secession alone was the national crime." ²

Knowledge of the spirit which animated the Saints induced the Secretary of War to place them under military supervision, and in May, 1862, the Third California Infantry and a part of the Second California Cavalry were ordered to Utah. The commander of this force was Colonel P. E. Connor, who had a fine record in the Mexican War, and who was among the first, at the outbreak of the Rebellion, to tender his services to the government in California, where he was then engaged in business. On assuming command of the military district of Utah, which included Utah and Nevada, Colonel
_________________________
¹ Journal of Discourses, Vol. IX, p. 18.
² Tullidge's "Life of Brigham Young," Chap. 24.

--------               DURING THE SOUTHERN REBELLION               545   --------

Connor issued an order directing commanders of posts, camps, and detachments to arrest and imprison, until they took the oath of allegiance, "all persons who from this date shall be guilty of uttering treasonable sentiments against the government," adding, "Traitors shall not utter treasonable sentiments in this district with impunity, but must seek some more genial soil, or receive the punishment they so richly deserve."

When Connor's force arrived at Fort Crittenden (the Camp Floyd of General Johnston), the Mormons supposed that it would make its camp there. Persons having a pecuniary interest in there occupation of the old site, where they wanted to sell to the government the buildings they had bought for a song, tried hard to induce Colonel Connor to accept their view, even warning him of armed Mormon opposition to his passage through Salt Lake City. But he was not a man to be thus deterred. Among the rumors that reached him was one that Bill Hickman, the Danite chief, was offering to bet $500 in Salt Lake City that the colonel could not cross the river Jordan. Colonel Connor is said to have sent back the reply that he "would cross the river Jordan if hell yawned below him."

On Saturday, October 18, Connor marched twenty miles toward the Mormon capital, and the next day crossed the Jordan at 2 P. M., without finding a person in sight on the eastern shore. The command, knowing that the Nauvoo Legion outnumbered them vastly, and ignorant of the real intention of the Mormon leaders, advanced with every preparation to meet resistance. They were, as an accompanying correspondent expressed it, "six hundred miles of sand from reinforcements." The conciliatory policy of so many federal officers in Utah would have induced Colonel Connor to march quietly around the city, and select some place for his camp where it would not offend Mormon eyes. What he did do was to halt his command when the city was two miles distant, form his column with an advance guard of cavalry and a light battery, the infantry and commissary wagons coming next, and in this order, to the bewilderment of the Mormon authorities, march into the principal street, with his two bands playing, to Emigrants' Square, and so to Governor Harding's residence.

The only United States flag displayed on any building that day was the governor's. The sidewalks were packed with men, women,

--------     546     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

and children, but not a cheer was heard. In front of the governor's residence the battalion was formed in two lines, and the governor, standing in the buggy in which he had ridden out to meet them, addressed them, saying that their mission was one of peace and security, and urging them to maintain the strictest discipline. The troops, Colonel Connor leading, gave three cheers for the country and the flag, and three for Governor Harding, and then took up their march to the slope at the base of Wahsatch Mountain, where the Camp Douglas of to-day is situated. This camp was in sight of the Mormon city, and Young's residence was in range of its guns. Thus did Brigham's will bend before the quiet determination of a government officer who respected his government's dignity.

But the Mormon spirit was to be still further tested. On December 8 Governor Harding read his first message to the territorial legislature. It began with a tribute to the industry and enterprise of the people; spoke of the progress of the war, and of the application of the territory for statehood, and in this connection said, "I am sorry to say that since my sojourn amongst you I have heard no sentiments, either publicly or privately expressed, that would lead me to believe that much sympathy is felt by any considerable number of your people in favor of the government of the United States, now struggling for its very existence." He declared that the demand for statehood should not be entertained unless it was "clearly shown that there is a sufficient population" and "that the people are loyal to the federal government and the laws." He recommended the taking of a correct census to settle the question of population.

All these utterances were gall and wormwood to a body of Mormon lawmakers, but worse was to come. Congress having passed an act "to prevent and punish the practice of polygamy in the territories," the governor naturally considered it his duty to call attention to the matter. Prevising that he desired to do so "in no offensive manner or unkind spirit," he pointed out that the practice was founded on no territorial law, resting merely on custom; and laid, down the principle that "no community can happily exist with an institution so important as that of marriage wanting in all those qualities that make it homogeneal with institutions and laws of neighboring civilized countries having the same spirit." He spoke of the marriage of a mother and her daughter to the same man as

--------               DURING THE SOUTHERN REBELLION               547   --------

"no less a marvel in morals than in matters of taste," and warned them against following the recommendation of high church authorities that the federal law be disregarded. This message, according to the Mormon historian, was "an insult offered to their representatives."¹

These representatives resented the "insult " by making no reference in the journal to the reading of the message, and by failing to have it printed. When this was made known in Washington, the Senate, on January 16, 1863, called for a report by the Committee on Territories concerning the suppression of the message, and they got one from its chairman, Benjamin Wade, pointing out that Utah Territory was in the control of "a sort of Jewish theocracy," affording "the first exhibition, within the limits of the United States, of a church ruling the state," and declaring that the governor's message contained "nothing that should give offence to any legislature willing to be governed by the laws of morality," closing with a recommendation that the message be printed by Congress. The territorial legislature adjourned on January 16 without sending to Governor Harding for his approval a single appropriation bill, and the next day the so-called legislature of the State of Deseret met and received a message from the state governor, Brigham Young.

Next the new federal judges came under Mormon displeasure. We have seen the conflict of jurisdiction existing between the federal and the so-called probate courts and their officers. Judge Waite perceived the difficulties thus caused as soon as he entered upon his duties, and he sent to Washington an act giving the United States marshal authority to select juries for the federal courts, taking from the probate courts jurisdiction in civil actions, and leaving them a limited criminal jurisdiction subject to appeal to the federal court, and providing for a reorganization of the militia under the federal governor. Bernhisel and Hooper sent home immediate notice of the arrival of this bill in Washington.

Now, indeed, it was time for Brigham to "bend his finger." If a governor could openly criticise polygamy, and a judge seek to undermine Young's legal and military authority, without a protest, his days of power were certainly drawing to a close. Accordingly, a big mass-meeting was held in Salt Lake City on March 3, 1863, "for the purpose of investigating certain acts of several of the United
_________________________
¹ Tullidge's "History of Salt Lake City," p. 305.

--------     548     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

States officials in the territory." Speeches were made by John Taylor and Young, in which the governor and judges were denounced.¹ A committee was appointed to ask the governor and two judges to resign and leave the territory, and a petition was signed requesting President Lincoln to remove them, the first reason stated being that "they are strenuously endeavoring to create mischief, and stir up strife between the people of the territory and the troops in Camp Douglas." The meeting then adjourned, the band playing the "Marseillaise."

The committee, consisting of John Taylor, J. Clinton, and Orson Pratt, called on the governor and the judges the next morning, and met with a flat refusal to pay any attention to the mandate of the meeting. "You may go back and tell your constituents," said Governor Harding, "that I will not resign my office, and will not leave this territory, until it shall please the President to recall me. I will not be driven away. I may be in danger in staying, but my purpose is fixed." Judge Drake told the committee that he had a right to ask Congress to pass or amend any law, and that it was a special insult for him, a citizen, to be asked by Taylor, a foreigner, to leave any part of the Republic. "Go back to Brigham Young, your master," said he, "that embodiment of sin, shame, and disgust, and tell him that I neither fear him, nor love him, nor hate him -- that I utterly despise him. Tell him, whose tools and tricksters you are, that I did not come here by his permission, and that I will not go away at his desire nor by his direction.... A horse thief or a murderer has, when arrested, a right to speak in court; and, unless in such capacity or under such circumstances, don't you even dare to speak to me again." Judge Waite simply declined to resign because to do so would imply "either that I was sensible of having done something wrong, or that I was afraid to remain at my post and perform my duty."²

As soon as the action of the Mormon mass-meeting became known at Camp Douglas, all the commissioned officers there signed a counter petition to President Lincoln, "as an act of duty we owe our government," declaring that the charge of inciting trouble between the people and the troops was "a base and unqualified falsehood," that the accused officers had been "true and
_________________________
¹ Reported in Mrs. Waite's "Mormon Prophet," pp. 98-102.
² Text of replies in Mrs. Waite's "Mormon Prophet," pp. 107-109.

--------               DURING THE SOUTHERN REBELLION               549   --------

faithful to the government," and that there was no good reason for their removal.

Excitement in Salt Lake City now ran high. Young, in a violent harangue in the Tabernacle on March 8, after declaring his loyalty to the government, said, "Is there anything that could be asked that we would not do? Yes. Let the present administration ask us for a thousand men, or even five hundred, and I'd see them d -- d first, and then they could not have them. What do you think of that?' (Loud cries of 'Good, Good,' and great applause.)"¹

Young expected arrest, and had a signal arranged by which the citizens would rush to his support if this was attempted. A false alarm of this kind was given on March 9, and in an hour two thousand armed men were assembled around his house.² Steptoe, who in an earlier year had declined the governorship of the territory and petitioned for Young's reappointment, took credit for what followed in an article in the Overland Monthly for December, 1896. Being at Salt Lake City at the time, he suggested to Wells and other leaders that they charge Young with the crime of polygamy before one of the magistrates, and have him arraigned and admitted to bail, in order to place him beyond the reach of the military officers. The affidavit was sworn to before the compliant Chief Justice Kinney by Young's private secretary, was served by the territorial marshal, and Young was released in $5000 bail. Colonel Connor was informed of this arrest before he arrived in the city, and retraced his steps; the citizens dispersed to their homes; the grand jury found no indictment against Young, and in due time he was discharged from his recognizance.

In the meantime," says a Mormon chronicler, "our 'outside' friends in this city telegraphed to those interested in the mail³ and
_________________________
¹ Correspondence of the Chicago Tribune.
² "On the inside of the high walls surrounding Brigham's premises scaffolding was hastily erected in order to enable the militia to fire down upon the passing volunteers. The houses on the route which occupied a commanding position where an attack could be made upon the troops were taken possession of, and the small cannon brought out." -- "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 604."
³ The first Pony Express left Sacramento and St. Joseph, Missouri, on April 3, 1860. Major General M. B. Hazen in an official letter dated February, 1807 (House Misc. Doc. No. 75, 2d Session, 39th Congress), said: "Ben Holiday I believe to be the only outsider acceptable to those people, and to benefit himself I believe he would throw the whole weight of his influence in favor of Mormonism. By the terms of his contract to

--------     550     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

telegraph lines that they must work for the removal of the troops, Governor Harding, and Judges Waite and Drake, otherwise there would be 'difficulty,' and the mail and telegraph lines would be destroyed. Their moneyed interest has given them great energy in our behalf."¹ This "work" told Governor Harding was removed, leaving the territory on June 11 and, as proof that this was due to "work" and not to his own incapacity, he was made Chief Justice of Colorado Territory.² With him were displaced Chief Justice Kinney and Secretary Fuller.³ Judges Waite and Drake wrote to the President that it would take the support of five thousand men to make the federal courts in Utah effective. Waite resigned in the summer of 1863. Drake remained, but his court did practically no business.

Lincoln's policy, as he expressed it then, was, "I will let the Mormons alone if they will let me alone."⁴ He had war enough on his hands without seeking any diversion in Utah. J. D. Doty, the superintendent of Indian affairs, succeeded Harding as governor, Amos Reed of Wisconsin became secretary, and John Titus of Philadelphia chief justice. Affairs in Utah now became more quiet. General Connor (he was made a brigadier general for his service in the Bear River Indian campaign in 1862-1863) yielded nothing to Mormon threats or demands. A periodical called the Union Vidette, published by his force, appeared in November, 1863, and in it was printed a circular over his name, expressing belief in the existence of rich veins of gold, silver, copper, and other metals in the territory, and promising the fullest protection to miners and prospectors; and the beginning of the mining interests there dated from the picking up of a piece of ore by a lady member of the camp while attending a
_________________________
carry the mails from the Missouri to Utah, all papers and pamphlets for the news-dealers, not directed to subscribers, are thrown out. It looks very much like a scheme to keep light out of that country, nowhere so much needed."
¹ D. O. Calder's letter to George Q. Cannon, March 13, 1863, in Millennial Star.
² "Every attempt was made to seduce him from the path of duty, not omitting the same appliances which had been brought to bear upon Steptoe and Dawson, but all in vain." -- "The Mormon Prophet," p. 109.
³ Whitney, the Mormon historian, says that while the President was convinced that Harding was not the right man for the place," he doubtless believed that there was more or less truth in the charges of 'subserviency' to Young made by local anti-Mormons against Chief Justice Kinney and Secretary Fuller. He therefore removed them as well." -- "History of Utah," Vol. II, p. 103.
⁴ Young's letter to Cannon, "History of Salt Lake City," p. 325.

--------               DURING THE SOUTHERN REBELLION               551   --------

picnic party. Although the Mormons had discouraged mining as calculated to cause a rush of non-Mormon residents, they did not show any special resentment to the general's policy in this respect. With the increasing evidence that the Union cause would triumph, the church turned its face toward the federal government. We find, accordingly, a union of Mormons and Camp Douglas soldiers in the celebration of Union victories on March 4, 1865, with a procession and speeches, and, when General Connor left to assume command of the Department of the Platte, a ball in his honor was given in Salt Lake City; and at the time of Lincoln's assassination church and government officers joined in services in the Tabernacle, and the city was draped in mourning.

-------- [ 552 ] --------

CHAPTER XIX

EASTERN VISITORS TO SALT LAKE CITY -- UNPUBLISHED MURDERS
IN June, 1865, a distinguished party from the East visited Salt Lake City, and their visit was not without public significance. It included Schuyler Colfax, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Lieutenant Governor Bross of Illinois, Samuel Bowles, editor of the Springfield (Massachusetts) Republican, and A. D. Richardson of the staff of the New York Tribune. Crossing the continent was still effected by stage-coach at that time, and the Mormon capital had never been visited by civilians so well known and so influential. Mr. Colfax had stated publicly that President Lincoln, a short time before his death, had asked him to make a thorough investigation of territorial matters, and his visit was regarded as semi-official. The city council formally tendered to the visitors the hospitality of the city, and Mr. Bowles wrote that the Speaker's reception "was excessive if not oppressive."

In an interview between Colfax and Young, during which the subject of polygamy was brought up by the latter, he asked what the government intended to do with it, now that the slavery question was out of the way. Mr. Colfax replied with the expression of a hope that the prophets of the church would have a new "revelation" which would end the practice, pointing out an example in the course of Missouri and Maryland in abolishing slavery, without waiting for action by the federal government. "Mr. Young," says Bowles, "responded quietly and frankly that he should readily welcome such a revelation; that polygamy was not in the original book of the Mormons; that it was not an essential practice in the church, but only a privilege and a duty, under special command of God."¹

It is worth while to note Mr. Bowles's summing up of his observations
_________________________
¹ "Across the Continent," p. 111.

--------             EASTERN VISITORS TO SALT LAKE CITY             553   --------

of Mormondom during this visit. "The result," he wrote, "of the whole experience has been to increase my appreciation of the value of their material progress and development to the nation; to evoke congratulations to them and to the country for the wealth they have created, and the order, frugality, morality (sic), and industry they have organized in this remote spot in our continent; to excite wonder at the perfection of their church system, the extent of its ramifications, the sweep of its influence, and to enlarge my respect for the personal sincerity and character of many of the leaders in the organization."¹ These were the expressions of a leading journalist, thought worthy to be printed later in book form, on a church system and church officers about which he had gathered his information during a few hours' visit, and concerning which he was so fundamentally ignorant that he called their Bible -- whose title is, "Book of Mormon" -- "book of the Mormons!" It is reasonably certain that he had never read Smith's "revelations," doubtful if he was acquainted with even the framework of the Mormon Bible, and probable that he was wholly ignorant of the history of their recent "Reformation." Many a profound opinion of Mormonism has been founded on as little opportunity for accurate knowledge.²

The Eastern visitors soon learned, however, how little intention the Mormon leaders had to be cajoled out of polygamy. Before Mr. Bowles's book was published, he had to add a supplement, in which he explained that "since our visit to Utah in June, the leaders among the Mormons have repudiated their professions of loyalty to the government, and denied any disposition to yield the issue of polygamy." Tullidge sneers at Colfax "for entertaining for a while the pretty plan" of having the Mormons give up polygamy as the Missourians did slavery. The Deseret News, soon after the Colfax party left the territory, expressed the real Mormon view on this subject, saying: --
_________________________
¹ "Across the Continent," p. 106.
² As another illustration of the value of observations by such transient students may be cited the following, from Sir Charles Wentworth Dilke's "Greater Britain," Vol. I, p. 148: "Brigham's deeds have been those of a sincere man. His bitterest opponents cannot dispute the fact that, in 1844, when Nauvoo was about to be deserted owing to attacks by a ruffianly mob, Brigham Young rushed to the front and took command. To be a Mormon leader was then to be the leader of an outcast people, with a price set on his head, in a Missouri country in which almost every man who was not a Mormon was by profession an assassin."

--------     554     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

"As a people we view every revelation from the Lord as sacred. Polygamy was none of our seeking. It came to us from Heaven, and we recognized it, and still do, the voice of Him whose right it is not only to teach us, but to dictate and teach all men.... They {Gentiles} talk of revelations given, and of receiving counter revelations to forbid what has been commanded, as if man was the sole author, originator, and designer of them.... Do they wish to brand a whole people with the foul stigma of hypocrisy, who, from their leaders to the last converts that have made the dreary journey to these mountain wilds for their faith, have proved their honesty of purpose and deep sincerity of faith by the most sublime sacrifices? Either that is the issue of the irreasoning, or they imagine that we serve and worship the most accommodating Deity ever dreamed of in the wildest vagaries of the most savage polytheist."

This was a perfectly consistent statement of the Mormon position, a simple elaboration of Young's declaration that, to give up belief in Smith as a prophet, and in his "revelations," would be to give up their faith. Just as truly, any later "revelation," repealing the one concerning polygamy, must be either a pretence or a temporary expedient, in orthodox Mormon eyes. The Mormons date the active crusade of the government against polygamy from the return of the Colfax party to the East, holding that this question did not enter into the early differences between them and the government.¹

In the year following Colfax's visit, there occurred in Utah two murders which attracted wide notice, and which called attention once more to the insecurity of the life of any man against whom the finger of the church was crooked. The first victim was O. N. Brassfield, a non-Mormon, who had the temerity to marry, on March 20, 1866, the second polygamous wife of a Mormon while the husband was in Europe on a mission. As he was entering his house in Salt Lake City, on the third day of the following month, he was shot dead. An order that had been given to disband the volunteer troops still remaining in the territory was countermanded from Washington, and General Sherman, then commander of that department, telegraphed to Young that he hoped to hear of no more murders of Gentiles in Utah, intimating that, if he did, it would be easy to reenlist some of the recently discharged volunteers and march them through the territory.

The second victim was Dr. J. King Robinson, a young man who had come to Utah as assistant surgeon of the California volunteers,
_________________________
¹ Tullidge's "History of Salt Lake City," p. 358.

--------             EASTERN VISITORS TO SALT LAKE CITY             555   --------

married the daughter of a Mormon whose widow and daughters had left the church, and taken possession of the land on which were some well-known warm springs, with the intention of establishing there a sanitarium. The city authorities at once set up a claim to the warm springs property, a building Dr. Robinson had erected there was burned, and, as he became aggressive in asserting his legal rights, he was called out one night, ostensibly to set a broken leg, knocked down, and shot dead. The audacity of this crime startled even the Mormons, and the opinion has been expressed that nothing more serious than a beating had been intended. There was an inquest before a city alderman, at which some non-Mormon lawyers and judges Titus and McCurdy were asked to assist. The chief feature of this hearing was the summing up by Ex-Governor J. B. Weller, of California, in which he denounced such murders, asked if there was not an organized influence which prevented the punishment of their perpetrators, and confessed that the prosecution had not been permitted "to lift the veil, and show the perpetrators of this horrible murder."¹

General W. B. Hazen, in his report of February, 1867, said of these victims:

"There is no doubt of their murder from Mormon church influences, although I do not believe by direct command. Principles are taught in their churches which would lead to such murders. I have earnestly to recommend that a list be made of the Mormon leaders, according to their importance, excepting Brigham Young, and that the President of the United States require the commanding officer at Camp Douglas to arrest and send to the state's prison at Jefferson City, Mo., beginning at the head of the list, man for man here after killed as these men were, to be held until the real perpetrators of the deed, with evidence for their conviction, be given up. I believe Young for the present necessary for us there"²

Had this policy been adopted, Mormon prisoners would soon have started East, for very soon afterward three other murders of the same character occurred, although the victims were not so prominent.³ Chief Justice Titus incurred the hatred of the Mormons by determined, if futile, efforts to bring offenders in such cases to justice, and to show their feeling they sent him a nightgown ten feet long, at the hands of a negro.
_________________________
¹ Text in "Rocky Mountain Saints," Appendix I.
² Mis. House Doc. No. 75, 2d Session, 39th Congress.
³ See note 70, p. 628, Bancroft's "History of Utah."

--------     556     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

When, in July, 1869, a delegation from Illinois, that included Senator Trumbull, Governor Oglesby, Editor Medill of the Chicago Tribune, and many members of the Chicago Board of Trade, visited Salt Lake City, they were welcomed by and affiliated with the Gentile element;¹ and when, in the following October, Vice President Colfax paid a second visit to the city, he declined the courtesies tendered to him by the city officers.² He made an address from the portico of the Townsend House, of which polygamy was the principle feature, and was soon afterward drawn into a newspaper discussion of the subject with John Taylor.
_________________________
¹ In an interview between Young and Senator Trumbull during this visit (reported in the Alta California), the following conversation took place: --

"Young -- We can take care of ourselves. Cumming was good enough in his way, for you know he was simply Governor of the Territory, while I was and am Governor of the people."

"Senator Trumbull -- Mr. Young, may I say to the President that you intend to observe the laws under the constitution?"

"Young -- Well-yes -- we intend to."

"Senator Trumbull -- But may I say to him that you will do so?"

"Young -- Yes, yes; so far as the laws are just, certainly."

² "Mr. Colfax politely refused to accept the proffered courtesies of the city. Brigham was reported to have uttered abusive language in the Tabernacle towards the Government and Congress, and to have charged the President and Vice President with being drunkards. One of the Aldermen who waited upon Mr. Colfax to tender to him the hospitality of the city could only say that he did not hear Brigham say so." -- "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 638.

-------- [ 557 ] --------

CHAPTER XX

GENTILE IRRUPTION AND MORMON SCHISM
THE end of the complete seclusion of the Mormon settlement in Utah from the rest of the country -- complete except so far as it was interrupted by the passage through the territory of the California emigration -- dates from the establishment of Camp Floyd, and the breaking up of that camp and the disposal of its accumulation of supplies, which gave the first big impetus to mercantile traffic in Utah.¹ Young was ever jealous of the mercantile power, so openly jealous that, as Tullidge puts it, "to become a merchant was to antagonize the church and her policies, so that it was almost illegitimate for Mormon men of enterprising character to enter into mercantile pursuits." This policy naturally increased the business of non-Mormons who established themselves in the city, and their prosperity directed the attention of the church authorities to them, and the pulpit orators hurled anathemas at those who traded with them. Thus Young, in a discourse, on March 28, 1858, urging the people to use home-made material, said: "Let the calicoes lie on the shelves and rot. I would rather build buildings every day and burn them down at night, than have traders here communing with our enemies outside, and keeping up a hell all the time, and raising devils to keep it going. They brought their hell with them. We can have enough of our own without their help."² A system of espionage, by means of the city police, was kept on the stores of non-Mormons, until it
_________________________
¹ "The community had become utterly destitute of almost everything necessary to their social comfort. The people were poorly clad, and rarely ever saw anything on their tables but what was prepared from flour, corn, beet-molasses, and the vegetables and fruits of their gardens.... It was at Camp Floyd, indeed, where the principal Utah merchants and businessmen of the second decade of our history may be said to have laid the foundation of their fortunes, among whom were the Walker Brothers." -- Tullidge, "History of Salt Lake City," pp. 246-247.
² Journal of Discourses, Vol. VII, p. 45.

--------     558     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

required courage for a Mormon to make a purchase in one of these establishments. To trade with an apostate Mormon was, of course, a still greater offence.

Among the mercantile houses that became strong after the establishment of Camp Floyd was that of Walker Brothers. There were four of them, Englishmen, who had come over with their mother, and shared in the privations of the early Utah settlement. Possessed of practical business talent and independence of thought, they rebelled against Young's dictatorial rule and the varied trammels by which their business was restricted. Without openly apostatizing, they insisted on a measure of independence. One manifestation of this was a refusal to contribute one-tenth of their income as a tithe for the expenditure of which no account was rendered. One year, when asked for their tithe, they gave the Bishop of their ward a check for $500 as "a contribution to the poor." When this form of contribution was reported to Young, he refused to accept it, and sent the brothers word that he would cut them off from the church unless they paid their tithe in the regular way. Their reply was to tear up the check and defy Young.

The natural result followed. Brigham and his lieutenants waged an open war on these merchants, denouncing them in the Tabernacle, and keeping policemen before their doors. The Walkers, on their part, kept on offering good wares at reasonable prices, and thus retained the custom of as many Mormons as dared trade with them openly, or could slip in undiscovered. Even the expedient of placing a sign bearing an "all-seeing eye" and the words "Holiness to the Lord" over every Mormon trader's door did not steer away from other doors the Mormon customers who delighted in bargains. But the church power was too great for any one firm to fight. Not only was a business man's capital in danger in those times, when the church was opposed to him, but his life was not safe. Stenhouse draws this picture of the condition of affairs in 1866: --

"After the assassination of Dr. Robinson, fears of violence were not unnatural, and many men who had never before carried arms buckled on their revolvers. Highly respectable men in Salt Lake City forsook the sidewalks after dusk, and, as they repaired to their residences, traversed the middle of the public street, carrying their revolvers in their hands.

With such a feeling of uneasiness, nearly all the non-Mormon merchants joined in a letter to Brigham Young, offering, if the church would purchase their

------           GENTILE IRRUPTION AND MORMON SCHISM           559  ------

goods and estates at twenty five percent less than their valuation, they would leave the Territory. Brigham answered them cavalierly that he had not asked them to come into the Territory, did not ask them to leave it, and that they might stay as long as they pleased.

"It was clear that Brigham felt himself master of the situation, and the merchants had to bide their time, and await the coming change that was anticipated from the completion of the Pacific Railroad. As the great iron way approached the mountains, and every day gave greater evidence of its being finished at a much earlier period than was at first anticipated, the hope of what it would accomplish nerved the discontented to struggle with the passing day."¹

The Mormon historian incorporates these two last paragraphs in his book, and says: "Here is at once described the Gentile and apostate view of the situation in those times, and, confined as it is to the salient point, no lengthy special argument in favor of President Young's policies could more clearly justify his mercantile cooperative movement. It was the moment of life or death to the temporal power of the church.... The organization of Z. C. M. I. at that crisis saved the temporal supremacy of the Mormon commonwealth."² It was to meet outside competition with a force which would be invincible that Young conceived the idea of Zion's Cooperative Mercantile Institution, which was incorporated in 1869, with Young as president. In carrying out this idea no opposing interest, whether inside the church or out of it, received the slightest consideration. "The universal dominance of the head of the church is admitted," says Tullidge, "and in 1868, before the opening of the Utah mines and the existence of a mixed population, there was no commercial escape from the necessities of a combination."³

Young is said to have received the idea of the big Cooperative enterprise from a small trader who asked permission to establish a mercantile system on the Cooperative plan, of moderate dimensions, throughout the territory. He gave it definite shape at a meeting of merchants in October, 1868, which was followed by a circular explaining the scheme to the people. A preamble asserted "the impolicy of leaving the trade and commerce of this territory to be conducted by strangers." The constitution of the concern provided
_________________________
¹ "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 625.
² Tullidge's "History of Salt Lake City," p. 385.
³ Cooperation is as much a cardinal and essential doctrine of the Mormon church as baptism for the remission of sin." -- Tullidge, "History of Salt Lake City."

--------     560     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

for a capital of $3,000,000 in $100 shares. Young's original idea was to have all the merchants pool their stocks, those who found no places in the new establishment to go into some other business, -- farming for instance, -- renting their stores as they could. Of course this meant financial ruin to the unprovided for, and the opposition was strong. But Young was not to be turned from the object he had in view. One man told Stenhouse that when he reported to Young that a certain merchant would be ruined by the scheme, and would not only be unable to pay his debts, but would lose his homestead, Young's reply was that the man had no business to get into debt, and that "if he loses his property it serves him right." Tullidge, in an article in Harpers Magazine for September, 1871 (written when he was at odds with Young), said, "The Mormon merchants were publicly told that all who refused to join the cooperation should be left out in the cold; and against the two most popular of them the Lion of the Lord roared, 'If Henry Lawrence don't mind what's he's about I'll send him on a mission, and W. S. Godbe I'll cut off from the church.'" After the organization of the concern in 1869 some of the leading Mormon merchants in Salt Lake City sold their goods to it on favorable terms, knowing that the prices of their stock would go down when the opening of the railroad lowered freight rates. The Z. C. M. I. was started as a wholesale and retail concern, and Young recommended that ward stores be opened throughout the city which should buy their goods of the Institution. Local cooperative stores were also organized throughout the territory, each of which was under pressure to make its purchases of the central concern. Branches were afterward established at Ogden, at Logan, and at Soda Springs, Idaho, and a large business was built up and is still continued.¹ The effect of this new competition on the non-Mormon establishments was, of course, very serious. Walker Brothers' sales, for instance, dropped $5000 or $6000 a month, and only the
_________________________
¹ Bancroft says that in 1883 the total sales of the Institution exceeded $4,000,000, and a half yearly dividend of five per cent was paid in October of that year, and there was a reserve fund of about $125,000; he placed the sales of the Ogden branch, in 1883, at about $800,000, and of the Logan branch at about $600,000. The thirty-second annual statement of the Institution, dated April 5,1901, contains the following figures: Capital stock, $1,077,144.89; reserve, $362,898.95; undivided profits, $179,042.88; cash receipts, February 1 to December 31, 1900, $3,457,624.44, sales for the same period, $3,489.571.84. The branch houses named is this report are at Ogden City and Provo, Utah, and at Idaho Falls, Idaho.

------           GENTILE IRRUPTION AND MORMON SCHISM           561  ------

opportunity to divert their capital profitably to mining saved them and others from immediate ruin.

But at this time an influence was preparing to make itself felt in Utah which was a more powerful opponent of Brigham Young's authority than any he had yet encountered. This influence took shape in what was known as the "New Movement," and also as "The Reformation." Its original leaders were W. S. Godbe and E. L. T. Harrison. Godbe was an Englishman, who saw a good deal of the world as a sailor, embraced the Mormon faith in his own country when seventeen years of age, and walked most of the way from New York to Salt Lake City in 1851. He became prominent in the Mormon capital as a merchant, making the trip over the plains twenty-four times between 1851 and 1859. Harrison was an architect by profession, a classical scholar, and a writer of no mean ability.

With these men were soon associated Eli B. Kelsey, a leading elder in the Mormon church, a president of Seventies, and a prominent worker in the English missions; H. W. Lawrence, a wealthy merchant who was a Bishop's counsellor; Amasa M. Lyman, who had been one of the Twelve Apostles and was acknowledged to be one of the most eloquent preachers in the church; W. H. Sherman, a prominent elder and a man of literary ability, who many years later went back to the church; T. B. H. Stenhouse, a Scotchman by birth, who was converted to Mormonism in 1846, and took a prominent part in missionary work in Europe, for three years holding the position of president of the Swiss and Italian missions; he emigrated to this country with his wife and children in 1855, practically penniless, and supported himself for a time in New York City as a newspaper writer; in Salt Lake City he married a second wife by Young's direction, and one of his daughters by his first wife married Brigham's eldest son. Stenhouse did not win the confidence of either Mormons or non-Mormons in the course of his career, but his book, "The Rocky Mountain Saints," contains much valuable information. Active with these men in the "New Movement" was Edward W. Tullidge, an elder and one of the Seventy, and a man of great literary ability. In later years Tullidge, while not openly associating himself with the Mormon church, wrote the "History of Salt Lake City" which the church accepts, a "Life of Brigham Young," which could not have been more fulsome if

--------     562     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

written by the most devout Mormon, and a "Life of Joseph the Prophet," which is a valueless expurgated edition of Joseph's autobiography which ran through the Millennial Star.

The "New Movement" was assisted by the advent of non-Mormons to the territory, by Young's arbitrary methods in starting his cooperative scheme, by the approaching completion of the Pacific Railroad, and, in a measure, by the organization of the Reorganized Church under the leadership of the prophet Joseph Smith's eldest son. Two elders of that church, who went to Salt Lake City in 1863, were refused permission to preach in the Tabernacle, but did effective work by house-to-house visitations, and there were said to be more than three hundred of the "Josephites," as they were called, in Salt Lake City in 1864.¹

Harrison and Tullidge had begun the publication of a magazine called the Peep o' Day at Camp Douglas, but it was a financial failure. Then Godbe and Harrison started the Utah Magazine, of which Harrison was editor. This, too, was only a drain on their purses. Accordingly, some time in the year 1868, giving it over to the care of Tullidge, they set out on a trip to New York by stage. Both were in doubt on many points regarding their church; both were of that mental make-up which is susceptible to "revelations" and "callings;" by the time they reached New York they realized that they were "on the road to apostasy." Long discussions of the situation took place between them, and the outcome was characteristic of men who had been influenced by such teachings as those of the Mormons. Kneeling down in their room, they prayed earnestly, and as they did so "a voice spoke to them." For three weeks, while Godbe transacted his mercantile business, his friend prepared questions on religion and philosophy, "and in the evening, by appointment, 'a band of spirits' came to them and held converse with them, as friends would speak with friends. One by one the questions prepared by Mr. Harrison were read, and Mr. Godbe and Mr. Harrison, with pencil and paper, took down the answers as they heard them given by the spirits."² The instruction which they thus received was
_________________________
¹ "Persecution followed, as they claimed; and in early summer about one-half of the Josephites in Salt Lake City started eastward, so great being the excitement that General Connor ordered a strong escort to accompany them as far as Greene River. To those who remained, protection was also afforded by the authorities." -- Bancroft, "History of Utah," p. 645. ² "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 631.

------           GENTILE IRRUPTION AND MORMON SCHISM           563  ------

Delphic in its clearness -- that which was true in Mormonism should be preserved and the rest should be rejected.

When they returned to Utah they took Elder Eli B. Kelsey, Elder H. W. Lawrence, a man of wealth, and Stenhouse into their confidence, and it was decided to wage open warfare on Young's despotism, using the Utah Magazine as their mouthpiece. Without attacking Young personally, or the fundamental Mormon beliefs, the magazine disputed Young's doctrine that the world was degenerating to ruin, held up the really "great characters" the world has known, that Young might be contrasted with them, and discussed the probabilities of honest errors in religious beliefs. When the Mormon leaders read in the magazine such doctrine as that, "There is one false error which possesses the minds of some in this, that God Almighty intended the priesthood to do our thinking," they realized that they had a contest on their hands.

Young got into trouble with the laboring men at this time. He had contracts for building a part of the Pacific Railroad, which were sublet at a profit. An attempt by him to bring about a reduction of wages gave the magazine an opportunity to plead the laborers' cause which it gladly embraced.¹

In the summer of 1869 Alexander and David Hyrum Smith, sons of the prophet, visited Salt Lake City in the interest of the Reorganized Church. Many of Young's followers still looked on the sons of the prophet as their father's rightful successor to the leadership of the Church, as Young at Nauvoo had promised that Joseph III should be. But these sons now found that, even to be acknowledged as members of Brigham's fold, they must accept baptism at the hands of one of his elders, and acknowledge the "revelation" concerning polygamy as coming from God. They had not come with that intent. But they called on Young and discussed with him the injection of polygamy into the church doctrines. Young finally told them that they possessed, not the spirit of their father, but of their mother Emma, whom Young characterized as "a liar, yes, the damnedest liar that lived," declaring that she tried to poison the prophet.² He refused to them the use of the Tabernacle, but they spoke in private
_________________________
¹ Harpers Magazine, Vol. XLIII, p. 605.
² For Alexander Smith's report, see True Latter-Day Saints' Herald, Vol. XVI, pp. 85-86.

--------     564     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

houses and, through the influence of the Walker brothers, secured Independence Hall. The Brighamites, using a son of Hyrum Smith as their mouthpiece,¹ took pains that a goodly number of polygamists should attend the Independence Hall meetings, and interruptions of the speakers turned the gatherings into something like personal wrangles.

The presence of the prophet's sons gave the leaders of "The Reformation" an opportunity to aim a thrust at what was then generally understood to be one of Brigham Young's ambitions, namely, the handing down of the Presidency of the church to his oldest son; and an article in their magazine presented the matter in this light: "If we know the true feeling of our brethren, it is that they never intend Joseph Smith's nor any other man's son to preside over them, simply because of their sonship. The principle of heirship has cursed the world for ages, and with our brethren we expect to fight it till, with every other relic of tyranny, it is trodden under foot." Young accepted this challenge, and at once ordered Harrison and two other elders in affiliation with him to depart on missions. They disobeyed the order.

Godbe and Harrison told their friends in Utah that they had learned from the spirits who visited them in New York that the release of the people of the territory from the despotism of the church could come only through the development of the mines. So determined was the opposition of Young's priesthood to this development that its open advocacy in the magazine was the cause of more serious discussion than that given to any of the other subjects treated. As "The Reformation" did not then embrace more than a dozen members, the courage necessary to defy the church on such a question was not to be belittled. Just at that time came the visit of the Illinois party and of Vice President Colfax, and the latter was made acquainted with their plans and gave them encouragement. Ten days later the magazine, in an article on "The True Development of the Territory," openly advised paying more attention to mining. Young immediately called together the "School of the Prophets." This was an organization instituted in Utah, with the professed object of discussing doctrinal questions, having the "revelations" of the prophet elucidated by his
_________________________
¹ Hyrum's widow went to Salt lake City, and died there in September, 1852, at the house of H. C. Kimball, who had taken care of her.

------           GENTILE IRRUPTION AND MORMON SCHISM           565  ------

colleagues, etc. It was not open to all church members, the "scholars" attending by invitation, and it soon became an organization under Young's direction which took cognizance of the secular doings of the people, exercising an espionage over them. The school is no longer maintained. Before this school Young denounced the "Reformers" in his most scathing terms, going so far as to intimate that his rule was itself in danger. Consequently the leaders of the "New Movement" were notified to appear before the High Council for a hearing.

When this hearing occurred, Young managed that Godbe and Harrison should be the only persons on trial. Both of them defied him to his face, denying his "right to dictate to them in all things spiritual and temporal," -- this was the question put to them, -- and protesting against his rule. They also read a set of resolutions giving an outline of their intended movements. They were at once excommunicated, and the only elder, Eli B. Kelsey, who voted against this action was immediately punished in the same way. Kelsey was not granted even the perfunctory hearing that was customarily allowed in such cases, and he was "turned over to the devil," instead of being consigned by the usual formula "to the buffetings of Satan."

But this did not silence the "Reformers." Their lives were considered in danger by their acquaintances, and the assassination of the most prominent of them was anticipated;¹ but they went
_________________________
¹ "In August my husband sent a respectful and kindly letter to the Bishop of our ward, stating that he had no faith in Brigham's claim to an Infallible Priesthood; and that he considered that he ought to be cut off from the church. I added a postscript stating that I wished to share my husband's fate. A little after ten o'clock, on the Saturday night succeeding our withdrawal from the church, we were returning home together... when we suddenly saw four men come out from under some trees at a little distance from us.... As soon as they approached, they seized hold of my husband's arms, one on each side, and held him firmly, thus rendering him almost powerless. They were all masked.... In an instant I saw them raise their arms, as if taking aim, and for one brief second I thought that our end had surely come, and that we, like so many obnoxious persons before us, were about to be murdered for the great sin of apostasy. This I firmly believe would have been my husband's fate if I had not chanced to be with him or had I run away.... The wretches, although otherwise well armed, were not holding revolvers in their hands as I at first supposed. They were furnished with huge garden syringes, charged with the most disgusting filth. My hair, bonnet, face, clothes, person -- every inch of my body, every shred I wore -- were in an instant saturated, and my husband and myself stood there reeking from head to foot. The villains, when they had perpetrated this disgusting and brutal outrage, turned and fled." -- Mrs. Stenhouse, "Tell it All," pp. 578-581.

--------     566     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

straight ahead on the lines they had proclaimed. Their first public meetings were held on Sunday, December 19, 1869. The knowledge of the fact that they claimed to act by direct and recent revelation gave them no small advantage with a people whose belief rested on such manifestations of the divine will, and they had crowded audiences. The services were continued every Sunday, and on the evening of one week day; the magazine went on with its work, and they were the founders of the Salt Lake Tribune which later, as a secular journal, has led the Gentile press in Utah.¹

But the attempt to establish a reformed Mormonism did not succeed, and the organization gradually disappeared. One of the surviving leaders said to me (in October, 1901): "My parents had believed in Mormonism, and I believed in the Mormon prophet and the doctrines set forth in his revelations. We hoped to purify the Mormon church, eradicating evils that had annexed themselves to it in later years. But our study of the question showed us that the Mormon faith rested on no substantial basis, and we became believers in transcendentalism." Mr. Godbe and Mr. Lawrence still reside in Utah. The former has made and lost more than one fortune in the mines. The Mormon historian Whitney says of the leaders in this attempted reform: "These men were all reputable and respected members of the community. Naught against their morality or general uprightness of character was known or advanced."² Stenhouse, writing three years before Young's death, said: --

"But for the boldness of the Reformers, Utah to-day would not have been what it is. Inspired by their example, the people who have listened to them disregarded the teachings of the priesthood against trading with or purchasing of the Gentiles. The spell was broken, and, as in all such like experience, the other extreme was for a time threatened. Walker Brothers regained their lost trade.... Reference could be made to elders, some of whom had to steal away from Utah, for fear of violent hands being laid upon them had their intended departure been made known, who are to-day wealthy and respected gentlemen in the highest walks of life, both in the United States and in Europe."
_________________________
¹ Whitney's "History of Utah," Vol. II, p. 332."
² For accounts of "The Reformation" by leaders in it, see Chap. 53 of Stenhouse's "Rocky Mountain Saints," and Tullidge's article, Harper's Magazine, Vol. XLIII, p. 602.

-------- [ 567 ] --------

CHAPTER XXI

THE LAST YEARS OF BRIGHAM YOUNG
GOVERNOR DOTY died in June, 1865, without coming in open conflict with Young, and was succeeded by Charles Durkee, a native of Vermont, but appointed from Wisconsin, which state he had represented in the United States Senate. He resigned in 1869, and was succeeded by J. Wilson Shaffer of Illinois, appointed by President Grant at the request of Secretary of War Rawlins, who, in a visit to the territory in 1868, concluded that its welfare required a governor who would assert his authority. Secretary S. A. Mann, as acting governor, had, just before Shaffer's arrival, signed a female suffrage bill passed by the territorial legislature. This gave offence to the new governor, and Mann was at once succeeded by Professor V. H. Vaughn of the University of Alabama, and Chief Justice C. C. Wilson (who had succeeded Titus) by James B. McKean. The latter was a native of Rensselaer County, New York; had been county judge of Saratoga County from 1854 to 1858, a member of the 36th and 37th Congresses, and colonel of the 72nd New York Volunteers.

Governor Shaffer's first important act was to issue a proclamation forbidding all drills and gatherings of the militia of the territory (which meant the Nauvoo Legion), except by the order of himself or the United States marshal. Wells, signing himself "Lieutenant General," sent the governor a written request for the suspension of this order. The governor, in reply, reminded Wells that the only "Lieutenant General" recognized by law was then Philip H. Sheridan, and declined to assist him in a course which "would aid you and your turbulent associates to further convince your followers that you and your associates are more powerful than the federal government." Thus practically disappeared this famous Mormon military organization.

Governor Shaffer was ill when he reached Utah, and he died

--------     568     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

a few days after his reply to Wells was written, Secretary Vaughn succeeding him until the arrival of G. A. Black, the new secretary, who then became acting governor pending the arrival of George L. Woods, an ex-governor of Oregon, who was next appointed to the executive office.

As soon as the new federal judges, who were men of high personal character, took their seats, they decided that the United States marshal, and not the territorial marshal, was the proper person to impanel the juries in the federal courts, and that the attorney general appointed by the President under the Territorial Act, and not the one elected under that act, should prosecute indictments found in the federal courts. The chief justice also filled a vacancy in the office of federal attorney. The territorial legislature of 1870, accordingly, made no appropriation for the expenses of the courts; and the chief justice, in dismissing the grand and petit juries on this account, explained to them that he had heard one of the high priesthood question the right of Congress even to pass the Territorial Act.

In September, 1871, the United States marshal summoned a grand jury from nine counties (twenty-three jurors and seventeen talesmen) of whom only seven were Mormons. All the latter, examined on their voir dire, declared that they believed that polygamy was a revelation to the church, and that they would obey the revelation rather than the law, and all were successfully challenged. This grand jury, early in October, found indictments against Brigham Young, "General" Wells, G. Q. Cannon, and others under a territorial statute directed against lewdness and improper cohabitation. This action caused intense excitement in the Mormon capital. Prosecutor Baskin was quoted as saying that the troops at Camp Douglas would be used to enforce the warrant for Young's arrest if necessary, and the possible outcome has been thus portrayed by the Mormon historian: --

"It was well known that he [Young] had often declared that he never would give himself up to be murdered as his predecessor, the Prophet Joseph, and his brother Hyrum had been, while in the hands of the law, and under the sacred pledge of the state for their safety; and, ere this could have been repeated, ten thousand Mormon Elders would have gone into the jaws of death with Brigham Young. In a few hours the suspended Nauvoo Legion would have been in arms."¹
_________________________
¹ Tullidge's "History of Salt Lake City," p. 527.

------               THE LAST YEARS OF BRIGHAM YOUNG               569  ------

The warrant was served on Young at his house by the United States marshal, and, as Young was ill, a deputy was left in charge of him. On October 9 Young appeared in court with the leading men of the church, and a motion to quash the indictment was made before the chief justice and denied.

The same grand jury on October 28 found indictments for murder against D. H. Wells, W. H. Kimball, and Hosea Stout for alleged responsibility for the killing of Richard Yates during the "war" of 1857. The fact that the man was killed was not disputed; his brains were knocked out with an axe as he was sleeping by the side of two Mormon guards.¹ The defence was that he died the death of a spy. Wells was admitted to bail in $50,000, and the other two men were placed under guard at Camp Douglas. Indictments were also found against Brigham Young, W. A. Hickman, O. P. Rockwell, G. D. Grant, and Simon Dutton for the murder of one of the Aikin party at Warm Springs. They were all admitted to bail.

When the case against Young, on the charge of improper cohabitation, was called on November 20, his counsel announced that he had gone South for his health, as was his custom in winter, and the prosecution thereupon claimed that his bail was forfeited. Two adjournments were granted at the request of his counsel. On January 3 Young appeared in court, and his counsel urged that he be admitted to bail, pleading his age and ill health. The judge refused this request, but said that the marshal could, if he desired, detain the prisoner in one of Young's own houses. This course was taken, and he remained under detention until released by the decision of the United States Supreme Court.

In April, 1872, that court decided that the territorial jury law of Utah, in force since 1859, had received the implied approval of Congress; that the duties of the attorney and marshal appointed by the President under the Territorial Act "have exclusive relation to cases arising under the laws and constitution of the United States," and "the making up of the jury list and all matters connected with the designation of jurors are subject to the regulation of territorial law."² This was a great victory for the Mormons.

In October, 1873, the United States Supreme Court rendered
_________________________
¹ Hickman tells the story in his "Brigham's Destroying Angel," p. 122.
² Chilton vs. Englebrech, 13 Wallace, p. 434.

--------     570     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

its decision in the case of "Snow vs. The United States" on the appeal from Chief Justice McKean's ruling about the authority of the prosecuting officers. It overruled the chief justice, confining the duties of the attorney appointed by the President to cases in which the federal government was concerned, concluding that "in any event, no great inconvenience can arise, because the entire matter is subject to the control and regulation of Congress."¹

The following comments, from three different sources, will show the reader how many influences were then shaping the control of authority in Utah: --

"At about this time {December, 1871} a change came in the action of the Department of justice in these Utah prosecutions, and fair-minded men of the nation demanded of the United States Government that it should stop the disgraceful and illegal proceedings of Judge McKean's court. The influence of Senator Morton was probably the first and most potent brought to bear in this matter, and immediately thereafter Senator Lyman Trumbull threw the weight of his name and statesmanship in the same direction, which resulted in Baskin and Maxwell being superseded,... and finally resulted in the setting aside of two years of McKean's doings as illegal by the august decision of the Supreme Court." -- Tullidge, "History of Salt Lake City," p. 547.

"The Attorney for the Mormons labored assiduously at Washington, and, contrary to the usual custom in the Supreme Court, the forthcoming decision had been whispered to some grateful ears. The Mormon anniversary conference beginning on the sixth of April was continued over without adjournment awaiting that decision." -- "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 688.

"Thus stood affairs during the winter of 1870-71. The Gentiles had the courts, the Mormons had the money. In the spring Nevada came over to run Utah. Hon. Thomas Fitch of that state had been defeated in his second race for Congress; so he came to Utah as Attorney for the Mormons. Senator Stewart and other Nevada politicians made heavy investments in Utah mines; litigation multiplied as to mining titles, and Judge McKean did not rule to suit Utah.... The great Emma mine, worth two or three millions, became a power in our judicial embroglio. The Chief Justice, in various rulings, favored the present occupants. Nevada called upon Senator Stewart, who agreed to go straight to Long Branch and see that McKean was removed. But Ulysses the Silent... promptly made reply that if Judge McKean had committed no greater fault than to revise a little Nevada law, he was not altogether unpardonable." -- Beadle, "Polygamy," p. 429.

The Supreme Court decisions left the federal courts in Utah practically powerless, and President Grant understood this. On February 14, 1873, he sent a special message to Congress, saying
_________________________
¹ Wallace's "Reports," Vol. XVIII, p. 317.

------               THE LAST YEARS OF BRIGHAM YOUNG               571  ------

that he considered it necessary, in order to maintain the supremacy of the laws of the United States, "to provide that the selection of grand and petit jurors for the district courts {of Utah}, if not put under the control of federal officers, shall be placed in the hands of persons entirely independent of those who are determined not to enforce any act of Congress obnoxious to them, and also to pass some act which shall deprive the probate courts, or any court created by the territorial legislature, of any power to interfere with or impede the action of the courts held by the United States judges."

In line with this recommendation Senator Frelinghuysen had introduced a bill in the Senate early in February, which the Senate speedily passed, the Democrats and Schurz, Carpenter, and Trumbull voting against it. Mormon influence fought it with desperation in the House, and in the closing hours of the session had it laid aside. The diary of Delegate Hooper says on this subject, "Maxwell {the United States Marshal for Utah} said he would take out British papers and be an American citizen no longer. Claggett {Delegate from Montana} asserted that we had spent $200,000 on the judiciary committee, and Merritt {Delegate from Idaho} swore that there had been treachery and we had bribed Congress."¹

In the election of 1872 the Mormons dropped Hooper, who had long served them as Delegate at Washington, and sent in his place George Q. Cannon, an Englishman by birth and a polygamist. But Mormon influence in Washington was now to receive a severe check. On June 23, 1874, the President approved an act introduced by Mr. Poland of Vermont, and known as the Poland Bill,² which had important results. It took from the probate courts
_________________________
¹ The Mormons do not always conceal the influences they employ to control legislation in which they are interested. Thus Tullidge, referring to the men of whom their Cooperative Institution buys goods, says: "But Z. C. M. I. has not only a commercial significance in the history of our city, but also a politic alone. It has long been the temporal bulwark around the Mormon community. Results which have been seen in Utah affairs, preservative of the Mormon power and people, unaccountable to 'the outsider' except on the now stale supposition that 'the Mormon Church has purchased Congress,' may be better traced to the silent but potent influence of Z. C. M. I. among the ruling business men of America, just as John Sharp's position as one of the directors of U. P. R -- R, -- a compeer among such men as Charles Francis Adams, Jay Gould and Sidney Dillon -- gives him a voice in Utah affairs among the railroad rulers of America." -- "History of Salt Lake City;" p. 734.
² Chap. 469, 1st Session, 43d Congress.

--------     572     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

in Utah all civil, chancery, and criminal jurisdiction; made the common law in force; provided that the United States attorney should prosecute all criminal cases arising in the United States courts in the territory; that the United States marshal should serve and execute all processes and writs of the supreme and district courts, and that the clerk of the district court in each district and the judge of probate of the county should prepare the jury lists, each containing two hundred names, from which the United States marshal should draw the grand and petit juries for the term. It further provided that, when a woman filed a bill to declare void a marriage because of a previous marriage, the court could grant alimony; and that, in any prosecution for adultery, bigamy, or polygamy, a juror could be challenged if he practised polygamy or believed in its righteousness.

The suit for divorce brought by Young's wife "No. 19," -- Ann Eliza Young -- in January, 1873, attracted attention all over the country. Her bill charged neglect, cruel treatment, and desertion, set forth that Young had property worth $8,000,000 and an income of not less than $40,000 a year, and asked for an allowance of $1000 a month while the suit was pending, $6000 for preliminary counsel fees, and $14,000 more when the final decree was made, and that she be awarded $200,000 for her support. Young in his reply surprised even his Mormon friends. After setting forth his legal marriage in Ohio, stating that he and the plaintiff were members of a church which held the doctrine that "members thereto might rightfully enter into plural marriages," and admitting such a marriage in this case, he continued: "But defendant denies that he and the said plaintiff intermarried in any other or different sense or manner than that above mentioned or set forth. Defendant further alleges that the said complainant was then informed by the defendant, and then and there well knew that, by reason of said marriage, in the manner aforesaid, she could not have and need not expect the society or personal attention of this defendant as in the ordinary relation between husband and wife." He further declared that his property did not exceed $600,000 in value, and his income $6000 a month.

Judge McKean, on February 25, 1875, ordered Young to pay Ann Eliza $3000 for counsel fees and $500 a month alimony pendente lite, and, when he failed to obey, sentenced him to pay a

------               THE LAST YEARS OF BRIGHAM YOUNG               573  ------

fine of $25 and to one day's imprisonment. Young was driven to his own residence by the deputy marshal for dinner, and, after taking what clothing he required, was conducted to the penitentiary, where he was locked up in a cell for a short time, and then placed in a room in the warden's office for the night.

Judge McKean was accused of inconsistency in granting alimony, because, in so doing, he had to give legal sanction to Ann Eliza's marriage to Brigham while the latter's legal wife was living. Judge McKean's successor, Judge D. P. Loew, refused to imprison Young, taking the ground that there had been no valid marriage. Loew's successor, Judge Boreman, ordered Young imprisoned until the amount due was paid, but he was left at his house in custody of the marshal. Boreman's successor, Judge White, freed Young on the ground that Boreman's order was void. White's successor, Judge Schaeffer, in 1876 reduced the alimony to $100 per month, and, in default of payment, certain of Young's property was sold at auction and rents were ordered seized to make up the deficiency. The divorce case came to trial in April, 1877, when Judge Schaeffer decreed that the polygamous marriage was void, annulled all orders for alimony, and assessed the costs against the defendant.

Nothing further of great importance affecting the relations of the church with the federal government occurred during the rest of Young's life. Governor Woods incurred the animosity of the Mormons by asserting his authority from time to time ("he intermeddled," Bancroft says). In 1874 he was succeeded by S. B. Axtell of California, who showed such open sympathy with the Mormon view of his office as to incur the severest censure of the non-Mormon press. Axtell was displaced in the following year by G. B. Emery of Tennessee, who held office until the early part of 1880, when he was succeeded by Eli H. Murray.¹
_________________________
¹ Governor Murray showed no disposition to yield to Mormon authority. In his message in 1882 be referred pointedly, among other matters, to the tithing, declaring that "the poor man who earns a dollar by the sweat of his brow is entitled to that dollar," and that "any exaction or undue influence to dispossess him of any part of it, in any other manner than in payment of a legal obligation, is oppression," and he granted a certificate of election as Delegate to Congress to Allan G. Campbell, who received only 1350 votes to 18,568 for George Q. Cannon, holding that the latter was not a citizen. Governor Murray's resignation was accepted in March, 1886, and he was succeeded in the following May by Caleb W. West, who, in turn, was supplanted in May, 1889, by A. L. Thomas, who was territorial governor when Utah was admitted as a state.

-------- [ 574 ] --------

CHAPTER XXII

BRIGHAM YOUNG'S DEATH -- HIS CHARACTER
BRIGHAM YOUNG died in Salt Lake City at 4 P.M. on Wednesday, August 29, 1877. He was attacked with acute cholera morbus on the evening of the 23rd, after delivering an address in the Council House, and it was followed by inflammation of the bowels. The body lay in state in the Tabernacle from Saturday, September 1, until Sunday noon, when the funeral services were held. He was buried in a little plot on one of the main streets of Salt Lake City, not far from his place of residence.

The steps by which Young reached the position of head of the Mormon church, the character of his rule, and the means by which he maintained it have been set forth in the previous chapters of this work. In the ruler we have seen a man without education, but possessed of an iron will, courage to take advantage of unusual opportunities, and a thorough knowledge of his flock gained by association with them in all their wanderings. In his people we have seen a nucleus of fanatics, including some of Joseph Smith's fellow-plotters, constantly added to by new recruits, mostly poor and ignorant foreigners, who had been made to believe in Smith's Bible and "revelations," and been further lured to a change of residence by false pictures of the country they were going to, and the business opportunities that awaited them there. Having made a prominent tenet of the church the practice of polygamy, which Young certainly knew the federal government would not approve, he had an additional bond with which to unite the interests of his flock with his own, and thus to make them believe his approval as necessary to their personal safety as they believed it to be necessary to their salvation. The command which Young exercised in these circumstances is not an illustration of any form of leadership which can be held up to admiration. It is rather an exemplification

-----               BRIGHAM YOUNG'S DEATH - HIS CHARACTER              575  -----

of that tyranny in church and state which the world condemns whenever an example of it is afforded.

Young was the centre of responsibility for all the rebellion, nullification, and crime carried on under the authority of the church while he was its head. He never concealed his own power. He gloried in it, and declared it openly in and out of the Tabernacle. Authority of this kind cannot be divided. Whatever credit is due to Young for securing it, is legitimately his. But those who point to its acquisition as a sign of greatness, must accept for him, with it, responsibility for the crimes that were carried on under it.

The laudators of Young have found evidence of great executive ability in his management of the migration from Nauvoo to Utah. But, in the first place, this migration was compulsory; the Mormons were obliged to move. In the second place its accomplishment was no more successful than the contemporary migrations to Oregon, and the loss of life in the camps on the Missouri River was greater than that incurred in the great rush across the plains to California; while the horrors of the hand-cart movement -- a scheme of Young's own device -- have never been equalled in Western travel. In Utah, circumstances greatly favored Young's success. Had not gold been discovered when it was in California, the Mormon settlement would long have been like a dot in a desert, and its ability to support the stream Of immigrants attracted from Europe would have been problematic, since, in more than one summer, those already there had narrowly escaped starvation while depending on the agricultural resources of the valley.

J. Hyde, writing in 1857, said that Young "by the native force and vigor of a strong mind" had taken from beneath the Mormon church system "the monstrous stilts of a miserable superstition, and consolidated it into a compact scheme of the sternest fanaticism."¹ In other words, he might have explained, instead of relying on such "revelations" as served Smith, he refused to use artificial commands of God, and substituted the commands of Young, teaching, and having his associates teach, that obedience to the head of the church was obedience to the Supreme Power. Both Hyde and Stenhouse, writing before Young's death, and as witnesses of the strength of his autocratic government, overestimated him. This is seen in the view they took of the effect of his
_________________________
¹ "Mormonism," p.151.

--------     576     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

death. Hyde declared that under any of the other contemporary leaders Taylor, Kimball, Orson Hyde, or Pratt: "Mormonism will decline. Brigham is its sun; this is its daytime." Stenhouse asserted that, "Theocracy will die out with Brigham's flickering flame of life; and, when he is laid in the tomb, many who are silent now will curse his memory for the cruel suffering that his ambition caused them to endure." But all such prophecies remain unfulfilled. Young's death caused no more revolution or change in the Mormon church than does the death of a Pope in the Church of Rome. "Regret it who may," wrote a Salt Lake City correspondent less than three months after his burial, "the fact is visible to every intelligent person here that Mormonism has taken a new lease of life, and, instead of disintegration, there never was such unity among its people; and in the place of a rapidly dying consumptive, whose days were numbered, the body of the church is the picture of pristine health and vigor, with all the ambition and enthusiasm of a first love."¹ The new leadership has, grudgingly, traded polygamy for statehood; but the church power is as strong and despotic and unified to-day on the lines on which it is working as it was under Young, only exercising that power on the more civilized basis rendered necessary by closer connection with an outside civilization.

Young was a successful accumulator of property for his own use. A poor man when he set out from Nauvoo, his estate at his death was valued at between $2,000,000 and $3,000,000. This was a great accumulation for a pioneer who had settled in a wilderness, been burdened with a polygamous family of over twenty wives and fifty children, and the cares of a church denomination, without salary as a church officer. "I am the only person in the church," Young said to Greeley in 1859, "who has not a regular calling apart from the church service;" and he added, "We think a man who cannot make his living aside from the ministry of the church unsuited to that office. I am called rich, and consider myself worth $250,000; but no dollar of it ever was paid me by the church, nor for any service as a minister of the Everlasting Gospel."² Two years after his death a writer in the Salt Lake Tribune³ asserted that Young had secured in Utah from the tithing
_________________________
¹ New York Times, November 23, 1877.
² "Overland Journey," p. 213.
³ June 25, 1879.

-----               BRIGHAM YOUNG'S DEATH - HIS CHARACTER              577  -----

$13,000,000, squandered about $9,000,000 on his family, and left the rest to be fought for by his heirs and assigns.¹ Notwithstanding the vast sums taken by him in tithing for the alleged benefit of the poor, there was not in Salt Lake City, at the time of his death, a single hospital or "home" creditable to that settlement.

The mere acquisition of his wealth no more entitled Young to be held up as a marvellous man of business than did Tweed's accumulations give him this distinction in New York. Beadle declares that "Brigham never made a success of any business he undertook except managing the Mormons," and cites among his business failures the non-success of every distant colony he planted, the Cottonwood Canal (whose mouth was ten feet higher than its source), his beet-sugar manufactory, and his Colorado Transportation Company (to bring goods for southern Utah up the Colorado River).²

The reports of Young's discourses in the Temple show that he was as determined in carrying out his own financial schemes as he was in enforcing orders pertaining to the church. Here is an almost humorous illustration of this. In urging the people one day to be more regular in paying their tithing, he said they need not fear that he would make a bad use of their money, as he had plenty of his own, adding: --

"I believe I will tell you how I get some of it. A great many of these elders in Israel, soon after courting these young ladies, and old ladies, and middle-aged ladies, and having them sealed to them, want to have a bill of divorce. I have told them from the beginning that sealing men and women for time and all eternity is one of the ordinances of the House of God, and that I never wanted a farthing for sealing them, nor for officiating in any of the ordinances of God's house. But when you ask for a bill of divorce, I intend that you shall pay for it. That keeps me in spending money, besides enabling me to give hundreds of dollars to the poor, and buy butter, eggs, and little notions for women and children, and otherwise use it where it does good. You may think this a singular feature of the Gospel, but I cannot exactly say that this is in the Gospel."³
_________________________
¹ "Having control of the tithing, and possessing unlimited credit, he has added 'house to house and field to field,' while every one knew that he had no personal enterprises sufficient to enable him to meet anything like the current expenses of his numerous wives and children. As trustee in trust he renders no account of the funds that come into his hands, but tells the faithful that they are at perfect liberty to examine the books at any moment." -- "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 665.
² "Polygamy," p. 484.
³ Deseret News, March 20, 1861.

--------     578     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

For such an openly jolly old hypocrite one can scarcely resist the feeling that he would like to pass around the hat.

We have seen how Young gave himself control of a valuable canon. That was only the beginning of such acquisitions. The territorial legislature of Utah was continually making special grants to him. Among them may be mentioned the control of City Creek Canon (said to have been worth $10,000 a year) on payment of $500; of the waters of Mill Creek; exclusive right to Kansas Prairie as a herd-ground; the whole of Cache Valley for a herd-ground; Rush Valley for a herd-ground; rights to establish ferries; an appropriation of $2500 for an academy in Salt Lake City (which was not built), etc.¹

Young's holdings of real estate were large, not only in Salt Lake City, but in almost every county in the territory.² Besides city lots and farm lands, he. owned grist and saw mills, and he took care that his farms were well cultivated and that his mills made fine flour.³

As trustee in trust for the church Young had control of all the church property and income, practically without responsibility or oversight. Mrs. Waite (writing in 1866) said that attempts for many years by the General Conference to procure a balance sheet of receipts and expenditures had failed, and that the accounts in the tithing office, such as they were, were kept by clerks who were the leading actors in the Salt Lake Theatre, owned by Young.⁴ It was openly charged that, in 1852, Young "balanced his account" with the church by having the clerk credit him with the amount due by him, "for services rendered," and that, in 1867, he balanced his account again by crediting himself with $967,000. A committee appointed to investigate the accounts of Young after
_________________________
¹ Here is the text of one of these acts: "Be it ordained by the General Assembly of the State of Deseret that Brigham Young has the sole control of City Creek and Canon; and that he pay into the public treasury the sum of $500 therefore. Dec. 9, 1850."
² "For several years past the agent of the church, A. M. Musser, has been engaged in securing legal deeds for all the property the prophet claims, and by this he will be able to secure in his lifetime to his different families such property as will render them independent at his death. The building of the Pacific Railroad is said to have yielded him about a quarter of a million." -- "Rocky Mountain Saints," p. 666.
³ "His position secured him also many valuable presents. From a barrel of brandy down to an umbrella, Brigham receives courteously and remembers the donors with increased kindness. I saw one man make him a present of ten fine milch cows." -- Hyde, "Mormonism," p. 165.
⁴ "The Mormon Prophet," pp. 148-149.

-----               BRIGHAM YOUNG'S DEATH - HIS CHARACTER              579  -----

his death reported to the Conference of October, 1878, that "for the sole purpose of preserving it from the spoliation of the enemy," he "had transferred certain property from the possession of the church to his own individual possession," but that it had been transferred back again.

Young's will divided his wives and children into nineteen "classes," and directed his executors to pay to each such a sum as might be necessary for their comfortable support; the word "marriage" in the will to mean "either by ceremony before a lawful magistrate, or according to the order of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, or by their cohabitation in conformity to our custom."

On June 14, 1879, Emmeline A. Young, on behalf of herself and the heirs at law, began a suit against the executors of Young's estate, charging that they had improperly appropriated $200,000; had improperly allowed nearly $1,000,000 to John Taylor as trustee in trust to the church, less a credit of $300,000 for Young's services as trustee; and that they claimed the power, as members of the Apostles' Quorum, to dispose of all the testator's property and to disinherit any heir who refused to submit. This suit was compromised in the following September, the seven persons joining in it executing a release on payment of $75,000. A suit which the church had begun against the heirs and executors was also discontinued. The Salt Lake Herald (Mormon) of October 5, 1879, said, "The adjustment is far preferable to a continuance of the suit, which was proving not only expensive, but had become excessively annoying to many people, was a large disturbing element in the community, and was rapidly descending into paths that nobody here cares to see trodden."

Just how many wives Brigham Young had, in the course of his life, would depend on his own and others' definition of that term. He told Horace Greeley, in 1859: "I have fifteen; I know no one who has more. But some of those sealed to me are old ladies, whom I regard rather as mothers than wives, but whom I have taken home to cherish and support."¹ In 1869, he informed the Boston Board of Trade, when that body visited Salt Lake City, that he had sixteen wives living, and had lost four, and that forty-nine of his children were living then. " He was," says Beadle,
_________________________
¹ "Overland journey," p. 215.

--------     580     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

"sealed on the spiritual wife system to more women than any one can count; all over Mormondom are pious old widows, or wives of Gentiles and apostates, who hope to rise at the last day and claim a celestial share in Brigham." J. Hyde said that he knew of about twenty-five wives with whom Brigham lived. The following list is made up from "Pictures and Biographies of Brigham Young and his Wives," published by J. H. Crockwell of Salt Lake City, by authority of Young's eldest son and of seven of his wives, but is not complete: --

NAME
Mary Ann Angel - 1
Louisa Beman - 2
Mrs. Lucy Decker Seely
H. E. C. Campbell
Augusta Adams
Clara Decker
Clara C. Ross
Emily Dow Partridge - 2
Susan Snively
Olive Grey Frost - 2
Emmeline Free
Margaret Pierce
N. K. T. Carter
Ellen Rockwood
Maria Lawrence - 2
Martha Bowker
Margaret M. Alley
Lucy Bigelow
Z. D. Huntington - 2
Eliza K. Snow - 2
Eliza Burgess
Harriet Barney
Harriet A. Folsom
Mary Van Cott
Ann Eliza Webb

DATE OF MARRIAGE
February, 1834. Ohio
April, 1841. Nauvoo
June, 1842. Nauvoo
November, 1843.Nauvoo
November, 1843. Nauvoo
May, 1844. Nauvoo
September, 1844. Nauvoo
September, 1844. Nauvoo
November, 1844. Nauvoo
February, 1845. Nauvoo
April, 1845. Nauvoo
April, 1845. Nauvoo
January, 1846. Nauvoo
January, 1846. Nauvoo
January, 1846. Nauvoo
January, 1846. Nauvoo
January, 1846. Nauvoo
March, 1847. (?)
March, 1847 (?). Nauvoo
June, 1849. S. L. C.
October, 1850. S. L. C.
October, 1850. S. L. C.
January, 1863. S. L. C.
January, 1865. S. L. C.
April, 1868. S. L. C.

NUMBER OF CHILDREN
6
4
7
1
0
5
4
7
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
2
3
1
0
1
1
0
1
0

Young's principal houses in Salt Lake City stood at the southeastern corner of the block adjoining the Temple block, and designated on the map as block 8. The largest building, occupying the
_________________________
¹ His first wife died 1832.
² Joseph Smith's widows.

-----               BRIGHAM YOUNG'S DEATH - HIS CHARACTER              581  -----

corner, was called the Beehive House; connected with this was a smaller building in which were Young's private offices, the tithing office, etc.; and next to this was a building partly of stone, called the Lion House, taking its name from the figure of a lion sculptured on its front, representing Young's title "The Lion of the Lord." When J. Hyde wrote, seventeen or eighteen of Young's wives dwelt in the Lion House, and the Beehive House became his official residence.¹ Individual wives were provided for elsewhere. His legal wife lived in what was called the White House, a few hundred yards from his official home. His well-beloved Amelia lived in another house half a block distant; another favorite, just across the street; Emmeline, on the same block; and not far away the latest acquisition to his harem.

Young's life in his later years was a very orderly one, although he was not methodical in arranging his office hours and attending to his many duties. Rising before eight A.m., he was usually in his office at nine, transacting business with his secretary, and was ready to receive callers at ten. So many were the people who had occasion to see him, and so varied were the matters that could be brought to his attention, that many hours would be devoted to these callers if other engagements did not interfere. Once a year he made a sort of visit of state to all the principal settlements in the territory, accompanied by counsellors, apostles, and Bishops, and sometimes by a favorite wife. Shorter excursions of the same kind were made at other times. Each settlement was expected to give him a formal greeting, and this sometimes took the form of a procession with banners, such as might have been prepared for a conquering hero.
_________________________
¹ The Beehive House is still the official residence of the head of the church, and in it President Snow was living at the time of his death. The office building is still devoted to office uses, and the Lion House now furnishes temporary quarters to the Latter-Day Saints' College.

-------- [ 582 ] --------

CHAPTER XXIII

SOCIAL ASPECTS OF POLYGAMY
THERE was something compulsory about all phases of life in Utah during Brigham Young's regime -- the form of employment for the men, the domestic regulations of the women, the church duties each should perform, and even the location in the territory which they should call their home. Not only did large numbers of the foreign immigrants find themselves in debt to the church on their arrival, and become compelled in this way to labor on the "public works" as they might be ordered, but the skilled mechanics who brought their tools with them in most cases found on their arrival that existence in Utah meant a contest with the soil for food. Even when a mechanic obtained employment at his trade it was in the ruder branches.

Mormon authorities have always tried to show that Americans have predominated in their community. Tullidge classes the population in this order: Americans, English, Scandinavian (these claim one-fifth of the Mormon population of Utah), Scotch, Welsh, Germans, and a few Irish, French, Italians, and Swiss. The combination of new-comers and the emigrants from Nauvoo made a rude society of fanatics,¹ before whom there was held out enough prospect of gain in land values (scarcely one of the immigrants had ever been a landowner) to overcome a good deal of the discontent natural to their mode of life, and who, in religious matters, were held in control by a priesthood, against whom they could not rebel without endangering that hope of heaven which had induced them to journey across the ocean. There are roughness and lawlessness in all frontier settlements, but this Mormon community differed
_________________________
¹ "I have discovered thus early (1852) that little deference is paid to women. Repeatedly, in my long walk to our boarding house, I was obliged to retreat back from the {street} crossing places and stand on one side for men to cross over. There are said to be a great many of the lower order of English here, and this rudeness, so unusual with our countrymen, may proceed from them." -- Mrs. Ferris. "Life among the Mormons."

-----                        SOCIAL ASPECTS OF POLYGAMY                       583  -----

from all other gatherings of new population in the American West. It did not migrate of its own accord, attracted by a fertile soil or precious ores; it was induced to migrate, not without misrepresentation concerning material prospects, it is true, but mainly because of the hope that by doing so it would share in the blessings and protection of a Zion. The gambling hell and the dance hall, which form principal features of frontier mining settlements, were wanting in Salt Lake City, and the absence of the brothel was pointed to as evidence of the moral effect of polygamy.

The system of plural marriages left its impress all over the home life of the territory. Many of the Mormon leaders, as we have seen, had more wives than one when they made their first trip across the plains, and the practice of polygamy, while denied on occasion, was not concealed from the time the settlement was made in the valley to the date of its public proclamation. In the early days, a man with more than one wife provided for them according to his means. Young began with quarters better than the average, but modest in their way, and finally occupied the big buildings which cost him many thousands of dollars. If a man with several wives had the means to do so, he would build a long, low dwelling, with an outside door for each wife, and thus house all under the same roof in a sort of separate barracks. When Gunnison wrote, in 1852, there were many instances in which more than one wife shared the same house when it contained only one apartment, but he said: "It is usual to board out the extra ones, who most frequently pay their own way by sewing, and other female employments." Mrs. Ferris wrote: "The mass of the dwellings are small, low, and hutlike. Some of them literally swarmed with women and children, and had an aspect of extreme want of neatness.... One family, in which there were two wives, was living in a small hut -- three children very sick {with scarlet fever} -- two beds and a cook-stove in the same room, creating the air of a pest-house."¹

Hyde, describing the city in 1857, thus enumerated the home accommodations of some of the leaders: --

"A very pretty house on the east side was occupied by the late J. M. Grant and his five wives. A large barrack-like house on the corner is tenanted by Ezra T. Benson and his four ladies. A large but mean-looking house to the west was
_________________________
¹ "Life among the Mormons," pp. 111, 145.

--------     584     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

inhabited by the late Parley P. Pratt and his nine wives. In that long, dirty row of single rooms, half hidden by a very beautiful orchard and garden, lived Dr. Richard and his eleven wives. Wilford Woodruff and five wives reside in another large house still further west. O. Pratt and some four or five wives occupy an adjacent building. Looking toward the north, we espy a whole block covered with houses, barns, gardens, and orchards. In these dwell H. C. Kimball and his eighteen or twenty wives, their families and dependents."¹

Horace Greeley, prejudiced as he was in favor of the Mormons when he visited Salt Lake City in 1859, was forced to observe: --

"The degradation (or, if you please, the restriction) of woman to the single office of childbearing and its accessories is an inevitable consequence of the system here paramount. I have not observed a sign in the streets, an advertisement in the journals, of this Mormon metropolis, whereby a woman proposes to do anything whatever. No Mormon has ever cited to me his wife's or any woman's opinion on any subject; no Mormon woman has been introduced or spoken to me; and, though I have been asked to visit Mormons in their houses, no one has spoken of his wife (or wives) desiring to see me, or his desiring me to make her (or their) acquaintance, or voluntarily indicated the existence of such a being or beings."²

Woman's natural jealousy, and the suffering that a loving wife would endure when called upon to share her husband's affection and her home with other women, would seem to form a sort of natural check to polygamous marriages. But in Utah this check was overcome both by the absolute power of the priesthood over their flock, and by the adroit device of making polygamy not merely permissive, but essential to eternal salvation. That the many wives of even so exalted a prophet as Brigham Young could become rebellious is shown by the language employed by him in his discourse of September 21, 1856, of which the following will suffice as a specimen: --

"Men will say, 'My wife, though a most excellent woman, has not seen a happy day since I took my second wife; no, not a happy day for a year.'... I wish my women to understand that what I am going to say is for them, as well as all others, and I want those who are here to tell their sisters, yes, all the women in this community, and then write it back to the states, and do as you please with it. I am going to give you from this time till the 6th day of October next for reflection,
_________________________
¹ "Mormonism," p. 34. The number of wives of the church leaders decreased in later years. Beadle, giving the number of wives "supposed to appertain to each" in 1882, credits President Taylor with four (three having died), and the Apostles with an average of three each, Erastus Snow having five, and four others only two each.
² "Overland journey," p. 217.

-----                        SOCIAL ASPECTS OF POLYGAMY                       585  -----

that you may determine whether you wish to stay with your husbands or not, and then I am going to set every woman at liberty, and say to them, 'Now go your way, my women with the rest; go your way.' And my wives have got to do one of two things; either round up their shoulders to endure the afflictions of this world, and live their religion, or they may leave, for I will not have them about me. I will go into heaven alone, rather than have scratching and fighting all around me. I will set all at liberty. What, first wife too?' Yes, I will liberate you all. I know what my women will say; they will say, 'You can have as many women as you please, Brigham.' But I want to go somewhere and do something to get rid of the whiners.... Sisters, I am not joking."¹

Grant, on the same day, in connection with his presentation of the doctrine of blood atonement, declared that there was "scarcely a mother in Israel" who would not, if they could, "break asunder the cable of the Church in Christ; and they talk it to their husbands, to their daughters, and to their neighbors, and say that they have not seen a week's happiness since they became acquainted with that law, or since their husbands took a second wife."² The coarse and plain-spoken H. C. Kimball, in a discourse in the Tabernacle, November 9, 1856, thus defined the duty of polygamous wives, "It is the duty of a woman to be obedient to her husband, and, unless she is, I would not give a damn for all her queenly right or authority, nor for her either, if she will quarrel and lie about the work of God and the principles of plurality."³

Gentile observers were amazed, in the earlier days of Utah, to see to what lengths the fanatical teachings of the church officers would be accepted by women. Thus Mrs. Ferris found that the explanation of the willingness of many young women in Utah to be married to venerable church officers, who already had harems, was their belief that they could only be "saved" if married or sealed to a faithful Saint, and that an older man was less likely to apostatize, and so carry his wives to perdition with him, than a young one; therefore "it became an object with these silly fools to get into the harems of the priests and elders."

If this advantage of the church officers in the selection of new wives did not avail, other means were employed,⁴ as in the notorious San Pete case. The officers remaining at home did not hesitate to insist on a fair division of the spoils (that is, the
_________________________
¹ Journal of Discourses, Vol. IV, p. 55.
² Ibid, p. 52.
³ Deseret News, Vol. VI, p. 291.
⁴ Conan Doyle's story, "A Study in scarlet," is founded on the use of this power.

--------     586     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

marriageable immigrants), as is shown by the following remarks of Heber C. Kimball to some missionaries about starting out: "Let truth and righteousness be your motto, and don't go into the world for anything but to preach the Gospel, build up the Kingdom of God, and gather the sheep into the fold. You are sent out as shepherds to gather the sheep together; and remember that they are not your sheep; they belong to Him that sends you. Then don't make a choice of any of those sheep; don't make selections before they are brought home and put into the fold. You understand that. Amen." Mr. Ferris thus described the use of his priestly power made by Wilford Woodruff, who, as head of the church in later years, gave out the advice about abandoning polygamy: "Woodruff has a regular system of changing his harem. He takes in one or more young girls, and so manages, after he tires of them, that they are glad to ask for a divorce, after which he beats the bush for recruits. He took a fresh one, about fourteen years old, in March, 1853, and will probably get rid of her in the course of the ensuing summer."¹

Mrs. Waite thus relates a conversation she had with a Mormon wife about her husband going into polygamy: --

"'Oh, it is hard,' she said, 'very hard; but no matter, we must bear it. It is a correct principle, and there is no salvation without it. We had one {wife} but it was so hard, both for my husband and myself, that we could not endure it, and she left us at the end of seven months. She had been with us as a servant several months, and was a good girl; but as soon as she was made a wife she became insolent, and told me she had as good a right to the house and things as I had, and you know that didn't suit me well. But,' continued she, 'I wish we had kept her, and I had borne everything, for we have got to have one, and don't you think it would be pleasanter to have one you had known than a stranger?'"²

The voice which the first wife had in the matter was defined in the Seer (Vol. I, p. 41). If she objected, she could state her objection to President Young, who, if he found the reason sufficient, could forbid the marriage; but if he considered that her reason was not good, then the marriage could take place, and "he {the husband} will be justified, and she will be condemned, because she did not give them unto him as Sarah gave Hagar to Abraham,
_________________________
¹ "Utah and the Mormons," p. 255.
² "The Mormon Prophet," p. 260. Many accounts of the feeling of first wives regarding polygamy may be found in this book and in Mrs. Stenhouse's "Tell it All."

-----                        SOCIAL ASPECTS OF POLYGAMY                       587  -----

and as Rachel and Leah gave Bilhah and Zilpah to their husband, Jacob." Young's dictatorship in the choice of wives was equally absolute. "No man in Utah," said the Seer (Vol. I, p. 31), "who already has a wife, and who may desire to obtain another, has any right to make any proposition of marriage to a lady until he has consulted the President of the whole church, and through him obtained a revelation from God as to whether it would be pleasing in His sight."

The authority of the priesthood was always exerted to compel at least every prominent member of the church to take more wives than one. "For a man to be confined to one woman is a small business," said Kimball in the Tabernacle, on April 4, 1857. This influence coerced Stenhouse to take as his second wife a fourteen-year-old daughter of Parley P. Pratt, although he loved his legal wife, and she had told him that she would not live with him if he married again, and although his intimate friend, Superintendent Cooke, of the Overland Stage Company, to save him, threatened to prosecute him under the law against bigamy if he yielded.¹ Another illustration, given by Mrs. Waite, may be cited. Kimball, calling on a Prussian immigrant named Taussig one day, asked him how he was doing and how many wives he had, and on being told that he had two, replied, "That is not enough. You must take a couple more. I'll send them to you." The narrative continues: --

"On the following evening, when the brother returned home, he found two women sitting there. His first wife said, 'Brother Taussig' (all the women call their husbands brother), 'these are the Sisters Pratt.' They were two widows of Parley P. Pratt. One of the ladies, Sarah, then said, 'Brother Taussig, Brother Kimball told us to call on you, and you know what for.' 'Yes, ladies,' replied Brother Taussig, 'but it is a very hard task for me to marry two' The other remarked, 'Brother Kimball told us you were doing a very good business and could support more women.' Sarah then took up the conversation, 'Well, Brother Taussig, I want to get married anyhow.' The good brother replied, 'Well, ladies, I will see what I can do and let you know.'"²

Brother Taussig compromised the matter with the Bishop of his ward by marrying Sarah, but she did not like her new home,
_________________________
¹ When Mr. and Mrs. Stenhouse left the church at the time of the "New Movement" their daughter, who was a polygamous wife of Brigham Young's son, decided with the church and refused even to speak with her parents.
² "The Mormon Prophet," p. 258.

--------     588     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

and he was allowed to divorce her on payment of $10 to Brigham Young!

Each polygamous family was, of course, governed in accordance with the character of its head: a kind man would treat all his wives kindly, however decided a preference he might show for one; and under a brute all would be unhappy. Young, in his earlier days at Salt Lake City, used to assemble all his family for prayers, and have a kind word for each of the women, and all ate at a common table after his permanent residences were built. "Brigham's wives," says Hyde, "although poorly clothed and hardworked, are still very infatuated with their system, very devout in their religion, very devoted to their children. They content themselves with his kindness as they cannot obtain his love."¹ He kept no servants, the wives performing all the household work, and one of them acting as teacher to her own and the others' children. As the excuse for marriage with the Mormons is childbearing,² the older wives were practically discarded, taking the place of examples of piety and of spiritual advisers.

A summing up of the many-sided evils of polygamy was thus presented by President Cleveland in his first annual message: --

"The strength, the perpetuity, and the destiny of the nation rests upon our homes, established by the law of God, guarded by parental care, regulated by parental authority, and sanctified by parental love. These are not the homes of polygamy.

"The mothers of our land, who rule the nation as they mould the characters and guide the actions of their sons, live according to God's holy ordinances, and each, secure and happy in the exclusive love of the father of her children, sheds the warm light of true womanhood, unperverted and unpolluted, upon all within
_________________________
¹ "Mormonism," p. 164.
² How far this doctrine was not observed may be noted in the following remarks of H. C. Kimball in the Tabernacle, on February 1, 1857: "They {his wives} have got to live their religion, serve their God, and do right as well as myself. Suppose that I lose the whole of them before I go into the spiritual world, but that I have been a good, faithful man all the days of my life, and lived my religion, and had favor with God, and was kind to them, do you think I will be destitute there? No. The Lord says there are more there than there are here. They have been increasing there; they increase there a great deal faster than they do here, because there is no obstruction. They do not call upon the doctors to kill their offspring. In this world very many of the doctors are studying to diminish the human race. In the spiritual world... we will go to Brother Joseph... and he will say to us, 'Come along, my boys, we will give you a good suit of clothes. Where are your wives?' 'They are back yonder; they would not follow us.' 'Never mind,' says Joseph, 'here are thousands; have all you want.'" -- Journal of Discourses, Vol. IV, p.

-----                        SOCIAL ASPECTS OF POLYGAMY                       589  -----

her pure and wholesome family circle. These are not the cheerless, crushed, and unwomanly mothers of polygamy.

"The fathers of our families are the best citizens of the Republic. Wife and children are the sources of patriotism, and conjugal and parental affection beget devotion to the country. The man who, undefiled with plural marriage, is surrounded in his single home with his wife and children, has a status in the country which inspires him with respect for its laws and courage for its defence. These are not the fathers of polygamous families."

-------- [ 590 ] --------

CHAPTER XXIV

THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD
THE first measure "to punish and prevent the practice of polygamy in the Territories of the United States" was introduced in the House of Representatives by Mr. Morrill of Vermont (Bill No. 7) at the first session of the 36th Congress, on February 15, 1860. It contained clauses annulling some of the acts of the territorial legislature of Utah, including the one incorporating the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. This bill was reported by the Judiciary Committee on March 14, the committee declaring that "no argument was deemed necessary to prove that an act could be regarded as criminal which is so treated by the universal concurrence of the Christian and civilized world," and characterizing the church incorporation act as granting "such monstrous powers and arrogant assumptions as are at war with the genius of our government." The bill passed the House on April 5, by a vote of 149 to 60, was favorably reported to the Senate by Mr. Bayard from the Judiciary Committee on June 13, but did not pass that House.

Mr. Morrill introduced his bill by unanimous consent in the next Congress (on April 8, 1862), and it was passed by the House on April 28. Mr. Bayard, from the judiciary Committee, reported it back to the Senate on June 3 with amendments. He explained that the House Bill punished not only polygamous marriages, but cohabitation without marriage. The committee recommended limiting the punishment to bigamy -- a fine not to exceed $500 and imprisonment for not more than five years. Another amendment limited the amount of real estate which a church corporation could hold in the territories to $50,000. The bill passed the Senate with the negative votes of only the two California senators, and the House accepted the amendments. Lincoln signed it.

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           591  -----

Nothing practical was accomplished by this legislation, In 1867 George A. Smith and John Taylor, the presiding officers of the Utah legislature, petitioned Congress to repeal this act, setting forth as one reason that "the judiciary of this territory has not, up to the present time, tried any case under said law, though repeatedly urged to do so by those who have been anxious to test its constitutionality." The House Judiciary Committee reported that this was a practical request for the sanctioning of polygamy, and said: "Your committee has not been able to ascertain the reason why this law has not been enforced. The humiliating fact is, however, apparent that the law is at present practically a dead letter in the Territory of Utah, and that the gravest necessity exists for its enforcement; and, in the opinion of the committee, if it be through the fault or neglect of the judiciary of that territory that the laws are not enforced, the judges should be removed without delay; and that, if the failure to execute the law arises from other causes, it becomes the duty of the President of the United States to see that the law is faithfully executed."¹

In June, 1866, Senator Benjamin Wade of Ohio obtained unanimous consent to introduce a bill enacting radical legislation concerning such marriages as were performed and sanctioned by the Mormon church, but it did not pass. Senator Cragin of New Hampshire soon introduced a similar bill, but it, too failed to become a law.

In 1869, in the first Congress that met under President Grant, Mr. Cullom of Illinois introduced in the House the bill aimed at polygamy that was designated by his name. This bill was the practical starting-point of the anti-polygamous legislation subsequently enacted, as over it was aroused the feeling -- in its behalf in the East and against it in Utah -- that resulted impractical legislation.

Delegate Hooper made the leading speech against it, summing up his objections as follows: --

"(1) That under our constitution we are entitled to be protected in the full and free enjoyment of our religious faith.
"(2) That our views of the marriage relation are an essential portion of our religious faith.
"(3) That, in conceding the cognizance of the marriage relation as within
_________________________
¹ House Report No. 27, 2nd Session, 39th Congress.

--------     592     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

the province of church regulations, we are practically in accord with all other Christian denominations."
(4) That in our view of the marriage relation as a part of our religious belief we are entitled to immunity from persecution under the constitution, if such views are sincerely held; that, if such views are erroneous, their eradication must be by argument and not by force."

The bill, greatly amended, passed the House on March 23, 1870, by a vote of 94 to 32. The news of this action caused perhaps the greatest excitement ever known in Utah. There was no intention on the part of the Mormons to make any compromise on the question, and they set out to defeat the bill outright in the Senate. Meetings of Mormon women were gotten up in all parts of the territory, in which they asserted their devotion to the doctrine. The "Reformers," including Stenhouse, Harrison, Tullidge, and others, and merchants like Walker Brothers, Colonel Kahn, and T. Marshall, joined in a call for a mass-meeting at which all expressed disapproval of some of its provisions, like the one requiring men already having polygamous wives to break up their families. Mr. Godbe went to Washington while the bill was before the House, and worked hard for its modification. The bill did not pass the Senate, a leading argument against it being the assumed impossibility of convicting polygamists under it with any juries drawn in Utah.

The arrest of Brigham Young and others under the act to punish adulterers, and the proceedings against them before Judge McKean in 1871, have been noted. At the same term of the court Thomas Hawkins, an English immigrant, was convicted of the same charge on the evidence of his wife, and sentenced to imprisonment for three years and to pay a fine of $500. In passing sentence, Judge McKean told the prisoner that, if he let him off with a fine, the fine would be paid out of other funds than his own; that he would thus go free, and that "those men who mislead the people would make you and thousands of others believe that God had sent the money to pay the fine; that, by a miracle, you had been rescued from the authorities of the United States."

After the passage of the Poland law, in 1874, George Reynolds, Brigham Young's private secretary, was convicted of bigamy under the law of 1862, but was set free by the Supreme Court of the territory on the ground of illegality in the drawing of the grand

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           593  -----

jury. In the following year he was again convicted, and was sentenced to imprisonment for two years and to pay a fine of $500. The case was appealed to the United States Supreme Court, which rendered its decision in October, 1878, unanimously sustaining the conviction, except that Justice Field objected to the admission of one witness's testimony.

In its decision the court stated the question raised to be "whether religious belief can be accepted as a justification for an overt act made criminal by the law of the land." Next came a discussion of views of religious freedom, as bearing on the meaning of "religion" in the federal constitution, leading up to the conclusion that "Congress was deprived of all legislative power over mere opinion, but was left free to reach actions which were in violation of social duties, or subversive of good order." The court then traced the view of polygamy in England and the United States from the time when it was made a capital offence in England (as it was in Virginia in 1788), declaring that, "in the face of all this evidence, it is impossible to believe that the constitutional guaranty of religious freedom was intended to prohibit legislation in respect to this most important feature of social life." The opinion continued as follows: --

"In our opinion, the statute immediately under consideration is within the legislative power of Congress. It is constitutional and valid as prescribing a rule of action for all those residing in the Territories, and in places over which the United States has exclusive control. This being so, the only question which remains is, whether those who make polygamy a part of their religion are excepted from the operation of the statute. If they are, then those who do not make polygamy a part of their religious belief may be found guilty and punished, while those who do, must be acquitted and go free. This would be introducing a new element into criminal law. Laws are made for the government of actions, and, while they cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices. Suppose one believed that human sacrifices were a necessary part of religious worship, would it be seriously contended that the civil government under which he lived could not interfere to prevent a sacrifice? Or, if a wife religiously believed it was her duty to burn herself on the funeral pile of her dead husband, would it be beyond the power of the civil government to prevent her carrying her belief into practice?

"So here, as a law of the organization of society under the exclusive dominion of the United States, it is provided that plural marriages shall not be allowed. Can a man excuse his practices to the contrary because of his religious belief? To permit this would be to make the professed doctrines of religious belief superior

--------     594     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

to the law of the land, and in effect to permit every citizen to become a law unto himself. Government could exist only in name under such circumstances." A criminal intent is generally an element of crime, but every man is presumed to intend the necessary and legitimate consequences of what he knowingly does. Here the accused knew he had been once married, and that his first wife was living. He also knew that his second marriage was forbidden by law. When, therefore, he married the second time, he is presumed to have intended to break the law, and the breaking of the law is the crime. Every act necessary to constitute the crime was knowingly done, and the crime was therefore knowingly committed.¹

P. T. Van Zile of Michigan, who became district attorney of the territory in 1878, tried John Miles, a polygamist, for bigamy, in 1879, and he was convicted, the prosecutor taking advantage of the fact that the territorial legislature had practically adopted the California code, which allowed challenges of jurors for actual bias. The principal incident of this trial was the summoning of "General" Wells, then a counsellor of the church, as a witness, and his refusal to describe the dress worn during the ceremonies in the Endowment House, and the ceremonies themselves. He gave as his excuse, "because I am under moral and sacred obligations to not answer, and it is interwoven in my character never to betray a friend, a brother, my country, my God, or my religion." He was sentenced to pay a fine, of $100, and to two days' imprisonment. On his release, the City Council met him at the prison door and escorted him home, accompanied by bands of music and a procession made up of the benevolent, fire, and other organizations, and delegations from every ward.

Governor Emery, in his message to the territorial legislature of 1878, spoke as plainly about polygamy as any of his predecessors, saying that it was a grave crime, even if the law against it was a dead letter, and characterizing it as an evil endangering the peace of society.

There was a lull in the agitation against polygamy in Congress for some years after the contest over the Cullom Bill. In 1878 a mass-meeting of women of Salt Lake City opposed to polygamy was held there, and an address "to Mrs. Rutherford B. Hayes and the women of the United States," and a petition to Congress, were adopted, and a committee was appointed to distribute the petition throughout the country for signatures. The address set forth that
_________________________
¹ United States Reports, Otto, Vol. III, p. 162.

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           595  -----

there had been more polygamous marriages in the last year than ever before in the history of the Mormon church; that Endowment Houses, under the name of temples, and costing millions, were being erected in different parts of the territory in which the members were "sealed and bound by oaths so strong that even apostates will not reveal them;" that the Mormons had the balance of power in two territories, and were plotting to extend it; and asking Congress "to arrest the further progress of this evil."

President Hayes, in his annual message in December, 1879, spoke of the recent decision of the United States Supreme Court, and said that there was no reason for longer delay in the enforcement of the law, urging "more comprehensive and searching methods" of punishing and preventing polygamy if they were necessary. He returned to the subject in his message in 1880, saying: "Polygamy can only be suppressed by taking away the political power of the sect which encourages and sustains it.... I recommend that Congress provide for the government of Utah by a Governor and judges, or Commissioners, appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate, (or) that the right to vote, hold office, or sit on juries in the Territory of Utah be confined to those who neither practise nor uphold polygamy."

President Garfield took up the subject in his inaugural address on March 4, 1881. "The Mormon church," he said, "not only offends the moral sense of mankind by sanctioning polygamy, but prevents the administration of justice through ordinary instrumentalities of law." He expressed the opinion that Congress should prohibit polygamy, and not allow "any ecclesiastical organization to usurp in the smallest degree the functions and power, of the national government." President Arthur, in his message in December, 1881, referred to the difficulty of securing convictions of persons accused of polygamy -- "this odious crime, so revolting to the moral and religious sense of Christendom" -- and recommended legislation.

In the spirit of these recommendations, Senator Edmunds introduced in the Senate, on December 12, 1881, a comprehensive measure amending the anti-polygamy law of 1862, which, amended during the course of the debate, was passed in the Senate on February 12, 1882, without a roll-call,¹ and in the House on March 13,
_________________________
¹ Speeches against the bill were made in the Senate by Brown, Call, Lamar, Morgan, Pendleton, and Vest.

--------     596     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

by a vote of 199 to 42, and was approved by the President on March 22. This is what is known as the Edmunds law -- the first really serious blow struck by Congress against polygamy.

It provided, in brief, that, in the territories, any person who, having a husband or wife living, marries another, or marries more than one woman on the same day, shall be punished by a fine of not more than $500, and by imprisonment, for not more than five years; that a male person cohabiting with more than one woman shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and be subject to a fine of not more than $300 or to six months' imprisonment, or both; that in any prosecution for bigamy, polygamy, or unlawful cohabitation, a juror may be challenged if he is or has been living in the practice of either offence, or if he believes it right for a man to have more than one living and undivorced wife at a time, or to cohabit with more than one woman; that the President may have power to grant amnesty to offenders, as described, before the passage of this act; that the issue of so-called Mormon marriages born before January 1, 1883, be legitimated; that no polygamist shall be entitled to vote in any territory, or to hold office under the United States; that the President shall appoint in Utah a board of five persons for the registry of voters, and the reception and counting of votes.

To meet the determined opposition to the new law, an amendment (known as the Edmunds-Tucker law) was enacted in 1887. This law, in any prosecution coming under the definition of plural marriages, waived the process of subpoena, on affidavit of sufficient cause, in favor of an attachment; allowed a lawful husband or wife to testify regarding each other; required every marriage certificate in Utah to be signed by the parties and the person performing the ceremony, and filed in court; abolished female suffrage, and gave suffrage only to males of proper age who registered and took an oath, giving the names of their lawful wives, and promised to obey the laws of the United States, and especially the Edmunds law; disqualified as a juror or officeholder any person who had not taken an oath to support the laws of the United States, or who had been convicted under the Edmunds law; gave the President power to appoint the judges of the probate courts;¹ provided for escheating to the United States for the
_________________________
¹ The first territorial legislature which met after the passage of this law passed an act practically nullifying such appointments of probate judges, but the governor vetoed

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           597  -----

use of the common schools the property of corporations held in violation of the act in 1862, except buildings held exclusively for the worship of God, the parsonages connected therewith, and burial places; dissolved the corporation called the Perpetual Emigration Company, and forbade the legislature to pass any law to bring persons into the territory; dissolved the corporation known as the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, and gave the Supreme Court of the territory power to wind up its affairs; and annulled all laws regarding the Nauvoo Legion, and all acts of the territorial legislature.

The first members of the Utah commission appointed under the Edmunds law were Alexander Ramsey of Minnesota, A. B. Carleton of Indiana, A. S. Paddock of Nebraska, G. L. Godfrey of Iowa, and J. R. Pettigrew of Arkansas, their appointments being dated June 23, 1882.

The officers of the church and the Mormons as a body met the new situation as aggressively as did Brigham Young the approach of United States troops. Their preachers and their newspapers reiterated the divine nature of the "revelation" concerning polygamy and its obligatory character, urging the people to standby their leaders in opposition to the new laws. The following extracts from "an Epistle from the First Presidency, to the officers and members of the church," dated October 6, 1885, will sufficiently illustrate the attitude of the church organization: --

"The war is openly and undisguisedly made upon our religion. To induce men to repudiate that, to violate its precepts, and break its solemn covenants, every encouragement is given. The man who agrees to discard his wife or wives, and to trample upon the most sacred obligations which human beings can enter into, escapes imprisonment, and is applauded: while the man who will not make this compact of dishonor, who will not admit that his past life has been a fraud and a lie, who will not say to the world, 'I intended to deceive my God, my brethren, and my wives by making covenants I did not expect to keep,' is, beside being punished to the full extent of the law, compelled to endure the reproaches, taunts, and insults of a brutal judge....

"We did not reveal celestial marriage. We cannot withdraw or renounce it, God revealed it, and he has promised to maintain it and to bless those who obey it. Whatever fate, then, may threaten us, there is but one course for men of God to take; that is, to keep inviolate the holy covenants they have made in the
_________________________
it. In Beaver County, as soon as the appointment of a probate judge by the President was announced, the Mormon County Court met and reduced his salary to $5 a year.

--------     598     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

presence of God and angels. For the remainder, whether it be life or death, freedom or imprisonment, prosperity or adversity, we must trust in God. We may say, however, if any man or woman expects to enter into the celestial kingdom of our God without making sacrifices and without being tested to the very uttermost, they have not understood the Gospel....

"Upward of forty years ago the Lord revealed to his church the principle of celestial marriage. The idea of marrying more wives than one was as naturally abhorrent to the leading men and women of the church, at that day, as it could be to any people. They shrank with dread from the bare thought of entering into such relationship. But the command of God was before them in language which no faithful soul dare disobey, 'For, behold, I reveal unto you a new and everlasting covenant; and if ye abide not that covenant, then are ye damned; for no one can reject this covenant, and be permitted to enter into my glory.'... Who would suppose that any man, in this land of religious liberty, would presume to say to his fellow-man that he had no right to take such steps as he thought necessary to escape damnation? Or that Congress would enact a law which would present the alternative to religious believers of being consigned to a penitentiary if they should attempt to obey a law of God which would deliver them from damnation?"

There was a characteristic effort to evade the law as regards political rights. The People's Party (Mormon), to get around the provision concerning the test oath for voters, issued an address to them which said: "The questions that intending voters need therefore ask themselves are these: Are we guilty of the crimes of said act; or have we the present intention of committing these crimes, or of aiding, abetting, causing or advising any other person to commit them. Male citizens who can answer these questions in the negative can qualify under the laws as voters or office-holders."

Two events in 1885 were the cause of so much feeling that United States troops were held in readiness for transportation to Utah. The first of these was the placing of the United States flag at half mast in Salt Lake City, on July 4, over the city hall, county court-house, theatre, cooperative store, Deseret News office, tithing office, and President Taylor's residence, to show the Mormon opinion that the Edmunds law had destroyed liberty. When a committee of non-Mormon citizens called at the city hall for an explanation of this display, the city marshal said that it was "a whim of his," and the mayor ordered the flag raised to its proper place.

In November of that year a Mormon night watchman named

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           599  -----

McMurrin was shot and severely wounded by a United States deputy marshal named Collin. This caused great feeling, and there were rumors that the Mormons threatened to lynch Collin, that armed men had assembled to take him out of the officers' hands, and that the Mormons of the territory were arming themselves, and were ready at a moment's notice to march into Salt Lake City. Federal troops were held in readiness at Eastern points, but they were not used. The Salt Lake City Council, on December 8, made a report denying the truth of the disquieting rumors, and declaring that "at no time in the history of this city have the lives and property of its non-Mormon inhabitants been more secure than now."

The records of the courts in Utah show that the Mormons stood ready to obey the teachings of the church at any cost. Prosecutions under the Edmunds law began in 1884, and the convictions for polygamy or unlawful cohabitation (mostly the latter) were as follows in the years named: 3 in 1884, 39 in 1885, 112 in 1886, 214 in 1887, and 100 in 1888, with 48 in Idaho during the same period. Leading men in the church went into hiding -- "under ground," as it was called -- or fled from the territory. As to the actual continuance of polygamous marriages, the evidence was contradictory. A special report of the Utah Commission in 1884 expressed the opinion that there had been a decided decrease in their number in the cities, and very little decrease in the rural districts. Their regular report for that year estimated the number of males and females who had entered into that relation at 459. The report for 1888 stated that the registration officers gave the names of 29 females who, they had good reason to believe, had contracted polygamous marriages since the lists were closed in June, 1887. As late as 1889 Hans Jespersen was arrested for unlawful cohabitation. As his plural marriage was understood to be a recent one, the case attracted wide attention, since it was expected to prove the insincerity of the church in making the protest against the Edmunds law principally on the ground that it broke up existing families. Jespersen pleaded guilty of adultery and polygamy, and was sentenced to imprisonment for eight years. In making his plea he said that he was married at the Endowment House in Salt Lake City, that he and his wife were the only persons there, and that he did not know who married them. His wife

--------     600     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

testified that she "heard a voice pronounce them man and wife, but didn't see anyone nor who spoke."¹ Such were some of the methods adopted by the church to set at naught the law.

But along with this firm attitude, influences were at work looking to a change of policy. During the first year of the enforcement of the law it was on many sides declared a failure, the aggressive attitude of the church, and the willingness of its leaders to accept imprisonment, hiding, or exile, being regarded by many persons in the East as proof that the real remedy for the Utah situation was yet to be discovered. The Utah Commission, in their earlier reports, combated this idea, and pointed out that the young men in the church would grow restive as they saw all the offices out of their reach unless they took the test oath, and that they "would present an anomaly in human nature if they should fail to be strongly influenced against going into a relation which thus subjects them to political ostracism, and fixes on them the stigma of moral turpitude." How wide this influence was is seen in the political statistics of the times. When the Utah Commission entered on their duties in August, 1882, almost every office in the territory was held by a polygamist. By April, 1884, about 12,000 voters, male and female, had been disfranchised by the act, and of the 1351 elective officers in the territory not one was a polygamist, and not one of the municipal officers of Salt Lake City then in office had ever been "in polygamy."

The church leaders at first tried to meet this influence in two ways, by open rebuke of all Saints who showed a disposition to obey the new laws, and by special honors to those who took their punishment. Thus, the Deseret News told the brethren that they could not promise to obey the anti-polygamy laws without violating obligations that bound them to time and eternity; and when John Sharp, a leading member of the church in Salt Lake City, went before the court and announced his intention to obey these laws, he was instantly removed from the office of Bishop of his ward.

The restlessness of the flock showed itself in the breaking down of the business barriers set up by the church between Mormons and Gentiles. This subject received a good deal of attention in the minority report signed by two of the commissioners in 1888. They noted the sale of real estate by Mormons to Gentiles against
_________________________
¹ Report of the Utah Commission for 1890, p. 23.

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           601  -----

the remonstrances of the church, the organization of a Chamber of Commerce in Salt Lake City in which Mormons and Gentiles worked together, and the union of both elements in the last Fourth of July celebration.

In the spring of 1890, at the General Conference held in Salt Lake City, the office of "Prophet, Seer and Revelator and President" of the church, that had remained vacant since the death of John Taylor in 1887, was filled by the election of Wilford Woodruff, a polygamist who had refused to take the test oath, while G. Q. Cannon and Lorenzo Snow, who were disfranchised for the same cause, were made respectively counsellor and president of the Twelve.¹ Woodruff was born in Connecticut in 1807, became a Mormon in 1832, was several times sent on missions to England, and had gained so much prominence while the church was at Nauvoo that he was the chief dedicator of the Temple there. While there, he signed a certificate stating that he knew of no other system of marriage in the church but the one-wife system then prescribed in the "Book of Doctrine and Covenants." Before the date of his promotion, Woodruff had declared that plural marriages were no longer permitted, and, when he was confronted with evidence to the contrary brought out in court, he denied all knowledge of it, and afterward declared that, in consequence of the evidence presented, he had ordered the Endowment House to be taken down.

Governor Thomas, in his report for 1890, expressed the opinion that the church, under its system, could in only one way define its position regarding polygamy, and that was by a public declaration by the head of the church, or by action by a conference, and he added, "There is no reason to believe that any earthly power can extort from the church any such declaration." The governor was mistaken, not in measuring the purpose of the church, but in foreseeing all the influences that were now making themselves felt.

The revised statutes of Idaho at this time contained a provision (Sec. 509) disfranchising all polygamists and debarring from office all polygamists, and all persons who counselled or encouraged
_________________________
¹ Lorenzo Snow was elected president of the church on September 13, 1898, eleven days after the death of President Woodruff, and he held that position until his death which occurred on October 10, 1901.

--------     602     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

any one to commit polygamy. The constitutionality of this section was argued before the United States Supreme Court, which, on February 3, 1890, decided that it was constitutional. The anti-polygamists in Utah saw in this decision a means of attacking the Mormon belief even more aggressively than had been done by means of the Edmunds Bill. An act was drawn (Governor Thomas and ex-Governor West taking it to Washington) providing that no person living in plural or celestial marriage, or teaching the same, or being a member of, or a contributor to, any organization teaching it, or assisting in such a marriage, should be entitled to vote, to serve as a juror, or to hold office, a test oath forming a part of the act. Senator Cullom introduced this bill in the upper House and Mr. Struble of Iowa in the House of Representatives. The House Committee on Territories (the Democrats in the negative) voted to report the bill, amended so as to make it applicable to all the territories. This proposed legislation caused great excitement in Mormondom, and petitions against its passage were hurried to Washington, some of these containing non-Mormon signatures.

As a further menace to the position of the church, the United States Supreme Court, on May 19, affirmed the decision of the lower court confiscating the property of the Mormon church, and declaring that church organization to be an organized rebellion; and on June 21, the Senate passed Senator Edmunds's bill disposing of the real estate of the church for the benefit of the school fund.¹

The Mormon authorities now realized that the public sentiment of the country, as expressed in the federal law, had them in its grasp. They must make some concession to this public sentiment, or surrender all their privileges as citizens and the wealth of their church organization. Agents were hurried to Washington to implore the aid of Mr. Blaine in checking the progress of the Cullom Bill, and at home the head of the church made the concession in regard to polygamy which secured the admission of the territory as a state.

On September 25, 1890, Woodruff, as President of the church, issued a proclamation addressed "to whom it may concern," which struck out of the NECESSARY beliefs and practices of the Mormon church, the practice of polygamy.
_________________________
¹ After the admission of Utah as a state, Congress passed an act restoring the property to the church.

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           603  -----

This important step was taken, not in the form of a "revelation, "but simply as a proclamation or manifesto. It began with a solemn declaration that the allegation of the Utah Commission that plural marriages were still being solemnized was false, and the assertion that "we are not preaching polygamy nor permitting any person to enter into its practice." The closing and important part of the proclamation was as follows: --

"Inasmuch as laws have been enacted by Congress, which laws have been pronounced constitutional by the court of last resort, I hereby declare my intention to submit to these laws, and to use my influence with the members of the church over which I preside to have them do likewise.

"There is nothing in my teachings to the church, or in those of my associates, during the time specified, which can be reasonably construed to inculcate or encourage polygamy, and when any elder of the church has used language which appeared to convey any such teachings he has been promptly reproved.

"And now I publicly declare that my advice to the Latter-Day Saints is to refrain from contracting any marriage forbidden by the law of the land."

On October 6, the General Conference of the church, on motion of Lorenzo Snow, unanimously adopted the following resolution: --

"I move that, recognizing Wilford Woodruff as President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, and the only man on the earth at the present time who holds the keys of the sealing ordinances, we consider him fully authorized, by virtue of his position, to issue the manifesto that has been read in our hearing, and which is dated September 24, 1890, and as a church in general conference assembled we accept his declaration concerning plural marriages as authoritative and binding."

This action was reaffirmed by the General Conference of October 6, 1891.

Of course the church officers had to make some explanation to the brethren of their change of front. Cannon fell back on the "revelation" of January 19, 1841, which Smith put forth to excuse the failure to establish a Zion in Missouri, namely, that, when their enemies prevent their performing a task assigned by the Almighty, he would accept their effort to do so. He said that "it was on this basis" that President Woodruff had felt justified in issuing the manifesto. Woodruff explained: "It is not wisdom for us to make war upon 65,000,000 people.... The prophet {Joseph Smith} organized the church; and all that he has promised in this code of revelations {the "Book of Doctrine and Covenants"} has

--------     604     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

been fulfilled as fast as time would permit. That which is not fulfilled will be." Cannon did explain that the manifesto was the result of prayer, and Woodruff told the people that he had had a great many visits from the Prophet Joseph since his death, in dreams, and also from Brigham Young, but neither seems to have imparted any very valuable information, Joseph explaining that he was in an immense hurry preparing himself "to go to the earth with the Great Bridegroom when he goes to meet the Bride, the Lamb's wife."

Two recent incidents have indicated the restlessness of the Mormon church under the restriction placed upon polygamy. In 1898, the candidate for Representative in Congress, nominated by the Democratic Convention of Utah, was Brigham H. Roberts. It was commonly known in Utah that Roberts was a violator of the Edmunds law. A Mormon elder, writing from Brigham, Utah, in February, 1899, while Roberts's case was under consideration at Washington, said, "Many prominent Mormons foresaw the storm that was now raging, and deprecated Mr. Roberts's nomination and election."¹ This statement proves both the notoriety of Roberts's offence, and the connivance of the church in his nomination, because no Mormon can be nominated to an office in Utah when the church authorities order otherwise. When Roberts presented himself to be sworn in, in December, 1899, his case was referred to a special committee of nine members. The report of seven members of this committee found that Roberts married his first wife about the year 1878; that about 1885 he married a plural wife, who had since born him six children, the last two twins, born on August 11, 1897; that some years later he married a second plural wife, and that he had been living with all three till the time of his election; "that these facts were generally known in Utah, publicly charged against him during his campaign for election, and were not denied by him." Roberts refused to take the stand before the committee, and demurred to its jurisdiction on the ground that the hearing was an attempt to try him for a crime without an indictment and jury trial, and to deprive him of vested rights in the emoluments of the office to which he was elected, and that, if the crime alleged was proved, it would not constitute a sufficient cause to deprive him of his seat, because polygamy is not enumerated in the constitution
_________________________
¹ New York Evening Post, February 20, 1899.

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           605  -----

as a disqualification for the office of member of Congress. The majority report recommended that his seat be declared vacant. Two members of the committee reported that his offence afforded constitutional ground for expulsion, but not for exclusion from the House, and recommended that he be sworn in and immediately expelled. The resolution presented by the majority was adopted by the House by a vote of 268 to 50.¹

The second incident referred to was the passage by the Utah legislature in March, 1901, of a bill containing this provision: --

"No prosecution for adultery shall be commenced except on complaint of the husband or wife or relative of the accused with the first degree of consanguinity, or of the person with whom the unlawful act is alleged to have been committed, or of the father or mother of said person; and no prosecution for unlawful cohabitation shall be commenced except on complaint of the wife, or alleged plural wife of the accused; but this provision shall not apply to prosecutions under section 4208 of the Revised Statutes, 1898, defining and punishing polygamous marriages."

This bill passed the Utah senate by a vote of 11 to 7, and the house by a vote of 174 to 25. The excuse offered for it by the senator who introduced it was that it would "take away from certain agitators the opportunity to arouse periodic furors against the Mormons;" that more than half of the persons who had been polygamists had died or dissolved their polygamous relations, and that no good service could be subserved by prosecuting the remainder. This law aroused a protest throughout the country, and again the Mormon church saw that it had made a mistake, and on the 14th of March Governor H. M. Wells vetoed the bill, on grounds that may be summarized as declaring that the law would do the Mormons more harm than good. The most significant part of his message, as indicating what the Mormon authorities most dread, is contained in the following sentence: "I have every reason to believe its enactment would be the signal for a general demand upon the national Congress for a constitutional amendment directed solely against certain conditions here, a demand which, under the circumstances, would assuredly be complied with."
_________________________
¹ Roberts was tried in the district court in Salt Lake City, on April 30, 1900, on the charge of unlawful cohabitation. The case was submitted to the jury of eight men, without testimony, on an agreed statement of facts, and the jury disagreed, standing six for conviction and two for acquittal.

--------     606     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

The admission of Utah as a state followed naturally the promulgation by the Mormon church of a policy which was accepted by the non-Mormons as putting a practical end to the practice of polygamy. For the seventh time, in 1887, the Mormons had adopted a state constitution, the one ratified in that year providing that "bigamy and polygamy, being considered incompatible with 'a republican form of government,' each of them is hereby forbidden and declared a misdemeanor." The non-Mormons attacked the sincerity of this declaration, among other things pointing out the advice of the Church organ, while the constitution was before the people, that they be "as wise as serpents and as harmless as doves." Congress again refused admission.

On January 4, 1893, President Harrison issued a proclamation granting amnesty and pardon to all persons liable to the penalty of the Edmunds law "who have, since November 1, 1890, abstained from such unlawful cohabitation," but on condition that they should in future obey the laws of the United States. Until the time of Woodruff's manifesto there had been in Utah only two political parties, the People's, as the Mormon organization had always been known, and the Liberal (anti-Mormon). On June 10,1894, the People's Territorial Central Committee adopted resolutions reciting the organization of the Republicans and Democrats of the territory, declaring that the dissensions of the past should be left behind and that the People's party should dissolve. The Republican Territorial Committee a few days later voted that a division of the people on national party lines would result only in statehood controlled by the Mormon theocracy. The Democratic committee eight days later took a directly contrary view. At the territorial election in the following August the Democrats won, the vote standing: Democratic, 14,116; Liberal, 7386; Republican, 6613.

It would have been contrary to all political precedent if the Republicans had maintained their attitude after the Democrats had expressed their willingness to receive Mormon allies. Accordingly, in September, 1891, we find the Republicans adopting a declaration that it would be wise and patriotic to accept the changes that had occurred, and denying that statehood was involved in a division of the people on national party lines.

All parties in the territory now seemed to be maneuvering for

-----         THE FIGHT AGAINST POLYGAMY -- STATEHOOD           607  -----

position. The Mormon newspaper organs expressed complete indifference about securing statehood. In Congress Mr. Caine, the Utah Delegate, introduced what was known as the "Home Rule Bill," taking the control of territorial affairs from the governor and commission. This was known as a Democratic measure, and great pressure was brought to bear on Republican leaders at Washington to show them that Utah as a state would in all probability add to the strength of the Republican column. When, at the first session of the 53d Congress, J. L. Rawlins, a Democrat who had succeeded Caine as Delegate, introduced an act to enable the people of Utah to gain admission for the territory as a state, it met with no opposition at home, passed the House of Representatives on December 13, 1893, and the Senate on July 10, 1894 (without a division in either House), and was signed by the President on July 16. The enabling act required the constitutional convention to provide "by ordinance irrevocable without the consent of the United States and the people of that state, that perfect toleration of religious sentiment shall be secured, and that no inhabitant of said state shall ever be molested in person or property on account of his or her mode of religious worship; provided, that polygamous or plural marriages are forever prohibited."

The constitutional convention held under this act met in Salt Lake City on March 4, 1895, and completed its work on May 8, following. In the election of delegates for this convention the Democrats cast about 19,000 votes, the Republicans about 21,000 and the Populists about 6500. Of the 107 delegates chosen, 48 were Democrats and 59 Republicans. The constitution adopted contained the following provisions: --

"Art. 1. Sec. 4. The rights of conscience shall never be infringed. The state shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; no religious test shall be required as a qualification for any office of public trust, or for any vote at any election; nor shall any person be incompetent as a witness or juror on account of religious belief or the absence thereof. There shall be no union of church and state, nor shall any church dominate the state or interfere with its functions. No public money or property shall be appropriated for or applied to any religious worship, exercise, or instruction, or for the support of any ecclesiastical establishment."

Art. 111. The following ordinance shall be irrevocable without the consent of the United States and the people of this state: Perfect toleration of religious sentiment is guaranteed. No inhabitant of this state shall ever be molested in

--------     608     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

person or property on account of his or her mode of religious worship; but polygamous or plural marriages are forever prohibited."

This constitution was submitted to the people on November 5,1895, and was ratified by a vote of 31,305 to 7687, the Republicans at the same election electing their entire state ticket and a majority of the legislature. On January 4, 1896, President Cleveland issued a proclamation announcing the admission of Utah as a state. The inauguration of the new state officers took place at Salt Lake City two days later. The first governor, Heber M. Wells,¹ in his inaugural address made this declaration: "Let us learn to resent the absurd attacks that are made from time to time upon our sincerity by ignorant and prejudiced persons outside of Utah, and let us learn to know and respect each other more, and thus cement and intensify the fraternal sentiments now so widespread in our community, to the end that, by a mighty unity of purpose and Christian resolution, we may be able to insure that domestic tranquillity, promote that general welfare, and secure those blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity guaranteed by the constitution of the United States."

The vote of Utah since its admission as a state has been cast as follows: --

1895. Governor
1896. President
1900. Governor
1900. President

REPUBLICAN
20,833
13,491
47,600
47,089

DEMOCRAT
18,519
64,607
44,447
44,949

_________________________
¹ Son of "General" Wells of the Nauvoo Legion.

-------- [ 609 ] --------

CHAPTER XXV

THE MORMONISM OF TODAY
AN intelligent examination of the present status of the Mormon church can be made only after acquaintance with its past history, and the policy of the men who have given it its present doctrinal and political position. The Mormon power has ever in view objects rather than methods. It always keeps those objects in view, while at times adjusting methods to circumstances, as was the case in its latest treatment of the doctrine of polygamy. The casual visitor, making a tour of observation in Utah, and the would-be student of Mormon policies who satisfies himself with reading their books of doctrine instead of their early history, is certain to acquire little knowledge of the real Mormon character and the practical Mormon ambition, and if he writes on the subject he will contribute nothing more authentic than does Schouler in his "History of the United States" wherein he calls Joseph Smith "a careful organizer," and says that "it was a part of his creed to manage well the material concerns of his people, as they fed their flocks and raised their produce." Brigham Young's constant cry was that all the Mormons asked was to be left alone. Nothing suits the purposes of the heads of the church today better than the decrease of public attention attracted to their organization since the Woodruff manifesto concerning polygamy. In trying to arrive at a reasonable decision concerning their future place in American history, one must constantly bear in mind the arguments which they have to offer to religious enthusiasts, and the political and commercial power which they have already attained and which they are constantly strengthening.

The growth of Utah in population since its settlement by the Mormons has been as follows, accepting the figures of the United States census: --

--------     610     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

1850
1860
1870
1880
1890
1900

11,380
40,273
86,786
143,963
207,905
276,749

The census of 1890 (the religious statistics of the census of 1900 are not yet available) shows that, of a total church membership of 128,115 in Utah, the Latter-Day Saints numbered 118,201.

What may be called the Mormon political policy embraces these objects: to maintain the dictatorial power of the priesthood over the present church membership; to extend that membership over the adjoining states so as to acquire in the latter, first a balance of power, and later complete political control; to continue the work of proselyting throughout the United States and in foreign lands with a view to increasing the strength of the church at home by the immigration to Utah of the converts.

That the power of the Mormon priesthood over their flock has never been more autocratic than it is to-day is the testimony of the best witnesses who may be cited. A natural reason for this may be found in the strength which always comes to a religious sect with age, if it survives the period of its infancy. We have seen that in the early days of the church its members apostatized in scores, intimate acquaintance with Smith and his associates soon disclosing to men of intelligence and property their real objects. But the church membership in and around Utah to-day is made up of the children and the grandchildren of men and women who remained steadfast in their faith. These younger generations are therefore influenced in their belief, not only by such appeals as what is taught to them makes to their reason, but by the fact that these teachings are the teachings which have been accepted by their ancestors. It is, therefore, vastly more difficult to convince a younger Mormon to-day that his belief rests on a system of fraud than it was to enforce a similar argument on the minds of men and women who joined the Saints in Ohio or Illinois. We find, accordingly, that apostasies in Utah are of comparatively rare occurrence; that men of all classes accept orders to go on missions to all parts of the world without question; and that the tithings are paid with greater regularity than they have been since the days of Brigham Young.

-----                           THE MORMONISM OF TODAY                           611  -----

The extension of the membership of the Mormon church over the states and territories nearest to Utah has been carried on with intelligent zeal. The census of 1890 gives the following comparison of members of Latter-Day Saints churches and of "all bodies" in the states and territories named: --

Idaho
Arizona
Nevada
Wyoming
Colorado
New Mexico

L. D. SAINTS
14,972
6,500
525
1,336
1,762
456

ALL BODIES
24,036
26,972
5,877
11,705
86,837
105,749

The political influence of the Mormon church in all the states and territories adjacent to Utah is already great, amounting in some instances to practical dictation. It is not necessary that any body of voters should have the actual control of the politics of a state to insure to them the respect of political managers. The control of certain counties will insure to them the subserviency of the local politicians, who will speak a good word for them at the state capital, and the prospect that they will have greater influence in the future will be pressed upon the attention of the powers that be. We have seen how steadily the politicians of California at Washington stood by the Mormons in their earlier days, when they were seeking statehood and opposing any federal control of their affairs. The business reasons which influenced the Californians are a thousand times more effective to-day. The Cooperative Institution has a hold on the Eastern firms from which it buys goods, and every commercial traveller who visits Utah to sell the goods of his employers to Mormon merchants learns that a good word for his customers is always appreciated. The large corporations that are organized under the laws of Utah (and this includes the Union Pacific Railroad Company) are always in some way beholden to the Mormon legislative power. All this sufficiently indicates the measures quietly taken by the Mormon church to guard itself against any further federal interference.

The mission work of the Mormon church has always been conducted with zeal and efficiency, and it is so continued to-day. The

--------     612     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

church authorities in Utah no longer give out definite statistics showing the number of missionaries in the field, and the number of converts brought to Utah from abroad. The number of missionaries at work in October, 1901, was stated to me by church officers at from fourteen hundred to nineteen hundred, the smaller number being insisted upon as correct by those who gave it. As nearly as could be ascertained, about one-half this force is employed in the United States and the rest abroad. The home field most industriously cultivated has been the rural districts of the Southern states, whose ignorant population, ever susceptible to "preaching" of any kind, and quite incapable of answering the Mormon interpretation of the Scriptures, is most easily lead to accept the Mormon views. When such people are offered an opportunity to improve their worldly condition, as they are told they may do in Utah, at the same time that they can save their souls, the bait is a tempting one. The number of missionaries now at work in these Southern states is said to be much smaller than it was two years ago. Meanwhile the work of proselyting in the Eastern Atlantic states has become more active. The Mormons have their headquarters in Brooklyn, New York, and their missionaries make visits in all parts of Greater New York. They leave a great many tracts in private houses, explaining that they will make another call later, and doing so if they receive the least encouragement. They take great pains to reach servant girls with their literature and arguments, and the story has been published¹ of a Mormon missionary who secured employment as a butler, and made himself so efficient that his employer confided to him the engagement of all the house servants; in time the frequent changes which he made aroused suspicion, and an investigation disclosed the fact that he was a Mormon of good education, who used his position as head servant to perform effective proselyting work. By promise of a husband and a home of her own on her arrival in Utah, this man was said to have induced sixty girls to migrate from New York City to that state since he began his labors.

The Mormons estimate the membership of their church throughout the world at a little over 300,000. The numbers of "souls" in the church abroad was thus reported for the year ending December 31, 1899, as published in the Millennial Star: --
_________________________
¹ New York Sun, January 27, 1901.

-----                           THE MORMONISM OF TODAY                           613  -----

Great Britain
Scandinavia
Germany
Switzerland
Netherlands

4,588
5,438
1,198
1,078
1,556

These figures indicate a great falling off in the church constituency in Europe as compared with the year 1851, when the number of Mormons in Great Britain and Ireland was reported at more than thirty thousand. Many influences have contributed to decrease the membership of the church abroad and the number of converts which the church machinery has been able to bring to Utah. We have seen that the announcement of polygamy as a necessary belief of the church was a blow to the organization in Europe. The misrepresentation made to converts abroad to induce them to migrate to Utah, as illustrated in the earlier years of the church, has always been continued, and naturally many of the deceived immigrants have sent home accounts of their deception. A book could be filled with stories of the experiences of men and women who have gone to Utah, accepting the promises held out to them by the missionaries, -- such as productive farms, paying business enterprises; or remunerative employment, -- only to find their expectations disappointed, and themselves stranded in a country where they must perform the hardest labor in order to support themselves, if they had not the means with which to return home. The effect of such revelations has made some parts of Europe an unpleasant field for the visits of Mormon missionaries.

The government at Washington, during the operation of the Perpetual Emigration Fund organization, realized the evil of the introduction of so many Mormon converts from abroad. On August 9, 1879, Secretary of State William M. Evarts sent out a circular to the diplomatic officers of the United States throughout the world, calling their attention to the fact that the organized shipment of immigrants intended to add to the number of law-defying polygamists in Utah was "a deliberate and systematic attempt to bring persons to the United States with the intent of violating their laws and committing crimes expressly punishable under the statute as penitentiary offences," and instructing them to call the attention of the governments to which they were accredited to this matter, in order that those governments might take such

--------     614     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

steps as were compatible with their laws and usages "to check the organization of these criminal enterprises by agents who are thus operating beyond the reach of the law of the United States, and to prevent the departure of those proposing to come hither as violators of the law by engaging in such criminal enterprises, by whomsoever instigated." President Cleveland, in his first message, recommended the passage of a law to prevent the importation of Mormons into the United States. The Edmunds-Tucker law contained a provision dissolving the Perpetual Emigration Company, and forbidding the Utah legislature to pass any law to bring persons into the territory. Mormon authorities have informed me that there has been no systematic immigration work since the prosecutions under the Edmunds law. But as it is conceded that the Mormons make practically no proselytes among then Gentile neighbors, they must still look largely to other fields for that increase of their number which they have in view.

As a part of their system of colonizing the neighboring states and territories, they have made settlements in the Dominion of Canada and in Mexico. Their Canadian settlement is situated in Alberta. A report to the Superintendent of Immigration at Ottawa, dated December 30, 1899, stated that the Mormon colony there comprised 1700 souls, all coming from Utah; and that "they are a very progressive people, with good schools and churches." When they first made their settlement they gave a pledge to the Dominion government that they would refrain from the practice of polygamy while in that country. In 1889 the Department of the Interior at Ottawa was informed that the Mormons were not observing this pledge, but investigation convinced the department that this accusation was not true. However, in 1890, an amendment to the criminal law of the Dominion was enacted (clause 11, 53 Victoria, Chap. 37), making any person guilty of a misdemeanor, and liable to imprisonment for five years and a fine of $500, who practises any form of polygamy or spiritual marriage, or celebrates or assists in any such marriage ceremony.

The Secretario de Fomento of Mexico, under date of May 4, 1901, informed me that the number of Mormon colonists in that country was then 2319, located in seven places in Chihuahua and Sonora. He added: "The laws of this country do not permit polygamy. The government has never encouraged the immigration

-----                           THE MORMONISM OF TODAY                           615  -----

of Mormons, only that of foreigners of good character, working people who may be useful to the republic. And in the contracts made for the establishment of those Mormon colonies it was stipulated that they should be formed only of foreigners embodying all the aforesaid conditions."

No student of the question of polygamy, as a doctrine and practice of the Mormon church, can reach any other conclusion than that it is simply held in abeyance at the present time, with an expectation of a removal of the check now placed upon it. The impression, which undoubtedly prevails throughout other parts of the United States, that polygamy was finally abolished by the Woodruff manifesto and the terms of statehood, is founded on an ignorance of the compulsory character of the doctrine of polygamy, of the narrowness of President Woodruff's decree, and of the part which polygamous marriages have been given, by the church doctrinal teachings, in the plan of salvation. The sketch of the various steps leading up to the Woodruff manifesto shows that even that slight concession to public opinion was made, not because of any change of view by the church itself concerning polygamy, but simply to protect the church members from the loss of every privilege of citizenship. That manifesto did not in anyway condemn the polygamous doctrine; it simply advised the Saints to submit to the United States law against polygamy, with the easily understood but unexpressed explanation that it was to their temporal advantage to do so. How strictly this advice has since been lived up to -- to what extent polygamous practices have since been continued in Utah -- it is not necessary, in a work of this kind, to try to ascertain. The most intelligent non-Mormon testimony obtainable in the territory must be discarded if we are to believe that polygamous relations have not been continued in many instances. This, too, would be only what might naturally be expected among a people who had so long been taught that plural marriages were a religious duty, and that the check to them was applied, not by their church authorities, but by an outside government, hostility to which had long been inculcated in them.

It must be remembered that it is a part of the doctrine of polygamy that woman can enter heaven only as sealed to some devout member of the Mormon church "for time and eternity," and that the space around the earth is filled with spirits seeking some "tabernacles

--------     616     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

of clay" by means of which they may attain salvation. Through the teaching of this doctrine, which is accepted as explicitly by the membership of the Mormon church at large as is any doctrine by a Protestant denomination, the Mormon women believe that the salvation of their sex depends on "sealed" marriages, and that the more children they can bring into the world the more spirits they assist on the road to salvation. In the earlier days of the church, as Brigham Young himself testified, the bringing in of new wives into a family produced discord and heart-burnings, and many pictures have been drawn of the agony endured by a wife number one when her husband became a polygamist. All the testimony I can obtain in regard to the Mormonism of today shows that the Mormon women are now the most earnest advocates of polygamous marriages. Said one competent observer in Salt Lake City to me, "As the women of the South, during the war, were the rankest rebels, so the women of Mormondom are to-day the most zealous advocates of polygamy."

By precisely what steps the church may remove the existing prohibition of polygamous marriages I shall not attempt to decide. It is easy, however, to state the one enactment which would prevent the success of any such effort. This would be the adoption by Congress and ratification by the necessary number of states of a constitutional amendment making the practice of polygamy an offence under the federal law, and giving the federal courts jurisdiction to punish any violators of this law. The Mormon church recognizes this fact, and whenever such an amendment comes before Congress all its energies will be directed to prevent its ratification. Governor Wells's warning in his message vetoing the Utah Act of March, 1901, concerning prosecutions for adultery, that its enactment would be the signal for a general demand for the passage of a constitutional amendment against polygamy, showed how far the executive thought it necessary to go to prevent even the possibility of such an amendment. One of the main reasons why the Mormons are so constantly increasing their numbers in the neighboring states is that they may secure the vote of those states against an anti-polygamy amendment. Whenever such an amendment is introduced at Washington it will be found that every Mormon influence -- political, mercantile, and railroad -- will be arrayed against it, and its passage is unlikely unless the

-----                           THE MORMONISM OF TODAY                           617  -----

church shall make some misstep which will again direct public attention to it in a hostile manner.

The devout Mormon has no more doubt that his church will dominate this nation eventually than he has in the divine character of his prophet's revelations. Absurd as such a claim appears to all non-Mormon citizens, in these days when Mormonism has succeeded in turning public attention away from the sect, it is interesting to trace the church view of this matter, along with the impression which the Mormon power has made on some of its close observers. The early leaders made no concealment of their claim that Mormonism was to be a world religion. "What the world calls 'Mormonism' will rule every nation," said Orson Hyde. "God has decreed it, and his own right arm will accomplish it."¹ Brigham Young, in a sermon in the Tabernacle on February 15, 1856, told his people that their expulsion from Missouri was revealed to him in advance, as well as the course of their migrations, and he added: "Mark my words. Write them down. This people as a church and kingdom will go from the west to the east."

Tullidge, whose works, it must be remembered, were submitted to church revision, in his "Life of Brigham Young" thus defines the Mormon view of the political mission of the head of the church:" He is simply an apostle of a republican nationality, manifold in its genius; or, in popular words, he is the chief apostle of state rights by divine appointment. He has the mission, he affirms, and has been endowed with inspiration to preach the gospel of a true democracy to the nation, as well as the gospel for the remission of sins, and he believes the United States will ultimately need his ministration in both respects.... They form not, therefore, a rival power as against the Union, but an apostolic ministry to it, and their political gospel is state rights and self-government. This is political Mormonism in a nutshell."²

Tullidge further says in his "History of Salt Lake City" (writing in 1886): "The Mormons from the first have existed as a society, not as a sect. They have combined the two elements of organization -- the social and the religious. They are now a new society power in the world, and an entirety in themselves. They are indeed the only religious community in Christendom of modern birth."³
_________________________
¹ Journal of Discourses, Vol. VII, pp. 48-53.
² p. 244.
³ p. 387.

--------     618     THE STORY OF THE MORMONS       --------

Some of the closest observers of the Mormons in their earlier days took them very seriously. Thus Josiah Quincy, after visiting Joseph Smith at Nauvoo, wrote that it was "by no means impossible" that the answer to the question, "What historical American of the nineteenth century has exerted the most powerful influence upon the destiny of his countrymen," would not be, "Joseph Smith." Governor Ford of Illinois, who had to do officially with the Mormons during most of their stay in that state, afterward wrote concerning them: "The Christian world, which has hitherto regarded Mormonism with silent contempt, unhappily may yet have cause to fear its rapid increase. Modern society is full of material for such a religion.... It is to be feared that, in the course of a century, some gifted man like Paul, some splendid orator who will be able by his eloquence to attract crowds of the thousands who are ever ready to hear and be carried away by the sounding brass and tinkling cymbal of sparkling oratory, may command a hearing, may succeed in breathing a new life into this modern Mohammedanism, and make the name of the martyred Joseph ring as loud, and stir the souls of men as much, as the mighty name of Christ itself."¹

The close observers of Mormonism in Utah, who recognize its aims, but think that its days of greatest power are over, found this opinion on the fact that the church makes practically no converts among the neighboring Gentiles; and that the increasing mining and other business interests are gradually attracting a population of non-Mormons which the church can no longer offset by converts brought in from the East and from foreign lands. Special stress is laid on the future restriction on Mormon immigration that will be found in the lack of further government land which may be offered to immigrants, and in the discouraging stories sent home by immigrants who have been induced to move to Utah by the false representations of the missionaries. Unquestionably, if the Mormon church remains stationary as regards wealth and membership, it will be overshadowed by its surroundings. What it depends on to maintain its present status and to increase its power is the loyal devotion of the body of its adherents, and its skill in increasing their number in the states which now surround Utah, and eventually in other states.
_________________________
¹ Ford, "History of Illinois," p. 359.

[ 619 ]

INDEX

A
Aaronic Priesthood, 120.
"Abraham, Book of," 140.
Adam, Brigham Young's doctrine of, 116; settlement in Missouri, 195.
Adam-ondi-Ahman, revelation about, 195; last days of Mormons in, 210, 211.
Adoption, doctrine of, 280
Aikin party, murder of, 450; indictments for, 569.
Alexander, Col. E. B., leader of foremost companies in the Mormon "war," 487; reply to Young, 488; advance toward Salt Lake City, 491, 492; correspondence with Young, 494-496.
Allen, Capt. J., instructions about the Battalion, 371.
Alma, 94.
Alphabet, Mormon, 439.
Amlicites, 54.
Ammaron hides the golden plates, 91.
Anderson, Rosmos, victim of blood atonement, 456.
Anthon, Prof. Charles, account of Harris's visit, 39, 40.
"Argus's" letters on Mountain Meadows massacre, 532.
Apostasies, early, 133; reasons for, 153.
Apostles, duties of, 101; revelation on, 102, 120.
Archibold, Ann, on Mormon dishonesty, 332.
Army of Zion, 180, 181.
Arthur, Charlotte, on endowment oath, 355.
Arthur, Pres. C. A., on polygamy, 595.
"Articles of Faith," 118.
Atchison, Gen. D. R., Smith's counsel, 199; unpopularity with non-Mormons, 206; in Missouri legislature, 216.
Atwater, Darwin, on Rigdon's early declarations, 65.
Avard, S., reveals Danite constitution, 191; with volunteers for Daviess County, 198; arrest and confession, 209; testimony against Mormon leaders, 212; excommunicated, 213 note.
Avard, S. B., governor of Utah Territory, 573.

B
Babbitt, A. W., delegate to Congress, 430; on Salt Lake City duties, 431; refused admission, 431; secretary Utah Territory, 467; his death, 467 note.
Babel, tower of, departure of Jaredites, 90.
Backenstos, J. B., mission to Gov. Ford, 248; proclamations and action as sheriff, 336, 337; Lieut. Worrell's murder, 336; resignation demanded, 339; course during "last war," 346.
Balzac, on seers, 5.
Bancroft, H. H., "History of Utah," viii; on Rigdon, 75; contradicted by J. M. Grant, 466; defence of Mountain Meadows murderers, 527 note.
Bank at Kirtland, story of, 148-152; redemption of a bill by Smith, 265.
Banks, John, shooting of, 541.
Baptism, Disciples' and Mormon doctrine, 64; Disciples' tenet in Mormon Bible, 93 note; for the dead, 118, 119.
Baskin, R. N., prosecutor, 568.
Bateman, W., part in Mountain Meadows massacre, 522.
Battalion, the Mormon, how organized, 371; false claims for, 371-373; march to California, 373; dispersal, 373; meeting the pioneers, 388; in Salt Lake City, 397.
Bayard, Senator T. F., reports on Morrill Bill, 590.
Beadle, J. H., on the "Reformation," 444; on Gov. Dawson's punishment, 538; on warning to Gov. Hardin, 542; on outside influences, 570.
Beaver Island, Wis., Strang's colony, 325.
Beliefs, man's credulity, 2; origin of Mormon, 63, 64; reasons for acceptance, 124, 126; outline of Mormon, 107-121.
Bennett, Gen. James A., for Vice President, 253; Emma's alleged statement to, 323.
Bennett, Dr. John C., biography, 236; help in securing Nauvoo charter, 236; mayor and general, 238; inaugural address, 239; Mormon charges against, 268; letters to Sangamon Journal, lectures, and book, 269;

--------------    620                                               INDEX                                               --------------

Mormon licentiousness charged, 270; with Strang, 325.
Benson, A. G., Brannan's alleged interview with, 388.
Benson, E. T., proposed settlement in Iowa, 393.
Bently, Adamson, connection with Rigdon, 61; on Rigdon's foreknowledge of Mormon Bible, 65.
Benton, R. H., Mountain Meadows story, 526.
Benton, R. T., attack on Morrisites, 541.
Benton, T. H., alleged animosity to Mormons, 372.
Bernhisel, J. M., truth about the Battalion, 372 note; Delegate in Congress, 501.
Bible, the Mormon, contradictory accounts of, by the Smiths, 14, 23, 26, 27; Smith's confession to Peter Ingersol, 24.; Abigail Harris's statement, 25; how two wags uncovered the plates, 26; first accounts of the discovery of the plates, statement of Smith's father, 28-30; the account in Smith's autobiography, 30-32; Mother Smith's statements, 32-34; Harris's visit to Prof. Anthon, 38-41; Mrs. Harris's seizure of translated pages, 41; obstacles to retranslation, 42-46; descriptions of the work of translation, 42; second copy made, 44; substitution of translation from plates of Nephi, 45; preface to first edition, 45; translating at Whitmer's house, 46; publication of, 47-49; its printing, 47-49; failure to secure purchasers, 49; expectations of a new Bible, 65; critical examination of, 89-97; corrections made, 89; disregard of by Mormons, 89; facsimile of first edition title-page, 90; plates made by Mormon, 91, 92; books of, 90; historical narrative, 90-95; why "reformed Egyptian" was used, 92; Prof. Whitsitt's analysis, 92 note; Christ in, 94-96; literary style, 95; chapters of Scripture introduced, 96; anachronisms, 97; grammatical errors, 98; necessity of acceptance by Mormon church, 98; teachings against polygamy, 272,273.
Bidamon, Maj. L. C., Emma's second husband, 44; recovery of second Ms. of Mormon Bible, 44.
Big Blue, Mo., attack on, 177, 178.
Bird, W., part in Parrish murders, 449.
Bishop, GIadden, 436.
Bishops, the first, 120; to hold property; 146; as city magistrates, 429; Young's views of, 439 note, 442.
Black, Adam, agreement signed by, 198.
Black, G. A., secretary and acting governor, Utah Territory, 568.
Black, J. S., attorney general, approval of Floyd's order, 535.

Blair, S. M., attorney general Utah Territory, 458.
Blessings, patriarchal, 121.
Blood atonement, J. M. Grant the inventor, 444; early plan for, 445; the Kayesville offenders, 445; origin and practice, 454-457.
Bogart, Capt., at Crooked River, 203.
Boggs, Gov., non-Mormon petition to, 200; Gen. Doniphan's report to, 201; "order of extermination," 205, 206; attempted assassination of, 245; trip to California, 284.
Bonneville's explorations, 396.
"Book of Commandments," 112. See Revelations.
"Book of Doctrine and Covenants." publication of, in Missouri, 112; Kirtland edition, 112; result of publication, 169. See Revelations.
Booth, Danforth, concerning Oliver Cowdery, 80.
Booth, Rev, E., Harris's statement to, 36; conversion to Mormonism, 123, 126.; statement about marriage relations, 273.
Boreman, Judge J. S., presides at Lee's trial, 532.
Boweries, 370.
Bowles, Samuel, visit to Utah, 552.
Boyd of Kentucky, presents Deseret constitution, 231.
Boynton, J., in church fight, 158.
Brandebury, L. G., chief justice of Utah Territory, 458.
Brannan, S., emigration to California, 387, 388; alleged agreement with Benson, 388.
Brassfield, O. N., murder of, 554.
Brayman, M., reports to Gov. Ford, 343, 350, 351, 367.
Breastplate, delivery to Smith, 32; Mother Smith's description, 32.
Bremer, murder of, 536.
Brewer, Dr. C., on Mountain Meadow Massacre, 516.
Bridger, Col. James,, meets Utah pioneers, 386; his fort, 389; discoverer of Great Salt Lake, 395; guide to Col. Johnston, 492.
Brocchus, P. E., associate justice of Utah Territory, 458; address to the Mormons, 461, 462; Young's denunciation of, 462; leaves Utah, 465; report to the President, 465.
Brockman, Col., part in "last Mormon war," 348-351.
Bross, Lieut. Gov., visit to Utah, 552.
Brown, Col. A. G., Jr., on government contracts, 500; on amnesty proclamation, 512; the terms to the Mormons, 514.
Buchanan, Pres. James, Mormon appeal to, 477; directs the organization of troops, 477; views in first message, 478; letters to Col.

--------------                                                  INDEX                                          621     --------------

Kane, 501, 502; back-down to Young, 504; peace message to Congress, 510; amnesty proclamation, 511; appointment of peace commissioners, 511.
Buffaloes, vast herds of, 381.
Buffington, J., chief justice of Utah Territory, 458.
Bullock, T., experiences during the migration, 367, 368.
Burgess, Salem trip, 147.
"Burnings," the, in Illinois, 336, 343.
Burr, D. H., surveyor general; presence resented, 473; escape from Utah, 474.

C
Caine, J. T., " Home Rule Bill" 607.
Caldwell County, Mo., framed for the Mormons, 187; civil war in, 200, 201, 207-209.
Calhoun, J. C, Smith's letter to, 250.
California, the rush of gold seekers, 405-407; proposed consolidation with Deseret, 430; complaints of emigrants to, 440; exodus of Mormons, 496.
Campbell, Alexander and Thomas, 59; Alexander's views of Rigdon, 61; Rigdon's jealousy of, 62; challenge to Rigdon, 73; on Mormon Bible, 98.
Campbellites. See Disciples of Christ.
Camps, during the migration, 362, 363; on the Missouri, 375-378; Scott and Eccles, 499.
Canada, Mormon settlement in, 614; anti-polygamy law, 614.
Cannon, G. Q., alleged endowment oath, 354; senator from State of Deseret, 540; indicted for unlawful cohabitation, 568; Delegate to Congress, 571; explanation of Woodruff's manifesto, 602.
Cardenas, expedition to Utah, 395.
Carleton, A. B., member Utah commission, 597.
Carlton, Gen., erects cairn in Mountain Meadows, 534.
Carlin, Gov., on Nauvoo municipal court, 246.
Carlin, special constable in "last Mormon war," 347.
Carroll County, Mo., town started in, 195; measures to expel the Mormons, 201.
Carthage, Ill., petition to Gov. Ford, 298; murder of the Smiths, 301-306; anti-Mormon convention, 340; anti-Mormon meeting, 346.
Carthage Grays, part in the Smiths' murder, 303, 304.
Caswall, Rev. H., test of Smith's knowledge, 141; a Sunday service at Nauvoo, 260.
Chandler, Albert, recollections of, 48; on Smith, 311, 312.
Chartered Sisters of Charity, 270.

Chase, Willard, account of "peek-stone," 20; Smith's offer to, 26;
Chislett, J., description of hand-cart tragedy, 419.
Chittenden, Col. J. B., in command of anti-Mormon posse; 347
Christ, in Mormon Bible, 94-96; Smith's description of, 116; men who saw, 138; alleged polygamist, 288.
Church, Mormon, organization of, 99-101; legal organization, 100; form of government revealed, 100, 101, 119-121; name, 108; organized in Ohio, 122; early government of, 131; dissensions in Missouri, 188, 189; property at Nauvoo, 292; government after Smith's death, 314, 315; "secret works," 316 and note; Young elected president, 330; alleged disloyal oaths, 354, 355, 430; act of incorporation, 439; church-inspired murders, 448-451; disloyalty of, 431, 460, 474, 475, 483, 497, 543, 544; attitude toward the Southern states, 544; legislation about church property, 599; decision of U. S. Supreme Court, 602; policy of to-day, 610; fidelity of younger members, 610; extension of membership, 611; political influence, 611; present mission work, 611, 612; membership, 612; belief in national control, 617; checks, on its growth, 618.
Church of Christ, Rigdon's, 318. See Hendrickites.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. See Church, Mormon.
Church, Reorganized. See Reorganized Church.
Clark, Rev. J. A., on money-digging, 20; contradictory accounts of the golden book, 23; Martin Harris, 35, 36, 38; feeling of Smith's neighbors, 106.
Clark, Gen. J. B., Gov. Boggs's orders to, 205; at Far West, address to the Mormons, 209; Mormon testimonial to, 210; his summing up, 210.
Clarke, S. J., on thieving by Mormons, 261.
Clay County, Mo., first Mormon arrivals, 178; Army of Zion, 180; manufacture of arms, 182; welcome to Mormons, 185; responsibility for trouble, 185; non-Mormon meeting at Liberty, and its demands, 185, 186.
Clay, Henry, Smith's correspondence with, 250, 251.
Clayton, W., affidavit about the revelation concerning polygamy, 279.
Clemison, John, testimony of, 213.
Cleveland, Pres. Grover, on polygamy, 588; proclamation admitting Utah as a state, 608; against Mormon immigration, 614. Clifford, Maj. B., Jr., in command at Nauvoo, 348.
Cloistered Saints, 270.

--------------    622                                               INDEX                                               --------------

Cobb, J. T., investigations, 28.
CoIesville, N.Y., branch church in, 100; removal to Missouri, 169.
Colfax, S., first visit to Utah, 553; second visit, 556.
"Commandments, Book of." See "Book of Commandments."
Commerce, Ill., origin of, 223.
"Commissions" of Ohio converts, 128.
Conferences, church, provided for, 101.
Connor, Col. P. E., rebuke of disloyalty, 544; march into Salt Lake City, 545; establishes Camp Douglas, 546; invitation to miners, 550; ball in his honor, 602.
Consecration of property, 145, 194.
Converts, first Mormon, 100.
Cooke, Lieut Col. P. St. G., in Mormon "war," 482; sufferings of his force, 492; government sale at Camp Floyd, 537.
Cooperation, church doctrine, 559; Z. C. M. I., 559, 560.
Corrill, John, reasons for accepting Mormonism, 124-126; why he abandoned it, 125; ravings of converts, 130; on Jackson County agreement, 175; locked up, 177; on Missouri relations, 187; leaves the church, 189; on Danites, 189; on Mormon plundering, 202; testimony against the leaders, 212; excommunicated, 213 note; presents petition to the legislature, 216.
Council Bluffs, camp at, 376.
Council of Fifty, 316 note.
Counterfeiting alleged, 10, 81, 188, 260, 293, 302, 331, 344, 360; of government drafts in Salt Lake City, 536, 537.
Cowdery, Oliver, assistant translator, 38, 45; biography, 45; ordered West, 72; . testimony regarding the plates, 78; character and later years, 80-83; authorized to baptize, 99; ordained, 100; authorization to reveal, and its results, 101, 102; first sermon, 103; trip to Toronto, 113;. journey to Ohio, 122; miracle working, 139; boundaries of the promised land, 142; share of Kirtland property, printer, 146; Kirtland bank, 148; charges against, 154; charge against Smith, 157; arrival in Missouri, 162, 163; printer in Missouri, 167; mission to Kirtland, 176; expelled from church, 188.
Cowdery, W. A., on Kirtland Bank, 150; Smith on, 156.
Cowles, Austin, affidavit, 291.
Cradlebaugh, Judge John, action against Parrish murderers, 450; on Aiken murders, 450; appointed associate justice of Utah Territory, 478; on Mountain Meadows Massacre, 524 note, 525, 526; checked by Governor Cumming, 535.
Cragin Anti-polygamy Bill, 591.

Craig, C, L., deputy surveyor, report, 473.
Crickets, visitation of, 400.
Crooked River, battle of, 203.
Crosby, J. R., associate justice of Utah Territory, 537, 540.
Crystal-gazing, 16-18, practise by Smith, 18-22, See "Peek-stone."
Cullom, S. M., anti-polygamy bill of 1869, 591; proposed law of 1890, 602.
Cumming, Alfred, appointed governor of Utah, 478; proclamation to Young, 499; approached by Kane, 503; trip to Salt Lake City, 505-507; opinions of Young, 507; charges against Hurt, 507; scene in the Tabernacle, 508; on Mormon exodus, 510; peace commissioners on, 512; on Johnston's advance, 513 note; proclamation to the people, 516; opposes military posse, 535; order to Wells, 536; departure from Utah, 537.
Cumorah, land and hill of, 91.
Currency, Mormon, 439.
Curtis, George Ticknor, silence on Mormon "war," 480 note.
Cyprian Saints, 270.

D
Dame, Col. W. H., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 527-532.
Daniels, Mr. N., on the Smiths' murder, 304, 306,308.
Danites, flight of Cowdery and Whitmer from, 81; organization, 189-191; name, 191; constitution and oath, 191, 192, 334; Young on, 192; in politics, 198; testimony concerning, 212, 213; doings in and around Nauvoo, 334.
Darien Isthmus, landing place of Jaredites, 94.
Daviess County, Mo., riot at Gallatin, 198; civil war in, 200, 201; military operations in, 205-207; militia disbanded, 210; Gen. R. Wilson's visit, 210, 211.
Davison, Mrs., on Spaulding manuscript, 52.
Dawson, J. W., governor of Utah Territory, 537; offence and punishment, 538, 539.
Deacons, duties of, 101.
Debts, revelation about, 146, 164; Young's view of, 437.
Denmark, hostility to Mormons, 415 note.
Deseret News, defiance of the government, 483; on Gov. Dawson, 538; disloyal utterances, 543; on polygamy, 553; on Edmunds law, 600.
Deseret, State of, first constitution and boundaries, 429; memorial to Congress, 429; proposed consolidation with California, 430; protest against admission, 430; charge of treason, 431; ordinances, 438, 439, 440; currency and alphabet, 439; university,

--------------                                                  INDEX                                          623     --------------

440; second constitution and application for admission, 477; third application for admission, 540; meeting of legislature, 547.
Deveria, translation of papyri, 141.
Dewitt, Mo., siege of, 201.
Dickens, Charles, illiteracy in England, 230; description of a Mormon vessel, 233 note.
Dickinson, Ellen E., researches regarding Spaulding manuscript, 57.
Dilke, Sir C. Mr., on Young, 553 note.
Disciples of Christ, origin and beliefs, 60; similarity of Mormon beliefs, 63-65; expectation of a new Bible, 65; grove meeting, 129.
"Divine Authenticity of the Book of Mormon," 127.
Divining rod, 15.
Divorces, Young's fee for, 577.
Dixon, Hepworth, on Rigdon, 75.
"Doctrine and Covenants, Book of," See "Book" and Revelations.
Doctrines, Mormon, 107-121.
Dominguez's expedition to Utah, 395.
Doniphan, Gen. A. W., Smith's counsel, 199; militia force, 201; report to Gov. Boggs, 202.
Dotson, P. K., marshal of Utah Territory, 478; experience in counterfeit case, 536.
Doty, J. D., governor of Utah Territory, 550; death, 567.
Douglas, Stephen A., on Nauvoo Legion, 237; appointment for Bennett, 238; member of Hancock County commission, 337; commission's report, 340; presents Mormon memorial, 430; explanation of Salt Lake City duties, 431; anti-Mormon speech, 476.
Drake, T. J., associate justice Utah Territory, 540; defiance of Young, 548.
Drummond, W. W, associate justice of Utah Territory, 466; reputation in Illinois, 469; ignores the probate courts, 471; quarrel with a Jew, and its results, 471; return to the East and report, 472.
Dunklin, Gov., Mormon statement to, 175; reply thereto, 176; compromise urged, 182; message to legislature, 184; reply to Clay County Mormons, 186.
Dunn, Capt., visit to Nauvoo, 299.
Durfee, A., part in Parrish murders, 448, 449.
Durkee, C., governor of Utah Territory, 567.
Duties levied in Salt Lake City, 431; Col. Kane on, 459.
Dutton, S., indictment for murder, 569.
Dylkes, "the leather god," 124.

E
Eagle, Hancock, issued at Nauvoo, 345.
Eckles, D. R., chief justice of Utah Territory,

478; court at Camp Scott, 500; refusal to accompany Cumming, 506; jury charge on polygamy, 514.
Edmunds, Senator G. F., anti-polygamy bill, 595; Edmunds-Tucker amendment, 596; bill regarding church property, 602.
"Egyptian, reformed," why used on the plates, 92.
Elders, duties, 101; to travel, 113; early missionaries, 228, 229.
Elders' Journal, vii.
Election law, early Utah, 467.
Ellicott, Lord Bishop, on baptism for the dead, 118.
Emery, G. B., governor of Utah Territory, 573; on polygamy, 594.
Emmons, Sylvester, connection with the Expositor, 291.
Endowment House, early ceremonies at Nauvoo, 278; ceremony described, 353, 354; the oath, 354, 355; Gen. Well's refusal to testify about, 594.
England, proselyting in, 230-233; character of converts, 256, 257; converts, how treated, 257 note.
Enoch, Order of, 146.
Escalante, expedition to Utah, 395.
Ether, Book of, 93.
Evarts, W. M., circular regarding Mormon immigration, 613.
Evening and Morning Star, vii; office destroyed, 174.
"Everlasting Gospel," contained in golden plates, 31; Rigdon's use of the story of Cyril's plates and Joachim's teachings, 74-77; in Mormon writings, 77.
Expositor, Nauvoo, its origin and suppression, 290-296; incorrect statements about, 291 note.

F
Fairchild, Pres. T. H., pamphlet on second Spaulding Ms., 55, 56; on Rigdon, 68.
Faith cures, 139 note.
Fancher, Capt., leader of Mountain Meadows victims, 518.
Far West, Mo., founded, 187; surrender of, 208.
Fayette, N. Y., Mormon churchwork at, 100, 104.
Feet washing, 138.
Ferguson, James, affair with Judge Stiles, 471.
Ferris, B. G., "Utah and the Mormons," viii; "the real (Mormon) miracle," 1; secretary of Utah Territory, 467.
Fillmore, capital of Utah, 458.
Fillmore, Pres. M., appoints Utah officers, 458; deceived by Col. Kane, 459.
Fitch, T., attorney for Mormons, 570.

--------------    624                                               INDEX                                               --------------

Flenniken, R, P., associate justice of Utah Territory, 537, 540.
Floyd, Sec. J. B., order to Gen. Johnston, 534.
Ford, T., governor of Illinois, warrant for Smith's arrest, 247; on alleged pledge to Mormons, 248 note; visit to Carthage, demand on Mormons for information, 298; surrender of Mormon leaders called for, 298; the murder of the Smiths, 301-304; action after Smith's murder, 313; defends Mormons, 331; advises them not to vote, 333; advice to Young, 335; changed view of Mormons, 337; vacillating course, 345, 347, 348, 352; possible future of Mormonism, 618.
Forney, Jacob, on Mountain Meadows victims, 518 note, 525, 526 note.
Foster, Dr. R. D., Smith's accusations, 290; connection with Expositor, 291; .flight from Nauvoo, 295.
Freedom of worship in Utah, 429.
Frelinghuysen, F. T., defeat of his bill, 571.
Fremont, claim to discovery of Great Salt Lake, 396.
French, Gov., address to Hancock County citizens, 352.
Frontier Guardian, 394.
Fulgate, Mr., affidavit about Kinderhook plates, 87.
Fuller, F., secretary and acting governor of Utah Territory, 537-539; removal of, 550.
"Fur Company," 202.

G
Galland, Dr. Isaac, land proposition to Mormons, 223, 224; antecedents, 234 note; plan for Nauvoo, 234.
Gallatin, Mo., riot, 198; night attack on, 202.
Garden Grove camp, 366.
Garfield, Pres. J. A., on polygamy, 595.
Garfield, Mrs. J. A., recollections of Rigdon, 77, 75.
"Gazing," See "Crystal" and "Peek- stone."
Gifts of tongues and miracles, 138.
Gilbert, J. H., part in printing Mormon Bible, 47-48.
Gilbert, Sidney, storekeeper in Missouri, 167; visit by mob, 174; locked up, 177.
Gladdenites, suppression of, 436.
Glyphs, 87.
Godbe, W. S., Young's order to, 426; Young's threat, 560; in "New Movement," 561; opposition to Cullom Bill, 592.
Godfrey, G, L., member Utah commission, 597.
Gold Bible. See "Bible, Mormon."
Gold discovery in California, effect in Utah, 405-408,

Grandin, E. B., publisher of Mormon Bible, 47.
Grant, G. .D., indicted for murder, 569.
Grant, J. M., anecdote of Smith, 310; on Salt Lake City immorality, 442; leader in "The Reformation," and inventor of blood atonement, 444; on human sacrifices, 454; pamphlet, "The Truth about the Mormons," 461; denial of polygamy, 465 note; contradiction of H. H. Bancroft, 466; defiance of the government, 474; indictment for treason, 500; on discontented wives, 585.
Grant, Pres. U. S., refusal to remove Judge McKean, 570; special message to Congress, 570; signs Poland Bill, 571.
Gray, Prof. Asa, on Rafinesque, 88.
Great Salt Lake, discovery of, 395.
Great Salt Lake City. See Salt Lake City.
Great Salt Lake Valley, first view of by the Mormons, 390, 391; first Sunday service in, 396.
Great Salt Lake Valley Carrying Co., 403.
Greeley, Horace, on Mormon persecutions, 136; Mormon influence over, 479; Young's statements to, 576, 579; woman's place in Utah, 584.
Gregg, T., on Mormon persecutions, 220; on Smith's murder, 304.
Grow, Galusha A., action on Deseret constitution, 477.
Gunnison, Lieut. J. W., "The Mormons," viii; early knowledge of blood atonement, 445; Mormon view of land titles, 472 note; murder of, 473 note.

H
Haight, I. C., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 526-530
HaIe, Emma, marriage to Smith, 24.
Hale, Isaac, character, 23; objections to Smith, 24; Smith's promise, 36; account of the translation of the golden plates, 37.
Hall of the Seventies, 241.
Hamblin, J., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 525.
Hancock County, Ill., desire for settlers, 221; panic following Smith's murder, 313; Mormon vote in 1844, 333; the "burnings" 336; Douglas-Hardin commission 337; Gen. Hardin's proclamation, 338; anti-Mormon meetings, 338; convention at Carthage, 340; anti-Mormon meetings re-assembled, 345; contributions for poor Mormons, 368. See Illinois.
Hand-cart tragedy, 418-427.
Hardin, Gen. J. J., on Hancock County commission, 337; proclamation to Hancock County, 338; negotiations with Mormons, 340, 341.

--------------         INDEX       625  --------------

Harding, S. S., trick on Stoddard, 105; governor of Utah Territory, 540; pardon of Morrisites, 542; censure of, by Mormon grand jury, 542; first message to legislature, 546; retort of the legislators, 547; reply to Mormon committee, 548; removal, how secured, 550.
Harmonists, treatment of, 135.
Harney, Gen. W. S., in Mormon "war," 481.
Harris, Abigail, statement, 25.
Harris, B. D., territorial secretary, 458; departure with a federal appropriation, 464, 465.
Harris, Martin, personal and mental characteristics, 35; early partnership in the Golden Bible, 36; assistant translator, 37; visit to Prof. Anthon, 38-41; intrusted with translated pages, 41; description of the work of translating the plates, 42; punishment of, 43; part in publication of Mormon Bible, 47; Albert Chandler's recollection of, 48; Smith's revelations about, 43, 49; sale of farm, 49; warned about talkativeness, 79; exhibition of the plates, 79, 80, 83; expulsion from the church, and last years, 84; share in Kirtland property, 146; trial of, 154; Smith on, 156; on Smith's intemperance, 156.
Harris, Mrs. Martin, proceedings in court, 27; husband's abuse of, 35; Mother Smith on, 36; theft of the translated pages, 41; separation from husband, 47.
Harris, W., on Kirtland Bank, 148.
Harrison, Pres. B., proclamation of amnesty, 606.
Harrison, E. L. T., in "New Movement," 561-563; on Mormon oath, 354.
Harrison, W. H., Mormon vote for, 244.
Hartnett, J., secretary of Utah Territory, 478.
Haven, John, on Mrs. Davison's letter, 53.
Hawkins, T., convicted of polygamy, 592.
Hawn's Mill massacre, 204.
Hay, Hon. John, account of Smith's murder, 309 note.
Hayden's "Early History of the Disciples' Church in the Western Reserve," 63-66.
Hayes, Pres. R. B., on polygamy, 595.
Haywood, J. L., marshal of Utah Territory, 458.
Hazen, Gen. W. B., on Ben Holiday, 549 note; on Mormon murders, 555.
Hedlock, R., immigration scandal, 410.
Hendrick, Granville, founder of the Church of Christ, 183 note.
Hendrickites, 183 note.
Hendrix, D., picture of Smith, 13, 27; printing of the Mormon Bible, 48.
Hickman, "Bill," on Aikin murders, 451; indicted for murder, 500; petition for Morrisites' pardon, 542; a bet, 545.

Higbee, F. M., Smith's quarrel with, 271; card in Expositor, 292.
Higbee, J. M., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 522 ff.
High Council provided for, 101; organized, 120.
High Priest, office of, 120.
Hinckle, G. M., at Dewitt, Mo., 201; order to, 203; accused of treachery, 208; excommunicated, 213 note.
Hoge-Walker incident, 245-249.
Holiday, Ben, friend of the Mormons, 549 note.
Holman, J, H., Indian agent, on tampering with the mails, 484.
Holy Ghost, gift of, 98; form of, 116.
"Holy Order," 278.
Hooper, W. H., senator from State of Deseret, 540; on defeat of Frelinghuysen Bill, 571; speech against Cullom Bill, 591.
Host of Israel, 192.
Hotchkiss, H. R., landowner at Commerce, Ill., 223; demands on Smith, 225.
Howe, E. D., "Mormonism Unveiled," viii; researches concerning Spaulding Ms., 53, 56.
Hurlbut, D. P., connection with Spaulding Ms., 56-58.
Hurt, G., Indian agent, report to the government, and escape from Utah, 474; Cumming's charges against, 507.
Hutchins, J., appeal to Pres. Grant, 179 note.
Hyde, Elder John, Jr., weight of golden plates, 34 note; estimate of Rigdon and P. P. Pratt, 59; sketch of, 59; plates still unearthed, 92; New Testament quotations in the Mormon Bible, 96; the Danites, 191; leaders' plans in Missouri, 195; the proselyting in England, 232 note; effect of "sealing" ordinances, 288; endowment ceremony, 353, 354; victims of blood atonement, 455 note; on Young, 575.
Hyde, Orson, doctrinal diagram, 116; connection with Kirtland bank, 148; letter to Missouri, 155; mission to Missouri, I76; leaves the church, 189; substantiates Marsh, 214; mission to Jerusalem, 229; statements in England, 231; Christ an alleged polygamist, 288; Rigdon's prosecutor, 316; overtures to Rigdon, 317 note; overtures to William Smith, 335; editor of Frontier Guardian, 394; blood atonement foreshadowed, 454; on Mormon world rule, 617.

I
Icarians at Nauvoo, 355.
Idaho, anti-polygamy law, 601.
Illinois, early history, 219, 220; why Mormons were welcomed, 220, 221; Mormon land

-------------- 626         INDEX         --------------

purchases, 223; party divisions, 243; Mormons in politics, 243-249; uprising of non-Mormons, 297; Gov. Ford's course, 298; militia called out, 313; renewed anti-Mormon feeling, 331-333; Democratic repudiation of the Mormons, 335; the "burnings," 336; Douglas-Hardin commission, 337; negotiations for Mormon evacuation, 338-341; Mormon view of the expulsion, 342; Brayman's reports, 343; evacuation of Nauvoo, 344-351; "last Mormon war," 347-351. See Carthage, Hancock County, Quincy, Warsaw.
Immigration, foreign, 232, 233; disappointed immigrants, 258; to Utah, 410-417; Hedlock scandal, 410; misrepresentations to immigrants, 411-414, 613; petition to Queen Victoria, 412; Young's order to Saints in Europe, 413; "Perpetual Emigrating Fund," 414; routes to Utah, 415-417; the hand-cart tragedy, 418-427; bond exacted, 420 note; profits to agents, 427; supervision of, 434; action of government against, 613.
Independence, Mo., town of, 166; anti-Mormon county meeting, 170; doings of the "mob," 174.
Indians, origin of, 91; Pottawottomies' and Omahas' welcome to Mormons, 375, 376; encountered by Utah pioneers, 381, 383; Omahas' objection to their Mormon neighbors, 393; visit of pioneers to, 397; appropriation of their land, 473; incited to hostility by the Mormons, 473, 474; part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 521 ff.; interruption of the mails, 539. See Lamanites.
Ingersol, Peter, Smith's confession to, 24.
Iowa, Mormon land purchases, 223; evacuation by Mormons, 356; kind treatment of the emigrants from Nauvoo, 360; county organized for Mormons, 393; proposed permanent settlement, 393, 394.
Irrigation, first in Utah, 391.
Irving, Washington, on possibilities of the Far West, 380; his "Lake Bonneville," 396.
Israel, lost tribes of, 167.

J
Jack Mormons, 185.
Jackson County, Mo., population and pioneers, 161, 162; arrival of Mormon missionaries, 162; expulsion of Mormons from, 169-179; anti-Mormon manifesto, 170-I72; grievances of anti-Mormons, 172, 173; ultimatum to Mormons, 173; Mormon statements to the governor, 175-177; agreement signed, 175; land in Missouri to be held, 176; Big Blue attacked, 177, 178; exchange of shots, 178; departure of the Mormons, 178, 179; Mormon legal proceedings, 179;

proposition of non-Mormons, 182; its rejection, 183, 184; hoped-for return to Jackson County, 183 note.
Jacob, G. H., pamphlet on polygamy, 276.
Jaques, Vienna, 111.
Jaredites, 91, 93.
Jarvis, H. J., vengeance on, 446.
"Jerks," 129.
Jesperson, Hans, conviction of polygamy, 599.
Jews, ancestors of Indians, 53, 90; looked-for return to Jerusalem, 64.
John the Baptist, in Mormon Bible, 96; appearance to Smith, 99.
Johnson, Bishop, part in Parrish murders, 448.
Johnson, J., murder of, 536.
Johnson, Lyman E., charges against, 81; trial of, 154; expelled, 188.
Johnson, Nephi, testimony about Mountain Meadows Massacre, 532.
Johnston, Albert Sidney, federal commander in the Mormon "war," 482; march to Utah, 491; on Mormon purpose, 494; refusal of Young's offer of provisions, 503 note; policy stated, 506; defends Hurt, 507; reply to Gov. Cumming, 513 note; Floyd's order to, 535.
"Josephites." See Reorganized Church.
Journal of Discourses, viii.

K
Kane, Col. T. L., on defiling of the Nauvoo Temple, 355; ingenuity of the Mormon emigrants, 365; letter to Jesse C. Little, 372; trip to Nauvoo and the Missouri camps, 374; reported Mormon baptism, 374; character as a Mormon agent, 374; mortality in the Missouri camps, 377; description of Utah crickets, 400; part in appointment of Young as governor of Utah, 459; work in New York, 479; offer to mediate, letters from Buchanan, 501; interviews with Mormon leaders in Utah, 502; at Camp Scott, 503; telegram to Washington, 515 note.
Kanesville, 393, 394.
Kearney, Gen. S. F., proposition about the Battalion, 371.
Keeley, James, professor at Nauvoo, 242.
Kelsey, E. B., in " New Movement," 61, 565.
Kendall, postmaster general, Brannan's story about, 388.
Kennedy, J. H., on Rigdon, 123 note.
Kimball, Heber C., mission to England, 229; statements in England, 231; against Rigdon, 317; Young's counsellor, 330; sufferings of family during the migration, 364; leads a party across the plains, 394; pictures

--------------         INDEX       627  --------------

of famine in Utah, 408; chief justice State of Deseret, 429; on Young's authority, 437, 454; warnings to the flock, 444, 445, 497; on Young's trusteeship, 473; defiance of the federal government, 497; indicted for treason, 500; on woman's duty, 585; on a fair division of female converts, 586.
Kimball, Hiram, Smith's revelation about, 114.
Kimball, W. H., indictment for murder, 569.
Kinderhook plates, history of, 86.
King, Judge A. A., hearings before, 210-215.
Kinney, John F., chief justice of Utah Territory, 467; his store and boarding-house, 469; reappointment, 537; against Morrisites, 541, 542 ; removed, 550.
Kirtland, O., visitors to, 123; vagaries of converts, 128, 130; changed plans for church headquarters, 142; business enterprises (bank, etc.), 143-151; laying out the town, 144; Temple, 145, 160; bank, 148-152; fight at a church service, 158; final struggle and flight of Smith and Rigdon, 159, 160; Kirtland bank-bills in Utah, 439.
Klingensmith, part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 526-530.
Knight, j., Sr., conversion of, 100.
Knight, S., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 522 ff.

L
La Crosse, Wis., Stake at, 324.
Lahontan's claims to discovery, 395.
Laman, 94.
Lamanites, 53; Cowdery's mission to, 85, 102, 122, 163; wars of, 91-94. See Indians.
Land, Mormon views of, 164 396, 397, 398 note, 438, 472-474.
Land speculation, 144; in Kirtland, 144, 159, 160.
Lang, Andrew, on crystal-gazing, 17, 18.
Lapham, Fayette, interview with Joseph Smith, Sr., 19, 29.
Laramie, Fort, Utah pioneers at, 383.
Later-Day Saints, why so called, 108.
Law, William, a counsellor, 236; denial of a revelation 248; connection with the church, 290; knowledge of polygamy, 291; Smith's charges against, 293; flight from Nauvoo, 295.
Law, Wilson, offices, 290; connection with the Expositor, 291-295; flight from Nauvoo, 295.
Lawrence, H. W., Young's threat about, 560; in "New Movement," 561.
Lee, John D., conversion to Mormonism, 126; on Anthon's statement, 140; Danite

signs, 192; on Missouri plundering, 202, 211; a missionary, 228; on Smith's presidential candidacy, 254; his plural wives, 276, 277; adoption by Young, 289; Mormon faith in Smith, 309; on "secret works," 316 note; on successorship to Smith, 322; on cause of Mormon troubles, 361; on escapes from Utah, 450 note; illustration of blood atonement, 456; part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 520-531; trial and execution, 531, 532.
Legion, Nauvoo, organization of, 237; an army officer on, 239; appearance of, 239; surrender of arms, 299; as sheriffs posse, 336; mobilization of in the "war" in Utah, 484; in Camp Weber, 498; suppression of by Governor Shaffer, 567.
Lewis, Catherine, concerning plural wives, 275 note.
Lewis, Hiel and Joseph, on Smith's first account of the golden plates, 28.
Liberty, Mo., Mormon prisoners in, 212.
Lincoln, Abraham, name scratched by Mormons, 244; vote for Nauvoo charter, 244; signs anti-polygamy bill, 540; Young and G. A. Smith on, 543; petition to, 548; policy toward Mormons, 550.
Little, Jesse C., proposition to federal authorities, 372.
Loba, F., story of escape from Utah, 451.
Lucas, Gen. S. D., march to Far West, 207; terms of surrender, 208.
Lucas, governor of Iowa, on Mormons, 22I.
Lyman, Amasa W., against Rigdon, 317; leader of party across the plains, 394; defiance of federal government, 497; in "New Movement," 561.
Lynch, J., affidavit about Mountain Meadows Massacre, 524.
Lyon's revelation, 274.

M
Mack, Solomon, 8.
Mails, alleged tampering with, 440, 474, 480.
Mansion House, Nauvoo, 241.
"Manuscript Found," history of, and connection with the Mormon Bible, 50-58.
McCullough, Maj. Ben. See Peace Commission.
McDonald of Indiana, on Babbitt's admission, 431.
McDougal, T. A., on Hancock County commission, 337.
McFarland, D., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 523.
McKean, J. B., chief justice of Utah Territory, 567; overruled by Supreme Court, 570; Ann Eliza's divorce suit, 573; Hawkins's sentence, 592,

-------------- 628         INDEX         --------------

McKinstry, Mrs, affidavit of, 52.
McLean, H. H., kills P, P. Pratt, 519.
McLellin, W. E., trial of, 154; revelation about, 274.
McMurdy, S., part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 522 ff.
McMurrin, shooting of, 599.
Mann, S. A., secretary of Utah Territory, 567.
Marcy, Capt. R. B,, John Taylor's letter to, 498; expedition to New Mexico, 499.
Markham, S., affidavit, 271; captain of Utah pioneers, 381.
Marks, W., defends Rigdon, 317; alliance: with Emma, 323.
Marriage, rule in "Book of Commandments," 157.
Marsh, T. B., on church dissensions, 188; leaves the church, 189; affidavit of, 213; excommunicated, 213 note.
Marshals, conflict of authority, 470, 547, 568; Sup. Court decision, 569; Poland Bill, 572.
Matlack, W. E., editor of Hancock Eagle, 345.
Medill, Joseph, visit to Utah, 556.
Melchisedec, priesthood of, 99, 120.
Messenger and Advocate, viii.
Mexico, Mormon settlements in, 614.
Migration to Utah, destination not foreseen, 357, 358, 385-387; explanation to the Mormon people, 358; preparations for, 359; first departures from Nauvoo, 362; march to the Missouri, 363-370; suffering of the expelled remnant, 367-369; the line of march, 369; in camps on the Missouri, 375-378; mortality in the camps, 376, 377; trip of the pioneers, 380-391; the following companies, 392-394,
Miles, John, tried for polygamy, 594.
Millennial Star, vii; predicts destruction of the Union, 543.
Millennium, Disciples' and Mormons' belief, 63; Mormon expectation of, 108.
Milman, on inconsistency, 273 note.
Mining, first discovery of ore in Utah, 550; "Reformers'" views, 564; Emma mine, 570.
Miracles, modern, 5, 6; first Mormon, 103; in Ohio and England, 339; denial by Smith, 139 note; use of, in England, 231.
Missions, compulsory character, 437, 438; of to-day, 611.
Missouri, at time of Mormon arrival, 161, 162; Smith's first visits, 167, 168; Jackson County troubles, 168-184; politics, 198; pillaging and burning, 202; fate of Mormon persecutors, 204; alleged death sentence of Smith and others, 208; Mormon object in, 210; Mormon petition to legislature, 216; departure from the state, 217; Pecuniary losses in, 217. See Clay, Daviess, and Jackson counties, Independence.

Moffat, David, catechism, 116.
Mohammed and Smith, 109 note.
Money-digging, 15, 16, I8-22.
Morgan, James D., in Hancock County, Ill., 343.
Mormon (name), origin of, 107, 108.
Mormon (persons), 91.
Mormon (place), 94.
Mormon Bible. See Bible.
"Mormon, Book of," See Bible.
Mormon, Book of (subdivision of Bible), why written, 91.
Mormon church. See Church.
Mormon Hill, 31.
Mormonism of to-day, 609-618.
Moroni, 31, 92.
Morrill, J. S., anti-polygamy bill, 590.
Morris, Joseph, leader of Morrisites, 540, 541.
Morrisites, origin and punishment, 540, 541; pardon of, 542.
Morton, Senator O. P., influence, 570.
Mosheim's "Ecclesiastical History," Rigdon's knowledge of, 75.
Mountain Meadows Massacre, 517-534.
Mt. Pisgah, camp at, 366; privations at, 369, 370.
Mummies at Kirtland, 139-141, 151.
Murders, church-inspired, 448-451; number in Utah, 453 note; Brassfield, Robinson, and others, 554, 555; apprehension in Salt Lake City, 558.
Murray, E. H., governor of Utah Territory, 573. N
Nauvoo House, Bible MS. in corner-stone, 44; revelation about, 235; description and use, 241.
Nauvoo, Mormon settlement, 223-225; Origin of name, 225; unhealthfulness, 225, 226; growth in population, 227; foreign immigration, 228; Galland's plan for, 234; revelation about, 235; provisions of city charter, 236, 237; Legion authorized, 237; Mansion House, 241; Hall of Seventies, 241; University, 242; powers of Municipal Court, 237, 247; ordinances of City Council, 250; social conditions, 256-261; land sales, 257, 258; charges of thieving examined, 258-261; polygamy practised, 272-280; renewed charges of stealing, 330; hard times in, in 1845, 332; the Neighbor's comments on the repeal of the charter, 333; evacuation of the city by the Mormons, 344-351; "last Mormon war," 347-351;. indictments for counterfeiting, 344; arrival of new citizens, 344; Hancock Eagle issued, 345; terms of final surrender, 349; after the evacuation, 350, 356; completion and description of the

--------------         INDEX       629  --------------

Temple, 353-356; preparations for the move to the Far West, 359; real estate sales, 361.
Neighbor, Nauvoo, 253.
Nephi, Heaven's messenger, 31; substitution of translation from, 45; plates of, 91; a leader, 94.
Nephites, 53, 91-94.
Nevada, settlement of, 472 note.
New Citizens at Nauvoo, 345; position during "last Mormon war," 346.
Newell, Grandison, alleged plot against, 154; rumored warrant for Mormon leaders, 159.
New Jerusalem, promise of, 163.
"New Movement," 561-566.
New York Mormons, vote to move west of the Rockies, 359; Brannan's emigrants to California, 387, 388.

O
Oaths, Danite, 192, 334; Endowment House, 354, 355, 595; against the government, 430.
Oglesby, Gov. R. J., visit to Utah, 556.
Ohio, Mormon move to, revealed, 106; arrival of missionaries, 122; crowds to hear new doctrines, 123. See Kirtland.
Oneida Community, treatment of, 135.
"Oneness," organization, 332.

P
Pack, John, first-major of Utah pioneers, 381. Paddock, A. S., member Utah Commission, 597.
Page, Hiram, testimony regarding the plates, 79; occupation, 85; use of "peek-stone," and rebuke there for, 85.
Page, John E., with Strang, 325.
Papyri, the Kirtland, 140.
Parish, Warren, Smith on, 155; attack on William Smith, 158; responsibility for bank failure, 158.
Parker, Major, in Nauvoo, 347, 348.
Parks, Gen., report to Gen. Atchison, 201.
Parrish murders, 448-450.
Partridge, Edward, first bishop, 120; in Missouri, 167; tarred, 174; opposition to new settlement, 222.
Patriarch, Joseph, Sr., the first, 121; price of blessings, 121; later patriarchs, 121, 398.
Patterson, Pittsburg printer, 51-53.
Patterson, Robert, pamphlet on Spaulding Ms., 55; 67.
Patton, D. W. (Capt. Fear Not), killed at Crooked River, 203.
Peace Commission, on Mormon exodus, 509; appointment of, and instructions; 511; on Gov. Cumming, 512; consultations with Young, 512, 513.
"Peek-stone," Smith's, 20-22; Miss Chase's,

34; Hiram Page's, 85; use in revelations, 111; female rival in Ohio, 154.
Peep o' Day, 562.
Penrose, C. W., on blood atonement, 455 note; author of "Zion," 513.
People's Party, on test oath, 598; dissolution of, 606.
Perpetual Emigrating Fund, 414 note; rate to hand-cart emigrants, 419.
Peterson, Z., ordered west, 72; punishment, 122; arrival in Missouri, 162, 163.
Pettigrew, J. R., member Utah commission, 597.
Phelps, W. W., expectation of millennium, 109 note; printer in Missouri, biography, 167; mission to Gov. Dunklin, 176; on Clay County treatment, 185 ; deposed on charges, 188; testimony against Mormon leaders, 213; Smith on, 215; on origin of polygamy, 272 note; at Expositor trial, 294; statement to the church, 314; against Rigdon at Nauvoo, 315, 317.
Pierce, Pres. F., nominations for governor of Utah Territory, 468, 469; bad judicial appointments, 469.
Pioneers to Utah, origin of, 379; trip across the plains, 380-391; return trip, 392.
Plates, the golden, witnesses to, 78-86; made by Mormon, 91, 92; origin of, 94; plates still buried, 92 note, See Bible.
Poland Bill, 571.
Polk, Pres. J. K., Mormon address to, 357.
Polyandry, 288 note.
Polygamy, charge and denial of, in Ohio, 157; first suggested to Smith, 158; origin of the idea, 272-274; Mormon Bible forbids, 272, 273; early revelations against, 273; practice in Nauvoo, 274-280; ordered by an angel, 275; Lee on, 276; writing of the revelation, 279; Young on original copy, 280; denials and their value, 280 note; Rigdon's innocence in the matter, 280, 281; public announcement, 282; text of revelation, 282-285; Orson Pratt on 285, 286; obligatory character, 286, 553, 597, 615; effect in England, 286, 287; "sealing" 287, 288; Christ an alleged polygamist, 288; denial of the revelation at Nauvoo, 293, 294; view of, in church incorporation act, 440; denial of, by Col. Kane; 460; Judge Brocchus's criticism of, 462; denial of, by J. M. Grant, 465 note; Judge Eckles's charge to the grand jury, 514; Lincoln signs anti-polygamy bill, 540; Gov. Harding on, 546; Colfax's proposition to Young, 552; Deseret News' view, 553; social aspects of, 582-589; Greeley on woman's place in Utah, 584; the division of female converts, 585; a first wife's view, 586; Pres. Cleveland's view of, 588; legislation

-------------- 630         INDEX         --------------

concerning, 590-605; appeal of women against, 594; defiance of the Edmunds law, 597-600; proposed law of 1890, 602; Woodruff's manifesto, 602-609; Roberts case, 604; Utah law of 1901, 605; Mormon fear of a constitutional amendment, 605, 616; anxiety of the church to return to polygamy, 615; modern Mormon women's view of, 615.
Poor, support of the, 146.
Porter, Fitz John, in Mormon "war," 48a.
Post-offices of the Plains, 380.
Potter, G., part in Parrish murders, 448, 449.
Powell, L. W. See Peace Commission.
Pratt, Orson, on Anthon's statement, 40; on Rafinesque's glyphs, 87; on Mormon Bible, 89; sketch of, 89; on Roman Catholic church, 99 note; sermon on future possession of the earth, 110; rebuke by Young, 117; mission to England, 229; professor at Nauvoo, 242; Smith's affair with Mrs. Pratt, 270; effect of spiritual wife doctrine, 270 note; discourse announcing polygamy, 285, 286; on completion of Nauvoo Temple, 353; protest against the banishment of Mormons, 358; camp experience on the trip to the Missouri, 364; observations during the pioneer trip, 382; call for New York emigrants to California, 387; advance march to Great Salt Lake Valley, 389-391; on proposed settlement in Iowa, 393; appeal for mechanics, 403; in charge of English emigration, 424; on first Utah government, 429; charges against the government, 475; requests federal officers to resign, 548.
Pratt, P. P., stories about the golden plates, 26, 36; on Anthon's statement, 40; service to the church, 59; acquaintance with Rigdon, 71; visit to Smith, 71; mission to Ohio, 72; Smith's revealing, III; trial of, 154; rebellious spirit, 155; censure of Smith and Rigdon, 157; arrival in Missouri, 162, 163; on Jackson County "mob," 172; asks for a warrant, 178; on tithing, 194; surrender at Far West, 208; commitment, 214; mission to England, 229; On fate of Smith's murderers, 308; sustains Young at Nauvoo, 315, 317; Emma's church council, 323; an migration to the Far West, 358; departure from Nauvoo, 362 note; selects site for camp at Mt. Pisgah, 365; conveyer of BattaIion fund, 372; life in Winter Quarters, 377; on Brannan, 387; leader of the "first migration," 392; early view of Salt Lake City, 398; privations in Salt Lake City, 399; glowing report to England, 401; his death, 519.
Preface to first edition Mormon Bible, 45.
Prentiss, B. M., in Hancock County, Ill., 343.

Presidency, First, establishment of, 120; reason for, 155.
Presidential candidacy, Smith's, 250-255.
Priests, duties of, 101.
Prisoners, Mormon, in Missouri, 211, 212, 2I5.
Prophet, Smith's authorization as, 103.
Prophet, in New York, 334; Brannan editor, 387.
Proselyting, origin of, 131; progress in the United States, 228, 229; in England, 229-233; Young's plan, 329; to-day's system, 611, 612.

Q
Quails, visitation of, 368.
Quincy, Ill., arrival of Smith, 216; welcome to Mormons, 221; anti-Mormon meeting, 338; reply to Mormons, 339; peace meeting, 349.
Quincy, Josiah, visit to Nauvoo, 140 note; Smith's view of himself as a prophet, 266; on Smith's future influence, 618.
Quorums, 120.

R
Rafinesque's glyphs, 87.
Ramsey, A., member of Utah commission, 597.
Rawlins, Sec. J. A., view of Utah situation, 567.
Rawlins, J. L., enabling act, 607.
Reed, Amos, secretary of Utah Territory, 550.
"Reformation, The" (1856), its beginning, aims, and doings, 441-447.
"Reformation, The." See "New Movement."
Reid, H. P., counsel for Smith, 299.
Reid, L. H., chief justice of Utah Territory, 467.
Remick, Smith's dealings with, 264.
Reorganized Church, title to Kirtland Temple and legal status, 160; claim to Temple lot at Independence, Mo., 183 note; organization and membership, 223, 224; in Utah, 562-564.
Republican National Convention of 1856, on polygamy, 476.
Resurrection, Smith's view, 116.
Return, 44.
Revelations, Joseph Smith, Jr.'s, about the golden plates, 30-32; plates to be secret, 38; Harris's wickedness, 43; directing Harris, 49; new translation of Scriptures ordered, 68-71; to P. P. Pratt, et al., 71; concerning exhibition of the plates, 79; concerning Cowdery's honesty, 80; Harris's talkativeness, 79; form of church government, 100, 101; Whitmer on, 101; about other revealers, 101; authorization to Cowdery and its results, 101, 102; Smith to be the leader and prophet, 102; requiring re-baptism, 103;

--------------         INDEX       631  --------------

for Smith's support, 104; Rigdon"s authority, 106; move to Ohio ordered, 106; speedy millennium, 109; how revelations were received by Smith, 111; about Vienna Jaques, 111; publication of revelations, 112, 113; failures of, 113, 114; number of, by years, 114; Young's refusal to reveal, 115; imitators of Smith, 34, 85, 115, 154; about First Presidency and other offices, 120; Stakes, 120; elders to travel, 131; Smith's authority and support, 132; Rigdon's support, I32; rebuke of Rigdon, 133; westward move and New Jerusalem, 142; consecration of property, 145; about debts, 146, 164; Salem, Mass., trip, 147; New Jerusalem and Zion promised, 163; Saints' right to Zion, 164, 165; site of Zion, 166; Zion not to be moved, 179; army of Zion, promises not fulfilled, 180, 181; permitting murder, 190; tithing, 193, 194; Adam-ondi-Ahman, 195; excusing abandonment of Zion, 224; about Nauvoo, 235, 236; check on Smith's revelations, 256; against polygamy, 273; about McLellin, 274; the revelation of polygamy, kept secret, 276; promulgation of the revelation in Utah, 285; effect in England, 286; about Brigham Young, 329; Brigham Young on, 329, 435; Young's only revelation, 379; by Joseph Morris, 540.
Reynolds, George, conviction of polygamy, 592.
Rich, C. C., one of the Twelve, 330.
Richards, F. D., one of the Twelve, 330; sufferings of family during the migration, 364; passes hand-cart emigrants, 421; denounced by Young, 426.
Richards, Willard, plan for flight from Nauvoo, 299; account of the Smiths' murder, 305; appeal for peace, 313; statement to the church, 314; Young's counsellor, 330; reply to Hancock County commission, 340; leader of party across the plains, 394.
Richmond, Mo., Mormon prison, 211.
Rigdon, Nancy, testimony for Mormons, 214; Smith's attempt with, 270.
Rigdon, Sidney, Smith's early acquaintance with, 16, 22, 23, 43, 67; Mrs. Davison on, 52; denial by, 53; John Hyde, Jr., on, 59; sketch of in Smith's autobiography, 59; early church connections, 59-61; changed religious views, 60; religious temperament, 61; jealousy of the Campbells, 63; foreknowledge of the Mormon Bible, 65, 66; knowledge of Spaulding's Ms., 66, 67; share in translation of Scriptures, 68-71; conversion to Mormon faith, 71-73; use and knowledge of the "Everlasting Gospel," 74-77; his learning, 75; arraignment of Cowdery, et al., 81, 82;

Prof. Whitsitt's view, 92 note; originator of church government, 101; visit to Palmyra, 103; authority revealed, 106; in First Presidency, 12o; on Cowdery, 122; effect of his conversion, 123; his plan, 123 note; revelation about his support, 132; rebuked by Smith, 132; tarred and feathered, 133-135; tried and deprived of license, 136; seeing the Lord, 138; miracle working, 139; share of Kirtland property, 146-152; Smith's contempt for, 153; last appearance at Kirtland, 159; charge of cowardice, 168; welcome at Far West, 187; "salt sermon," 196; with volunteers for Daviess County, 198; studies law, 200 note; surrendered at Far West, 208; a prisoner, 211, 212; trial of, 212-215; appeal to the American people, 214; escape from prison, 215; letters of introduction, 221; opposes land purchase, 222; signs Hotchkiss's note, 224; one of Smith's counsellors, 236; order concerning Legion, 237; on Bennett, 238; attorney-at-law and postmaster, 238; professor at Nauvoo, 242; secures opinion for Smith, 246; named for Vice President, 253; Smith's complaints against, in Nauvoo, 263; innocence about polygamy, 272, 273, 278, 280, 281; course after Smith's death, 314, 315; trial and expulsion from the church, 316-318; his Church of Christ in Pennsylvania, 318, 319; remarkable visions there, 318, 319; last days in Friendship, N.Y., 319; alleged mental unsoundness, 318; refusal to rejoin the Mormons, 319, 320 note; interesting letter from, 320.
Roberts, B. H., refused seat in Congress, 604.
Robinson, Ebenezer, sketch of, 44; second copy of the Mormon Bible, 44; on Salem trip, I48; on Danites, 190; on tithing, 193; on Rigdon's "salt sermon," 197; prisoner in Missouri, 211; taught polygamy, 277, 278.
Robinson, G. W., surrender of at, Far West, 208; on Nancy Rigdon scandal, 271.
Robinson, J. King, murder of, 554
Rockwell, Porter P., alleged assassination of Gov. Boggs, 245; acquittal, 250; Lieut. Worrell's murder, 336; part in Aikin murders, 451; warns Young of the approach of troops, 483; indicted for treason, 500; at peace conference, 513; Shoots one of Gov. Dawson's assailants, 539; indicted for murder, 567.
Roman Catholic church, Mormon view of, 99 note.
Rosa, Dr. Storm, on Rigdon, 66.
Rowe, H., on spiritual wife doctrine, 287.
Ruddock, S. A., claim to discovery, 395.
Rudolph, Z., recollections of Rigdon, 67.
Ruskin's religious views, 127.

-------------- 632         INDEX         --------------

Ryder, Symonds, conversion, 123, 126; on tarring of Smith, 134,
Ryland, Judge, advice to Mormons, 178, 182.

S
Salem, Mass., trip, 147.
Salt Lake City, laid out, 397; name selected, 398; first cabins, 398; land division, 398; census in 1848, 398, 402; scarcity of food, 399, 404, 408; mills, bridges, and schools, 402; plans for manufactories, 402; picture of, in 1849, 404; bargains from gold seekers, 406; duties levied, 431; city charter, 438; bishops' courts, 439; filth and abomination, 442; entrance of Gentile merchants, 557; Mormon household arrangements, 583; Chamber of Commerce organized, 601.
"Salt sermon," by Rigdon, 196-198.
Sandwich Islands Spaulding Ms., 56.
San Pete affair, 457.
School of the Prophets, 564.
Schouler, James, on Joseph Smith, 609.
Scott, Walter, associate of Rigdon and the Campbells, 60; on millennium, 63, 64.
Scott, Gen. Winfieid, in Mormon "war," 481.
Scriptures, Smith's and Rigdon's translation of, 68-71.
"Sealing," doctrine of, 287, 288.
Seer, Orson Pratt's, on Roman Catholic church, 99 note; on the federal government, 475; Young's authority in plural marriages, 586, 587.
Sermon, first Mormon, 103; Rigdon's "salt," 196-198.
Seventies, Quorums of, 120.
Shaffer, J. W., governor of Utah Territory, 567; suppression of the Nauvoo legion, 567.
Shakespeare a plagiarist, 96.
Sharp, T. C., editor, indictment of, 308; incitement to hostilities, 346.
Shaver, L., associate justice of Utah, 467.
Sheen, I., memorial against admission of Deseret, 430.
Sherman, W. H., in" New Movement," 561.
Sherman, Gen. W. T., warning to Young, 554.
Signal, Warsaw, appeal to non-Mormons, 338; declares war, 346.
Sinclair, C. E., associate justice of Utah, 478.
Singleton, Col., in command of posse, 347.
Slater, Nelson, book, "Fruits of Mormonism," 440.
Slavery, Mormon views, 172 note.
SmaIling, Cyrus, on Kirtland Bank, 149; Smith on, 156.
Smith, Alexander, visit to Salt Lake City, 563.

Smith, Alfred, Gladdenite, 436.
Smith, Capt., of Carthage Grays, 303.
Smith, David Hyrum, visit to Utah, 563.
Smith, Don Carlos, against polygamy, 277.
Smith, Emma, married to Joseph, Jr., 24; connection with the golden plates, 28; married to Bidamon, 44; scribe to Joseph, 45, l02; opposition to polygamy, 279, 280; on the prophet's burial place, 307; plan for church government, 323; reported intended exposure, 323; Young's opinion of, 563.
Smith family, origin, 8; character, 11, 13, 14.
Smith, F. M., on the prophet's burial place, 308.
Smith, George A., mission to England, 229; on the migration from Nauvoo, 362 note; proposed settlement in Iowa, 393; part in Mountain Meadows Massacre, 528, 532; on Lincoln, 543; petition to Congress, 591.
Smith, Hyrum, part in publication of the Bible, 47; testimony regarding the plates, 79; conversion of, 100; early desire to preach, 100 note; letter to Missouri, 155; on Bennett, 238; patriarch, 248; revelation in favor of Hoge, 248; on thieving at Nauvoo, 259, 260; appeal for Rigdon, 264 note; denounces polygamy, 276; teaches it, 278, 291; reads revelation to Emma, 279; defence of Laws, 291; candidate for legislature, 293; charges against W. Law, 293; denial of polygamy revelation, 293; at Expositor trial, 293, 294; plan for flight, 299; story of his murder, 301-306.
Smith, John, patriarch, 398.
Smith, Joseph, Jr., "History of" (autobiography), vii; lack of education, 12, 19, 48, 89; two pictures of, in early life, 12, 13; untruthfulness, 14; a money-digger, 16, 18-22; first trip to Pennsylvania, 16; introduction to crystal-gazing, 16, 18-20; "peek-stone," discovery of and use, 20-22; elopement with Emma Hale, 24; confession to Peter Ingersol, 24; his account of the revelation and delivery of the golden plates, 30-32; lapse from virtue, 30; journey with plates to Pennsylvania, 36; translation of plates, 37; alarm over theft of translated pages, 42; "revelations" about Harris, 43, 49; substitute translation, 45; removal to Whitmer's house, 46; publication of Bible, 47-49; Albert Chandler's recollections of, 48; how associated with Rigdon, 46, 47; Pres. Fairchild on, 68; share in new translation of Scriptures, 68-71; his coming foretold, 70; abuse of Harris, 84; translation of Kinderhook plates, 87; authorized to baptize, etc., 99; ordained, 100; early leadership, 101, 102; charges against, dismissed, 104; support ordered, 104; on the word "Mormon," 108; revelations, how

--------------         INDEX       633  --------------

received, 111; illustrations of failures, 113, 114; number of, by years, 114; reckless use of, 114; on Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, 116; on resurrection, 116; "articles of faith," 118; baptism of the dead, 118; in First Presidency, 120; goes to Ohio, 122; restrains Kirtland converts, 130; Supreme authority, 132; to have a house, 132; rebukes Rigdon, 132; tarred and feathered, 133-135; defeats Rigdon, 136; on seeing the Lord, 138; miracle working, 139; denial of miraculous power, 139 note; translation of "Book of Abraham," 140; linguistic accomplishments tested, 141; westward move ordered, 142; Ohio business enterprises, 143-151; Young's picture of, as a storekeeper, 143; plans Kirtland Temple, 145; share of Kirtland property, 146; Salem, Mass., trip, 147; Kirtland Bank, 148-152; lack of dignity, 153; contempt for Rigdon, 153; plot against Newell, 154; picture of his flock, 155; moral character attacked, 104, 156, 157; denial of polygamy, 157, 272-274; self-defence at Kirtland, 159; flight from Kirtland, 159; first visits to Missouri, 166-168; charge of cowardice, 168; direction to Saints in Jackson County, 176, 179; with Army of Zion, 180, 181; on the drowning of non-Mormons, 182; arrival at Far West, 187; advice looking to Danites, 190; proposed salary, 193; early mistakes in Missouri, 195; with volunteers to Daviess County, 198; arrest of, at Far West, 199; studies law, 200 note; to drive out non-Mormons, 201; "Fur Company" ordered, 202; appeal for revenge, 203; surrendered at Far West, 208; a prisoner, 211, 212; hearing of, 212-215; Marsh on his ambition, 213; revelations and epistles written in prison, 215; escape to Illinois, 216; selects new place of settlement, 223; on land purchases, 224; trouble with Hotchkiss, 225; deception of immigrants, 225; revelation about Nauvoo, 235, 236; again declared head of the church, 236; order concerning Legion, 237; on Bennett, 238; lieutenant general, 239; opposition to Van Buren, 242, 243; advice to Mormon voters, 244; alleged order for Gov. Boggs's assassination, 245 note; arrest on this charge, 246; concealment and proposed flight, 246; rearrest and discharge, 246; another indictment and arrest, 247; released by his own court, 247; betrayal of Walker, 248; correspondence with Clay and Calhoun, 250, 251; Views on national politics, 252; named for President, 253; campaign work for him in the East, 254; monopoly as land agent, 257, 258; on thieving, 259; troubles in Nauvoo, 26a; complaints against Rigdon, 263; appeal to

bankruptcy act, 264 ; dealing with Remick, 264; city specie payment ordinance, 265; secular, pursuits, 265-267; view of himself as a prophet, 266; Satan's aims, 266; check on his revelations, 266; prediction of the War of the Rebellion, 267; falling out with Bennett, 268-270; scandal about Mrs. Pratt and Nancy Rigdon, 270; quarrel with F, M. Higbee, 271; marries Eliza R. Snow, 275; polygamy ordered by an angel, 275; his plural wives, 275 note, 279 note; denial of polygamy, 276; references to the practice, 278; writing of the revelation, 279; praise of the Laws, 290, 291; indicted for adultery and perjury, 290 note; view of hell, 292; method of securing spiritual wives, 292; political aims, 293; explanation of the revelation about polygamy, 294; action against the Expositor, 293, 296; writ secured by Expositor owners, 295; surrender to Gov. Ford, 298, 300; plan for flight, 299; story of his murder, 301-306; trial of the murderers, 301 note, 308; funeral and burial place, 307, 308; fate of some of his murderers, 308; review of his character, 309-312; personal appearance, 310; proposal in Utah to drop him and his Bible, 309; views on morality, 310; death masks, 311; his sons, 322 note; Young's fidelity to, 328-329; plan for a westward move, 338; divided Mormon views of, 433.
Smith, Joseph, Sr., career and reputation, in Vermont, 10; occupation in New York State, 11; money-digger, 15; dowser, 15; pedler of the new Bible, 49; testimony regarding the plates, 79; patriarch, 121; flight from Ohio, 121 note; causes a fight at Kirtland, 158.
Smith, Joseph, III; right to succeed the prophet, 322; head of Reorganized Church, 323.
Smith, Joseph F., secures Clayton's affidavit, 279
Smith, Lot, burning of the government wagon trains; 489, 490; in charge of government cavalry, 540.
Smith, Lucy, "History," vii; family, 8; characteristics, 9; religious views, 25; statements about the golden plates, spectacles, and breastplate, 32-34; on Harris's early connection with the Bible enterprise, 36; on Harris's punishment, 43; claim to have seen the plates, 86; on Rigdon, 137; on Kirtland church fight, 158; plea for prophet's son, 322; addresses a conference, 322; her death, 323.
Smith, "Mother." See Lucy.
Smith, "Peg Leg," information to the pioneers, 385.
Smith, Samuel H., testimony regarding the

-------------- 634         INDEX         --------------

plates, 79; conversion of, 100; appeal for peace at Nauvoo, 313.
Smith, William, attacked by Parish, 158; elected to Illinois legislature, 245; patriarch, 334; cut off from the church, 335; his "proclamation," 335; last days, 335; memorial against admission of Deseret, 430.
Smoot, A. O., informs Young of approach of troops, 482.
Snow, Eliza, on church fight at Kirtland, 258; marriage to Smith, 275.
Snow, Erastus, one of the Twelve, 330; first sight of Great Salt Lake Valley, 390, 391.
Snow, Lorenzo, on proselyting in England, 230; on Smith's presidential candidacy, 254; taught polygamy, 274; his plural marriages, 275; one of the Twelve, 330; on Mormon destination, 358; a party at Mt. Pisgah, 370; elected president of the church, 601 note.
Snow, Bishop Warren, part in San Pete affair, 457.
Snow, Z., associate justice of Utah Territory, 458.
Songs, Mormon, 498.
Spaulding manuscript, 50-58; history of manuscript found in the Sandwich Islands, 56-58; how incorporated in Mormon Bible, 66-68.
Spaulding, Solomon, 50-55.
Speaking with tongues, 138.
Spencer, Orson, professor at Nauvoo, 242; criticized by Young, 426.
Spiritual wives, Bennett's charges, 270; at Nauvoo, 274; doctrine of "sealing," 287; Smith's method of securing, 292.
Stakes, origin of name, 120.
Stansbury, Capt. H., on Young's dictatorship, 438.
Stanton, Sec. E. M., appeal to, 539; places Utah under military supervision, 544.
State, admission of Utah, 606-608.
Stealing. See Thieving.
Stenhouse, T. B. H., sketch of, 86; on Mormon Bible, 89; on proselyting in Europe, 232 note ; Joseph Smith's widows, 279 note; polyandry, 288; hand-cart victims, 425; illustration of blood atonement, 456; on Cumming's reception, 508, 509; on Mountain Meadows Massacre, 518 note, 532, 534 note; on Gov. Dawson's punishment, 538; on Morrisite tragedy, 541 note; apprehension in Salt Lake City, 558; in "New Movement," 561; vile assault on him and his wife, 565 note; on Young, 576, 577; his second marriage, 587.
Steptoe, Col. E. J., arrival in Utah, 467; why he declined the governorship, 468, 469; saves Young from arrest, 549.

Stewart of Nevada, influence of, 570.
Stiles, G. P., associate justice of Utah Territory, 467; effort to sustain federal marshals, 470; burning of his papers, 471; return to the East and report, 471.
Stoal, Josiah, Smith's employer, 16.
Stoddard, Calvin, call to preach, 105.
Stokes, W., arrest of Lee, 533.
Stout, H., indictment for murder, 569.
Strang, j. J., emissaries to Europe, 84, 325; biography, 324; claim to Smith's successorship, 324; his church in Wisconsin, 324, 326.
Strong of Pennsylvania, on Babbitt's admission, 431.
Struble, introduces anti-polygamy bill of 1890, 602.

T
Tabernacle in Salt Lake City, 408, 409.
Tarring and feathering of Smith and Rigdon, 113-135.
Taylor, John, mission to England, 229; editor at Nauvoo, 253; wears endowment robe at Nauvoo, 278; plan for flight from Nauvoo, 299; account of the Smiths' murder, 305; wounded in Carthage jail, 306; appeal for peace at Nauvoo, 313; statement to the church, 314; against Rigdon, 317; estimate of the migration, 365; truth about the Battalion, 373; misstatements to English converts, 411, 412; biography, 412 note; associate justice, State of Deseret, 429; letter to Capt. Marcy, 496; indicted for treason, 500; denunciation of the territorial officers, 548; rebuke by Judge Drake, 548; discussion with Colfax, 556; petition to Congress, 591.
Teachers, duty of, 101.
Teachings, Mormon, 115-120.
Teas, J, B., land at Commerce, Ill., 223.
Temples, baptism for the dead in, 119; at Kirtland, 145, 160; at Independence, Mo., consecrated, 167; corner-stone laying at Far West, 196, 218; at Nauvoo, revelation about, 235; description and cost, 240; dedication, 353; destruction of, 355, 356; site in Salt Lake City selected, 397; others in Utah, 411.
Territory. See Utah.
Texas, Wight's church in, 326.
Thieving, in Missouri, 202; charges of, at Nauvoo, church admissions, 258-261; charge against Strang's followers, 325; renewed Hancock County complaints, 331; 337; Young's charges of, in Utah, 441, 442.
Thomas, A. L., governor of Utah Territory, 573; on church's position regarding polygamy, 601.
Thomas, L. L., order to Young, 539.

--------------         INDEX       635  --------------

Times and Seasons, vii.
Tithing, origin of, 192, 193; income from, 193; rule regarding, 194; Young's handling of the fund, 576, 577.
Titus, John, chief justice of Utah Territory, 550; Mormon appeal to, 559.
Townsend, Rev. Jesse, Smith as viewed by his neighbors, 106.
Trail, the Mormon, 382.
Translation of the golden plates, 37, 42-46; second copy made, 44; at Whitmer's house, 46; alleged error, 85; of the Scriptures, 68-71.
Tribune, Salt Lake, founders, 566.
Trumbull, Lyman, visit to Utah, 556; use of his influence, 570; vote against Frelinghuysen Bill, 571.
Trustee in trust for the church, Young's selection, 473.
Tucker, Pomeroy, "Origin and Progress of Mormonism," viii; Smith's occupations, 11; picture of Smith, 12; Rigdon's early visits to Smith, 43, 67; publication of Mormon Bible, 47.
Tullidge, E. W., "History of Salt Lake City," viii; land rights, 164 note, 398 note; on hand-cart tragedy, 426; on land titles, 472; attitude of the church toward the federal government, 544; in the "New Movement" 561; Young's purpose, 568; outside influences, 570; view of the church character, 617.
Turner, Prof. J. B, on Mormon teachings, 127.
Twelve Apostles, authorized, 120; at head of the church, 315; reestablish the First Presidency, 330.

U
"Underground" escapes from the Edmunds law, 599.
Underwood of Kentucky, presents anti-Mormon memorial, 430.
United States Supreme Court decision, on jury law and prosecutor, 569; advance hints of, 570; regarding anti-polygamy laws, 593; regarding church property, 602.
University of Nauvoo, 242; of the State of Deseret, 440.
Urim and Thummim, delivery to Smith, 32; nature of, 33; Smith deprived of, 43; how made, 94.
Utah, pioneers' trip to, 379, 391; first migration and crops, 391; the following companies, 392-394; first white explorers, 395, 396; early crop failures, 398, 400; early rural settlements, 403; first Mormon government, 428; first state convention and constitution, 429; admitted as a territory, 432; Mormons forbidden to leave, 446,

447, 505 note; first territorial election, 458; Mormon election law, 467; rival courts and officers, 470; law about testimony and citations, 470; legislature sustains Young, 499; race population, 582; Utah commission, 397; vetoed law of 1901, 605; admitted as a state, 6o6-608; parties in, 606; the state constitution, 607; census, 610.

V
Van Buren, Pres. Martin, Smith's Hostility to, 242.
Van Dusen, I. McGee, description of endowment ceremony, 353.
Van Vliet, Capt. Stewart, mission to Salt Lake City, 485.
Van Zile, district attorney, trial of R. T. Benton, 541; trial of Miles, 594.
Vanghn, V M., secretary and acting governor of Utah Territory, 567, 568.
"Voice of Warning," 127.
Voree Herald, 325.

W
Wade, Ben, on the Mormons, 557; anti-polygamy bill, 591.
Waite, C. B., chief justice of Utah, 540; his offence to the Mormons and what followed, 547, 548; resigns, 550.
Waite, Mrs. C. B., on Steptoe's case, 468; on Gov. Dawson's punishment, 538; biography, 450 note; examples of polygamy, 586, 587.
Walker Brothers' experiences, 558, 560.
Walker-Hoge incident, 245-249.
Wallingford Community, treatment of, 135.
"War, the last Mormon" in Illinois, 347-351.
"War," the Mormon, in Utah, 476-515; the federal force, 481; instructions to the federal commander, 482; Young's proclamation, 486; Young's letter to the federal commander, 487; Mormon plan of campaign, 489; burning of wagon trains, 489, 490; preparation for spring campaign, wasteful contracts, 500; causes of the back-down, 504; exodus of Mormons, 509; the terms of peace, 514; Johnston's march to Salt Lake City, 515; departure of troops from the territory, 537.
Ward, the emigration scandal, 410.
Warren, Major W. B., on Hancock County commission, 337; in command in Hancock County, 343; advice to Mormons, 345; weekly reports from Nauvoo, 345.
Warsaw, Ill., anti-Mormon feeling, 297; regiment's share in the Smiths' murder, 304; flight of inhabitants, 313; Signal's appeal to non-Mormons, 338; protest against the

-------------- 636         INDEX         --------------

"burnings," 343; appeal for new settlers, 352; Mormon real estate sales, 361.
Wasp, Nauvoo, 253.
Weed, Thurlow, on Mormon Bible, 47.
Weller, John B., on Robinson murder, 555.
Wells, "Gen." D. H., disloyal utterances, 461; Order to the Legion, 484; to the federal commander, 488; his plan of campaign, 489; indicted for treason, 500; order from Gov. Cumming, 536; assails federal government, 543; request of Gov. Shaffer, 567; indicted for unlawful cohabitation and murder, 568, 569; refusal to testify, 594.
Wells, Gov. H. M., veto of the act of 1901, 605.
Wentworth, John, Smith's letter to, 90, 118; presents anti-Mormon petition, 431.
Wesley, John, belief in the miraculous, 129.
West, C. W., governor of Utah Territory, 573.
Westward movement of church, first step, 102.
White, A., land at Commerce, Ill., 223.
Whitmer, Christian, testimony regarding the plates, 79.
Whitmer, David, description of the translation of the plates, 42; miraculous manifestation to, 46; on Rigdon, 75, 101; expulsion from Far West, 81; later years, 83; on Smith's ignorance, 89; Smith's method of revealing, 111; the publication of the "Book of Doctrine and Covenants," 112, 113; failure of a revelation, 113; charges against, 154; expulsion, 188; plan to make him president of the church, 328.
Whitmer, Jacob, testimony regarding the plates, 79.
Whitmer, John, testimony regarding the plates, 79; failure as historian, 114; deposed, 188; testimony against Mormon leaders, 213.
Whitmer, Peter and family, 46, 83, 85; first elder, 100.
Whitmer, Peter, Jr., ordered West, 72; testimony regarding the plates, 79; arrival in Missouri, 162, 163.
Whiney, N. K., associate justice, State of Deseret, 429.
Whitney, O. F., "History of Utah," viii; on Gov. Dawson's punishment, 539.
Whitsitt, Prof., against Pres. Fairchild, 68; analysis of the Mormon Bible, 92 note.
Whittlers at Nauvoo, 261.
Whitton, Bridge, connection with the Kinderhook plates, 87.
Wight, Lyman, arrest at Far West, 199; surrendered at Far West, 208; commitment, 214; his church in Texas, 326.
Wilcox, Phineas, disappearance in Nauvoo, 334.

Wiley, Robert, on the Kinderhook plates, 86, 87.
Williams, F. G., trial of, 154.
Willie, captain of hand-cart emigrants, 423.
Wilson, C. C., chief justice Utah Territory, 567.
Wilson, Gen. R., operations in Daviess County, Mo., 210-211.
Winter, Rev. John, recollections of Rigdon, 66.
Winter Quarters, 363; settlement of, 377; removal to east side of the Missouri, 393.
Wisconsin, recommended to the Mormons, 186; Strang's church in, 324-326.
Witnesses of the golden plates, 78-86.
"Wolf Hunters," Young's, 452.
Woodruff, Wilford, first visit to Smith, 153; mission to England, 229; on the work there, 230; report of the conference with the Peace Commission, 513; elected president of the church, 601; manifesto about polygamy, 602-604; visits from the spirits of Smith and Young, 604.
Woods, G. L., governor of Utah Territory, 568; assertion of authority, 573.
Woods, J. W., counsel for Smith, 299.
Woodward, Judge D., on Father Smith, 10.
Wooton, F, H., secretary of Utah Territory, 537.
Worrell, Lieut., murder of, 336.

Y
Young, Ann Eliza, divorce suit, 572, 573.
Young, Brigham, suppression of Mother Smith's "History," vii; on Smith and the Mormon Bible, 98; refusal to reveal, 114; doctrine of Adam, 116; rebuke of O. Pratt, 117; on persecutions, 136; Smith as a storekeeper, 143; Kirtland Bank, 149; admission about Danites, 192; on tithing, 193, 194; flight to Quincy, Ill., 216; night visit to Far West, 218; president of the Twelve, 218; Smith's miraculous healing, 227; mission to England, 229; Smith's military rank, 237 note; married to Smith's widows, 275 note; original copy of the revelation about polygamy, 280; his first feeling about polygamy, 280 note; spiritual wife doctrine, 287; adopts Lee, 289; on Smith's burial place, 307; faith in Smith, 309; course after Smith's death, triumph over Rigdon, 314-318; promise about the prophet's son, 322; on Mother Smith, 323; biography, 327; joins Mormon church, 327; first two wives, 326, 327; preaching and working at his trade, 328; fidelity to Smith, 328, 329; revelation about, 329; on revelations, 329, 435; home missionaries sent out, 329; president of the church, 330; dishonesty

--------------         INDEX       637  --------------

of elders, 332; reply to Quincy committee, 339; reply to Hancock County commission, 340; address to Pres. Polk, 357; on migration to the far West, 359; rebuke to counterfeiters, 360; departure from Nauvoo, 362; address to the camp, 362; arrival on the Missouri, 367; misrepresentation to the English, 377; carpenter work, 377; his only revelation, 379; lieutenant general of Utah pioneers, 381; visit to Fort Laramie, 383; hears about Utah, 386; illness on the way, 389; return trip, 392; leads party across the plains, 394; first Sunday service in the valley, 396; land assignments, 396; on further explorations, 397; selects site of Salt Lake City Temple, 397; appeal to workmen, 403; denunciation of gold seekers, 407; order to Saints in Europe, 423; responsibility far hand-cart tragedy, 428, 425-427; plan for political independence, 428; governor of State of Deseret, 429; J. D. Grant's picture of, 433; his leadership in Utah, 433; spokesman of God, 434; dictatorship illustrated, 434-438; extracts from discourses, 435, 436, 437, 441, 443, 468, 475, 484, 497; denunciation of Gladdenites, 436; appropriation of a canon, 437; on property rights, 437; to his creditors, 437; on bishops' courts and bishops, 489, 442; trustee of the church, 440; charges of profanity, stealing, etc., 442, 443; threats of punishment, 443, 444; surprising confessions, 446; warning to would-be fugitives, 446, 497; responsibility for Parrish and Aikin murders, 448-451; his "Wolf Hunters," 452; on human sacrifice, 455, 456; first governor of Utah Territory, 458; Kane's part in his selection, 459; attack on Pres. Z. Taylor, 462, 463; denunciation of Judge Brocchus, 462-466; delayed election proclamation, 464; determination to be governor, 468, 475; treatment of Steptoe, 469; reply to Judge Stiles, 472; Mormon land conveyed to, 473; announces the approach of the federal troops, 483; to keep out the troops, 484; threat to "take to the mountains," 485; proclamation to the people of Utah, 486; letter to the federal commander, 48; letters to Col. Alexander, 494, 495; defiance

of federal government, 497, 549; indicted for treason, 500; interview with Kane, 502; offer of provisions refused, 503; reasons for a back-down, 504; introduction of Gov. Cumming in the Tabernacle, 598; conference with the Peace Commission, 512, 513; ultimatum about the troops, 514; snub to Gov. Cumming, 516; responsibility for Mountain Meadows Massacre, 527-532; proposed arrest for counterfeiting, 536, 537; authorized from Washington to raise troops, 539; nominated for governor of the State of Deseret, 540; scoff at Pres. Lincoln, 542; predicts ruin of the government, 544; denunciation of federal officers, 548; how arrest prevented, 549; interview with Colfax, 552; interview with Lyman Trumbull, 556; Opposition to Gentile merchants, 557, 558, 560; treatment of Walker Brothers, 558; connection with Z. C. M. I., 559, 560; attacked in Utah Magazine, 563; trouble with laborers, 563; interview with the prophet's sons, 563; indicted for unlawful cohabitation and murder, 568, 569; Ann EIiza's divorce suit, 572, 573; death of, 574; estimate of his character, 574-581; his wealth, 576-579; fee for divorces, 577; account with the church, 578, 579; his will, 579; list at his wives, 579, 580; his houses, 580; warning to dissatisfied wives, 584; family life, 588; view of the church's extension, 617.
Young, Emmeline A., suit against Brigham's executors, 579.
Young, Joseph A., succor to hand-cart emigrants, 423.

Z
Zarahemla, 91, 94.
Zion, city and land of, 163; right of Saints to; 163-165, 169; warning against a rush to, 165; location and founding of city, 166, 167; site of Temple consecrated, 167; not to be moved, 179; abandonment excused, 224.
Zion Cooperative Mercantile Institution, incorporation and object, 559; business statistics, 560 note; influence in politics, 571 note.

go back to: page 1

back to the top of this web-page